Activision Using Take Down Notices On CoD Glitch Videos

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Activision just being Activision. Anyone actually surprised?

Some YouTube video creators have found themselves on the unhappy side of copyright law recently as they say that Activision has been issuing copyright strikes on videos showing glitches and exploits in Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare.
 
Activision shitting on their customers? Typical stuff. Nothing to see here.

I get they don't want their game put in a negative light, but if it's in the game, it should be open season.

Poor move. Won't matter to their profits, as the customer base is so large, even if there were people pissed off enough to boycott, they'd only lose .001% of profits.
 
I can see pro/con to this. mind you the best solution is for them to fix it so that they don't need to issue a take down. As to the comments from people on the take down in general and copyrights I think is pretty funny reading what those few people think. If anyone ever took the time to read the EULA all of them would be aware that technically none of us even own the software we are just "using it with permission" That said its well with in the companies rights to request a take down as none of us actually own the game. that and the clause where all in game content and happenings belong to the publishers not the players. This is the same clause they use to go after gold farmers etc. as you can not sell or use anything that does not belong to you.

either way don't much care as I don't play that game although I am getting sick of cheaters in a lot of games these days and hope that they do more the curb that. It should be instant ban on all accounts using cheating. but as we know like all other game publishers its more about money. sure they may ban the account for a short time or just one game, but until they send a clear message to cheaters nothing will ever change.
 
Freedom of speech is no longer a cornerstone of this nation.
 
"Activision doesn't seem to be taking down every video that shows glitches or exploits in Advanced Warfare; there are still dozens if not hundreds readily available through a quick search. In a statement, Activision said it was that it was specifically targeting "videos that promote cheating and unfair exploits"—that is, videos that highlight how to gain advantages in online matches."

I have no problem with it if they are really only going after the videos that promote cheating.
However, they should patch the game to prevent it once they are aware of it.
 
If anyone ever took the time to read the EULA all of them would be aware that technically none of us even own the software we are just "using it with permission"
EULAs are too common and long for the average user to read. If they did, they'd never use any products. And remember, this is a country by the people and for the people, so they can put whatever they want in the EULA, but if we think they are infringing upon our civil liberties such as the right to free speech, and abusing the legal system by selectively implementing unjust copyright infringements only on negative reviews, we have a right as the people to tell them to shove it up their asses. I think sometimes people forget this fact, like there is some "gotcha" legal loophole clause, and therefore we have to eat a dick.

This isn't the first time we've seen this abuse either, as its been reported many times before that almost all publishers are getting away with the following because we ALLOW it to happen:
1) Abuse the legal system to hide unfavorable reviews
2) Setup "blacklists" of reviewers that don't get products or software to review because they haven't blown smoke up the asses of manufacturers/content providers in the past, and then we wonder why all the big titles get these crazy high reviews even when the games suck ass.

THE-LINE-MUST.jpg
 
I see Activision is doing DMCA abuse, again.

Its called "Fair use" as long as their is commentary over the video, considering that video games do not have the same benefit as movies/games because the chief part of "Game" is being interactive with it
 
I've been trying to get my hands on COD:MW3, only so I can finish the trilogy. I kind of grew attached to the characters of the series.
After that, I'd be damned if I'd buy anything from EA again.
 
I've been trying to get my hands on COD:MW3, only so I can finish the trilogy. I kind of grew attached to the characters of the series.
After that, I'd be damned if I'd buy anything from EA again.
I know, right? After the Battlefield 4 debacle, fuck EA. I'll stick to Call of Duty and Activision from now on.

Wait, what?
 
We need an amendment to the constitution which gives us electronic rights. Look I understand many take down and IP enforcement policies but forcing people to take down videos of games is ridiculous. Hey how about you waste less time paying some social media strategists, I mean you teen daughter to look for videos and send out canned letters and more time actually fixing the glitches.
 
I can see pro/con to this. mind you the best solution is for them to fix it so that they don't need to issue a take down. As to the comments from people on the take down in general and copyrights I think is pretty funny reading what those few people think. If anyone ever took the time to read the EULA all of them would be aware that technically none of us even own the software we are just "using it with permission" That said its well with in the companies rights to request a take down as none of us actually own the game. that and the clause where all in game content and happenings belong to the publishers not the players. This is the same clause they use to go after gold farmers etc. as you can not sell or use anything that does not belong to you.

I don't see how recording a video of a game has anything to do with the game asset.

