Adding one more thread to the "Need Build Advice Board"

GautLSU

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 1, 2006
Messages
73
Another lurker here coming out of the shadows to seek build advice. I've been reading, reading, reading and learning. FYI this is my first build. I've already made some decisions, but need help with the rest (mainly MB, RAM). So here goes:

Where I'm coming from:
P4 3Ghz, Asus p4c800, ATI X850pro (oc'd to pe) --this was originally a 9800pro rig

My primary use is gaming and misc. surfing, and occasional encoding or 3d modeling. I plan to move to Vista 32bit with all this. I want to build a rig that lasts 3+ years with minimal upgrading, hence the decision of getting a quad (in case I don't upgrade). I won't be doing a ton of overclocking at first, but I may push it later on. If so, I'll get a good cooler (thermalright ultra120) another time.

CASE: CM Centurion 5 (already own)

MONITOR: Dell 2405 fwp [EDIT- already own]

CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 G0 (on order from ncix)

PSU: Corsair HX620 (also on the way)

MB: GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3R LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - $129.99 @ the egg
-Here's where I need help. This is my frontrunner, but I'll hear suggestions on this one. I was also looking into the Asus P5KC. No need for SLI/Crossfire, and DDR3 is still irrelevent. I basically want a solid quality board with good features and decent overclockability should I persue that more. Also I want compatibility with 45nm and 1333fsb for future flexibility, so a quality P35 chipset is a no-brainer.

RAM: Crucial Ballistix 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - $80 After Rebate @ the egg
-I'm going to stick with 2GB for now, possibly 4GB + Vista 64bit down the line. I have to admit I don't know ram as well as I should. It appears that any namebrand set of PC-6400 will do, and I think the uberfast ram is way overkill for a quad cpu anyway right? I keep seeing Crucial, Corsair, and G Skill sets in people's builds. Feel free to suggest a set of sticks that will allow me to do good overclocking on a Q6600 if I so choose.

VIDEO: EVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB 320-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card - $350 After Rebate @ the egg
-Another quandry here. Have to choose between a GTS640, GTX, or Ultra. I find it hard to justify the price of the latter two, especially considering the G80 age vs. lack of price drops. Meanwhile I can see myself going for a similar next-gen card in a 1-1.5 years. It should be noted I'd like to game at 1920x1200, at least for a while. Crysis and COD4 will be high on my list, will the GTS get the job done till the DX10 video card scene matures? Are the superclocked versions worth it, or just do it yourself?

STORAGE: I already have a 74GB Raptor for OS/apps, a 250GB WD drive for redundancy/backup, and I'll likely pick up a 500GB or 750GB drive for my main storage. So no help needed here.

MEDIA: Can someone recommend a reliable/popular drive here? I see a lot of LG and Lite-On DVD burners going around, but I have no clue where to start.

SOUND: So I gather that X-Fi + Vista sucks for now (thanks Creative!!). I still have an Audigy 2 ZS that I can use, otherwise it'll be onboard sound.


Thanks for the help guys. I've been researching my brain off, but it's a lot to take in. This is my first actual build, and throwing in overclocking possibilities really complicates things.
 
I'd second your notion of skipping the x-fi. I have an x-fi with XP and it's nothing but problems, I can't even enable the x-fi feature in BF2. What a waste of $$ it was.
 
At 1920x1200 you're squarely in "Single GTX/Ultra and hope, SLI'd GTX's/Ultras to be 'safe'" territory. The GTS will not be enough. This is a "gut feeling" kind of thing, but it can struggle with newer titles at that res already, so running Crysis or any other high end DX10 title coming out at it with settings you'd want to deal with seems unlikely. I get 29FPS in World In Conflict Beta stress test at 1600x1200, 16xAF no AA with a GTX -- granted, beta code, and there's still clearly room to optimize drivers, as the latest set helped a good bit, but still. With a GTS I think it would be fast approaching unplayable.

Motherboard is a good choice. That, or an Abit. The ASUS boards cost entirely too much.

Stick with the Audigy 2 ZS or onboard for now. X-Fi's do suck -- I can attest to this from personal experience, as can the poster before me, apparently.

