Advice needed: Storage server zfs and iscsi with win server

ian_stagib

n00b
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
9
Hi everyone

So I'm trying to plan out the next roadmap for my storage server. I've managed thus far to build it up as such:

Norco RPC-4224
24 x 2Tb drives (mostly seagate LP's)
1 x 250gb plain ol' sata drive for OS / VM's
2 x Intel Xeon L5520 (2.26ghz quad w H/T)
Intel S5520HC motherboard
24Gb ddr3
Corsair AX1200
Areca 1261ml
extra ibm hba

Current config:
Esxi 5.1
VM1 - Windows Server 2012 (runs downloader programs for now, used to manage storage before I changed to zfs)
VM2 - Openindiana: 2 x 12 drive zfs raidz2 pools placed into one vdev (both expansion cards were passed through to this)

The future plan and current idea (please comment on this):
I'm thinking of wanting to use openindiana to manage the drives. Have a big zfs pool there. I want to create an iscsi target (preferably one big iscsi target) on it and pass it to windows. Then windows can install ReFS on it and go from there

so some things i need to figure out:

1) how the iscsi target on openindiana would work. is it possible to have one big one? or must i make multiples? Can it expand without data loss when the pool grows?

2) does zfs on openindiana still scrub the data in an iscsi volume

3) would ReFS allow for expanding a drive capacity (just like ntfs did before) in this scenario

The reasons for my current thinking are:

- Windows is quicker and easier to set up basic shares and users
- SMB performance is better
- ReFS can handle long filenames now
- ZFS (if point #2 is true) could handle the data integrity

Anyway, thanks for any input guys. I hope this thread helps someone else out there
 
If you only need a filer on ESXi, your setup is over complicated.
I would also not expect any speed advantages of 2012 in this setup compared to a Solaris filer.

In my own setup I use a Windws AD server for users with client licences for all users. Despite that
all my filer and backup systems are OmniOS or on the switch from OI to Omni. (Former all Windows)
with excellent performance, easy share handling and user managed by AD.
(Although Solaris user management is ok for not too many users).

I would skip the Windows filer and use Solaris on barebone. You will have better uptime and easier handling,
ZFS snap access via previous version, full ACL and Windows SID support and less needed reboots due to Windows
security updates. I would use appliance software with Web-UI like napp-it or Nexenta and a mirrorred rpool.
I would also opt for OmniOS stable as base.

Beside that:
- read about Comstar http://docs.oracle.com/cd/E23824_01/html/821-1459/fnnop.html
From Windows view, a target is like a local disk with fixed size.
- scrub is a pool feature independent from usage, works with iSCSI
- ReFS is something like ZFS light with less features, less performance, not the same expandability ond not the same age.
(Stability has to be proven)
 
Back
Top