Gold farmers are trading in-game items. But screen capture is just that, a capture of what's displayed on our screen. When we upload a video, we are not uploading the game itself.
 
Isn't filing false DMCAs illegal?

Well it's not a false DMCA since technically people are distributing copyrighted material. Activision could file DMCA on every single youtube video of their game out there.

As for cheat videos, I've often had to research how someone was doing something so I could learn how to defeat it. "How the hell did he get up there?.....oh it's an exploit....well now I know where to wait for him to interfere with his plan". I never use the exploit myself, I just exploit the exploit against the exploiter as best as I can :)
 
I don't see how recording a video of a game has anything to do with the game asset.

Gold farmers are trading in-game items. But screen capture is just that, a capture of what's displayed on our screen. When we upload a video, we are not uploading the game itself.

Exactly.

Isn't filing false DMCAs illegal?

Are you kidding? DMCA laws were made by big money lobbiests of big money media companies to our polititians in Washington to control what we do with the media we buy. It's all about control bro and they are in the drivers seat. :mad:
 
Won't matter to their profits, as the customer base is so large, even if there were people pissed off enough to boycott, they'd only lose .001% of profits.
I think
y8W5bwW.png
us that "boycotting" their game doesn't even cause the .001% to be lost...
 
ffs, the link formatted wrong and I can't edit, feel free to delete or fix that
 
Freedom of speech is no longer a cornerstone of this nation.

Well okay, like aside from DCMA being allegedly abused to take stuff offline, this is a private company doing private company junk. Your 1st Amendment rights prevent the government from exercising censorship which has like nothing at all to do with Activision being a Naughty Mister McGrump about people saying negative things about their products.
 
Well okay, like aside from DCMA being allegedly abused to take stuff offline, this is a private company doing private company junk. Your 1st Amendment rights prevent the government from exercising censorship which has like nothing at all to do with Activision being a Naughty Mister McGrump about people saying negative things about their products.

What difference does it make what's on paper if it's not worth the ink it's written with? The legal system/laws have been twisted against social welfare and toward protecting entities with deep pockets.

Activision is really small fry in this case, but imho this is still the tip of the iceberg rearing its ugly head; showing how little fear even they have of censoring content they find offensive when it should be protected speech.

Sure someone can contest it or legally challenge the abuse, but that would require time, effort and, more importantly, deep pockets and an army of lawyers, something the average person is not gonna want to or be able to muster against a corporate "citizen" with the law written in its favor.

The only recourse left these days is negative PR, but that's just a speed bump, the lobbies eventually get what they want. It's getting tiring seeing companies swinging their money bags around these days like punching gloves.
 
What Activision is saying is that it's FAR cheaper to pay legal beagles to bark at people than it is to pay for qualified programmers, or even those who aren't so qualified as skilled, to actually fix their shit;-)

Seems like they'd want the WTF? said upon the videos maker rather than their own company...but that's ME thinking again LOL
 
I have no problem with it if they are really only going after the videos that promote cheating.
However, they should patch the game to prevent it once they are aware of it.

Bullshit. It's up to Activision to fix the game so you can't cheat, it's not the public's duty to censor their critique so Activision is happy. If Activision doesn't like people cheating in their games, perhaps they should patch it ASAP so it's impossible to cheat. The public is under no obligation to not share game cheats, or even encouraging people to cheat. Not sure how this even got taken down under a Copyright law as Activision doesn't (and can't) own any copyrights on you showing someone how to do something.
 
Not sure how this even got taken down under a Copyright law as Activision doesn't (and can't) own any copyrights on you showing someone how to do something.

YouTube's default response is to take down any video that someone issues a copyright strike against. The person who gets the strike can then appeal the decision at which point the issuer has ten business days to respond with real legal action or the video goes back up. What I'm not sure of is whether or not the strike is rescinded...I seem to recall that it is not, and YouTube has a "three strikes and you're out" policy.
 
The DMCA is one of the most abused things. It was way to broad and should not exist.
The EULA's are a joke. So if a minor, who cannot commit to a contract, hits the "ok" button - this is in no way an agreement.
Just like the old "if you break this seal..." - what if I left the seal intact and cut the case open? It's BS.
 
Because it's easier to attack your user base then fix your shit...
And Indy gaming is on the rise while AAA goes to shit.
How about you spend over half of that advertising budget on some programmers to fix the errors instead? Your customers (we gamers) would be happy and eager to buy your shit, err, games on launch!
 
Of course gutless YT will be quick to pull any video that is remotely accused of violating or offending anyone. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top