I have never had issues with a Lite-On drive, they're cheap ($33 for a 20X SATA DVDRW) and get frequent firmware updates that keep them working well with newer media long after other manufacturers have given up entirely.
 
Another lurker here coming out of the shadows to seek build advice. I've been reading, reading, reading and learning. FYI this is my first build. I've already made some decisions, but need help with the rest (mainly MB, RAM). So here goes:

Where I'm coming from:
P4 3Ghz, Asus p4c800, ATI X850pro (oc'd to pe) --this was originally a 9800pro rig

My primary use is gaming and misc. surfing, and occasional encoding or 3d modeling. I plan to move to Vista 32bit with all this. I want to build a rig that lasts 3+ years with minimal upgrading, hence the decision of getting a quad (in case I don't upgrade). I won't be doing a ton of overclocking at first, but I may push it later on. If so, I'll get a good cooler (thermalright ultra120) another time.

CASE: CM Centurion 5 (already own)

MONITOR: Dell 2405 fwp

CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 G0 (on order from ncix)

PSU: Corsair HX620 (also on the way)

MB: GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3R LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - $129.99 @ the egg
-Here's where I need help. This is my frontrunner, but I'll hear suggestions on this one. I was also looking into the Asus P5KC. No need for SLI/Crossfire, and DDR3 is still irrelevent. I basically want a solid quality board with good features and decent overclockability should I persue that more. Also I want compatibility with 45nm and 1333fsb for future flexibility, so a quality P35 chipset is a no-brainer.

RAM: Crucial Ballistix 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - $80 After Rebate @ the egg
-I'm going to stick with 2GB for now, possibly 4GB + Vista 64bit down the line. I have to admit I don't know ram as well as I should. It appears that any namebrand set of PC-6400 will do, and I think the uberfast ram is way overkill for a quad cpu anyway right? I keep seeing Crucial, Corsair, and G Skill sets in people's builds. Feel free to suggest a set of sticks that will allow me to do good overclocking on a Q6600 if I so choose.

VIDEO: EVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB 320-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card - $350 After Rebate @ the egg
-Another quandry here. Have to choose between a GTS640, GTX, or Ultra. I find it hard to justify the price of the latter two, especially considering the G80 age vs. lack of price drops. Meanwhile I can see myself going for a similar next-gen card in a 1-1.5 years. It should be noted I'd like to game at 1920x1200, at least for a while. Crysis and COD4 will be high on my list, will the GTS get the job done till the DX10 video card scene matures? Are the superclocked versions worth it, or just do it yourself?

STORAGE: I already have a 74GB Raptor for OS/apps, a 250GB WD drive for redundancy/backup, and I'll likely pick up a 500GB or 750GB drive for my main storage. So no help needed here.

MEDIA: Can someone recommend a reliable/popular drive here? I see a lot of LG and Lite-On DVD burners going around, but I have no clue where to start.

SOUND: So I gather that X-Fi + Vista sucks for now (thanks Creative!!). I still have an Audigy 2 ZS that I can use, otherwise it'll be onboard sound.


Thanks for the help guys. I've been researching my brain off, but it's a lot to take in. This is my first actual build, and throwing in overclocking possibilities really complicates things.

When spending that kind of money on a system, do you really want to stick with the stock HS even if not overclocking???
 
At 1920x1200 you're squarely in "Single GTX/Ultra and hope, SLI'd GTX's/Ultras to be 'safe'" territory. The GTS will not be enough. This is a "gut feeling" kind of thing, but it can struggle with newer titles at that res already, so running Crysis or any other high end DX10 title coming out at it with settings you'd want to deal with seems unlikely. I get 29FPS in World In Conflict Beta stress test at 1600x1200, 16xAF no AA with a GTX -- granted, beta code, and there's still clearly room to optimize drivers, as the latest set helped a good bit, but still. With a GTS I think it would be fast approaching unplayable.

Motherboard is a good choice. That, or an Abit. The ASUS boards cost entirely too much.

Stick with the Audigy 2 ZS or onboard for now. X-Fi's do suck -- I can attest to this from personal experience, as can the poster before me, apparently.

I have never had issues with a Lite-On drive, they're cheap ($33 for a 20X SATA DVDRW) and get frequent firmware updates that keep them working well with newer media long after other manufacturers have given up entirely.

Hmm... well while I feel this is a good time to build a system, coincidentally it's a bad time for purchasing a video card. The 8800's aren't really fresh any more, but they still cost like they are. Meanwhile we're looking at like what... maybe 5-6 months for the G90 monsters? I don't like dropping 500-600 on a card that will be shat upon in half a year. And to be reasonable about the 1920x1200 thing, I know it'll be borderline with the newest games, but I can deal with say, 2xAA. Otherwise maybe drop down to 16x10 with more AA and all the graphical goodies. Does the GTX/Ultra make enough difference to justify? Or is it more a result of trying to push 19x12 more than anything?
 
When spending that kind of money on a system, do you really want to stick with the stock HS even if not overclocking???

I pretty much expect to upgrade the CPU Cooler at some point, mainly for going after a good overclock. However is it that wrong to stick with the stock fan in the meanwhile? I'm more concerned at the moment with just assembling the right combination of components and having it work right. The tinkering will come after.
 
When spending that kind of money on a system, do you really want to stick with the stock HS even if not overclocking???
a) The stock cooler is sufficient for stock speeds, hence...stock cooler. I don't see why any company would ship an inadequate cooler for it's products.. It's like buying a car that doesn't come with wheels.

b) the chip isn't going to destroy itself, if it gets to hot it'll shut down. that's about it...but it won't get to that point at stock speeds or even with light overclocking
 
Hmm... well while I feel this is a good time to build a system, coincidentally it's a bad time for purchasing a video card. The 8800's aren't really fresh any more, but they still cost like they are. Meanwhile we're looking at like what... maybe 5-6 months for the G90 monsters? I don't like dropping 500-600 on a card that will be shat upon in half a year. And to be reasonable about the 1920x1200 thing, I know it'll be borderline with the newest games, but I can deal with say, 2xAA. Otherwise maybe drop down to 16x10 with more AA and all the graphical goodies. Does the GTX/Ultra make enough difference to justify? Or is it more a result of trying to push 19x12 more than anything?

Even with 2xAA 1920x1200 is a lot to push. 1650x1080 with high AA/AF can be too much for a GTS, even. Yes, the GTX makes enough difference to justify. My display tops out at 1600x1200, but I have a 21" CRT that'll push 2040x1536. I hooked it up one day and ran DiRT at 1900x1200 and even my GTX struggled a bit from time to time. Unless you plan to buy the next gen cards as soon as they get here (for who knows how much -- prices on the high end have been going up) and are willing to suffer for the mean time I wouldn't be buying a GTS for that kind of resolution right now. You won't just be dropping AA (or turning it off completely) with a GTS to maintain that res, you'll be dropping settings as well.
 
a) The stock cooler is sufficient for stock speeds, hence...stock cooler. I don't see why any company would ship an inadequate cooler for it's products.. It's like buying a car that doesn't come with wheels.

b) the chip isn't going to destroy itself, if it gets to hot it'll shut down. that's about it...but it won't get to that point at stock speeds or even with light overclocking

Not really. The stock cooler works, but at what temps? It may keep it just under MAX temps for the cpu. I dont have 1 stock cooler on any of the comps i have. I would rather have at least mid range cooling then stock.

It may be just me but spending a few extra $$ for cooling is worth it. People spend 300-600 on a video card and then want to skimp on the cooler or power supply. Their choice. :) I am jus giving my 2 cents.
 
There's nothing wrong with the stock cooler. It's not like you can't replace it later.

As for sound, the latest X-Fi drivers work fine under Vista. Still, you might as well wait and get the PCI-E version when it comes out in a few months.
 
Not really. The stock cooler works, but at what temps? It may keep it just under MAX temps for the cpu. I dont have 1 stock cooler on any of the comps i have. I would rather have at least mid range cooling then stock.

It may be just me but spending a few extra $$ for cooling is worth it. People spend 300-600 on a video card and then want to skimp on the cooler or power supply. Their choice. :) I am jus giving my 2 cents.
My stock cooling has always worked fine ( as in reasonable temperatures, nothing borderine ) and for the life of me I can't find a review that demonstrates the Q6600 with stock cooling.

Oh well, different people I guess...part of how I grew up I guess ( poor ), I don't spend more money than I need to.
 
Okay so I'm assuming the other stuff (motherboard, ram) is all good. Please speak up if it's not.

And what I'm gathering is that I've put myself into a certain bracket if I want to game well on a 2405 fpw. Still, should I go for a GTS now for 350, then perhaps sell and upgrade in 6-8 months to a 400ish card that spanks a GTX? The alternative is going for the GTX/Ultra now at a premium (550+), thus making it hard to justify upgrading for quite some time. Bear in mind I'm coming from an X850, so a GTS would already be quite the jump for all my present games (BF2 and the like).

Which strategy will work out better over say a 2 year run for the relative cost?

I knew jumping into the 2405 would come back to bite me in the wallet! :p
 
I've already made it pretty clear what I think. You could potentially go with a 640MB GTS now and sell it, replacing it with a faster card in 6-8 months... but a GTX is under $500 after rebate anymore, and you're getting what is in effect a more than 1/4 faster part for another $100 or so over the 640MB GTS.... and resale value will be higher as well. Or go all out for another $50, get better OCing and cooler running higher stock clocks with an Ultra.. which will have slightly higher resale than the GTX.
 
Yah, mobo and ram choices are perfect. All you need is DDR2-800 with the Q6600, since you plan on OC'ing in the future.
 
Alright guys, per advice I've decided to go with a GTX. You're right, my 2405 fwp has served me well and deserves the treat ;)

Anyway, from a quick perusal of price watching forums, I've come across these two cards:

MSI NX8800GTX-T2D768E-HD OC GeForce 8800GTX 768MB 384-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card - Retail - $479.99 After Rebate @ the egg

EVGA GeForce 8800GTX 768MB 384bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card Retail 768-P2-N831-AR - $479.99 After Rebate @ ClubIT

As I understand it, EVGA is the preferred brand, but the MSI at newegg is a factory OC version, which can't hurt. Thoughts or other suggestions?

[EDIT] Oh and p.s. - Any problems with a GTX fitting into a Centurion 5??
 
Get the eVGA... you can OC it yourself and still be covered under warranty. In fact, you can change the cooler and still be covered under warranty. eVGA's warranty is the best.
 
Okay so here's the updated tally:

CASE: CM Centurion 5 (already own)
MONITOR: Dell 2405 fwp (already own)
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 G0 (on order from ncix)
PSU: Corsair HX620 (also on the way)
MB: GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3R LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - $129.99 @ the egg
RAM: Crucial Ballistix 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - $80 After Rebate @ the egg
VIDEO: EVGA GeForce 8800GTX 768MB 384bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card Retail 768-P2-N831-AR - $479.99 After Rebate @ ClubIT
MEDIA: LITE-ON Black 20X DVD+R 8X DVD+RW 8X DVD+R DL 20X DVD-R 6X DVD-RW 12X DVD-RAM 16X DVD-ROM 48X CD-R 32X CD-RW 48X CD-ROM 2MB Cache SATA DVD Burner with LightScribe - Retail
OPERATING SYSTEM: Microsoft Windows Vista 32-Bit Home Premium for System Builders Single Pack DVD - OEM - $111.99 @ the egg
STORAGE: Existing 74GB Raptor, Existing 250GB WD, + another 500GB tbd
SOUND: Existing Audigy 2 ZS or Onboard Sound

The only catch I may see is that the MSI GTX on newegg shows a picture of Company of Heroes as a pack-in (saw this in another thread). That wouldn't be a bad snag if it worked out. Any other comments?
 
Swapping the eVGA for MSI is a bad plan. MSI's warranty isn't as good -- they don't allow overclocking under warranty and don't allow you to change the stock cooling for something else if you want (though be warned eVGA requires you re-mount it before sending the card in for RMA service, so keep it and the bolts if you ever decide to do that.) -- and their customer service doesn't even begin to compare.
 
Okie doke, eVGA it is. Thanks for the help guys, time to pull some more triggers
 
Back
Top