Acer x241w - What panel is it?

mchan

n00b
Joined
Jan 7, 2008
Messages
3
I've been reading around this forum and found a lot of helpful info about lcd panels.
These past weeks, I've been shopping around for a 24" lcd and finally narrowed down my choice to SOYO 24" at officemax due to budget limit.

I'm quite happy with the display quality when I tested it at home, but not too sure about the quality. It's been a week now and everything still works fine.

Last Sunday, I'm browsing around bestbuy in my area and found the Acer x241w on sale for $296.xx. I was thinking.....it's cheap......maybe it's TN panel? I looked at the display example from top, bottom, left, right and it doesn't look a TN panel at all. Seeing it as a better choice than the SOYO (if it's not a TN plus bestbuy offer 4 year plan for 40$), I quickly bought it home.

Side to side with the SOYO, I found the color to be better and I'm tempted to keep this Acer and return the SOYO. Again, I don't see TN characteristics in this monitor. When I see it from bottom, the panel does not turn black. Side to side, it looks like a VA panel to me. I have another TN panel at home (Westy LCM22w3) and the Acer wins by miles.
So, I read various posts and news that this Acer is supposed to have a TN. Can anyone confirm it ? Thanks a bunch :)
 
Up till now, I'm still scratching my head to admit it is a TN panel. I'm so tempted to crack open the case and see if there is anything printed in the panel itself.
Again, I don't see any of the usual TN characteristics. I've been flipping the LCD on all angles to see anything (color shifting, dark patches) and it really looks the same with the SOYO.

The back says it's x241Wsd. Not x241WBsd. I thought the B in the model number would indicate a TN panel for Acer. There's also 2 user manuals floating around the internet, 1 says 178/178 viewing angle, the other says 168/168
Maybe there's something wrong with my eyes and I'm just hoping the impossible?
Can it be that TN panels have come a long way...

I will try to post pics
 
just curious, what is wrong with a tn panel anyway, don't think I have ever seen one that I know of.
 
You must have gotten a manufacturing defect unit. Someone stuck in a VA panel by mistake.
Prad says TN too: http://www.prad.de/en/guide/screen3876.html

A friend got one recently and unlike yours, it has nasty vertical color shifts and uneven back lighting.

You won the panel lottery. Congrats!
 
I bought the Acer X241WSD as well and I experience exactly the same characteristics as described by mcann. I have tried to view through different angles and the colors don't change at all. I kept my Sceptre LCD side by side and experimented the same scenerio and saw the colors changing to black and brown if I viewed from the top. But with the Acer I don't experience any such characteristics.
It's pretty hard to believe that this is a TN panel.
 
I bought the Acer X241WSD as well and I experience exactly the same characteristics as described by mcann. I have tried to view through different angles and the colors don't change at all. I kept my Sceptre LCD side by side and experimented the same scenerio and saw the colors changing to black and brown if I viewed from the top. But with the Acer I don't experience any such characteristics.
It's pretty hard to believe that this is a TN panel.

Ok, step away from the monitor. The PANEL police are surrounding your house as I type. You are harboring alien TN technology that was not supposed to be released until 2015.

I was just using this same monitor and I could see color shifts just glancing from the top to the bottom, never mind moving my head. Q/C issues perhaps?

In the interests of science would you mind ripping the X241 apart and confirm the alien TN tech in there?
 
here's a photo, although i suck at taking pictures but it conveys the point.

dsc00777na4.jpg


As you can see, I am trying to view the screen from the extreme top but the colors never disappear.
 
That looks suspiciously photoshopped. LimP Gawd is not a natural name. ;-)

Doesn't look really hideous, but it does get darker. Could you take another shot centered and little less angle? And could you also display a full screen solid color?
 
ok that's the last set I can post, I have been reading about TN panels over the web and from what I found that it should change colors such that we can hardly read or distinguish anything on the screen.

here are more pics:
dsc00791xt8.jpg


dsc00792gx1.jpg
 
Oh and another thing, my monitor doesn't seem to have any major back lighting issues either :/
 
Could be the camera, but I see some color shifting. Did you use a flash?

I can't show this post to my friend with the 241, otherwise it will be RMA time at the Office Depot coral.
 
Heeey, wait a sec. That screen looks a lot like a Acer AL2416Ws PVA screen. Maybe they ran out of x241 labels?
 
i don't own this monitor, but i've seen it at best buy and its definitely NOT a TN panel. the viewing angles are very different from (much better than) my hp w2408, especially from below. in terms of viewing angles, it looked very similar to the lg l246, which also has a semi-glossy finish to the screen.
 
And BB agrees with you:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage...er+24&lp=1&type=product&cp=1&id=1170289357971

From their blurb it states:
* Ultrafast 6 ms response time
* 1000:1 contrast ratio; 500 cd/m² brightness
* 1920 x 120 maximum resolution; 178° horizontal and vertical viewing angles
* 1 VGA and 2 DVI with HDCP inputs
* 8-bit panel for improved color reproduction

It must be a VA of some sort. Only at Best Buy tho. Everywhere else it's a TN. Did Acer run out of model numbers?
 
Here are a couple of my pics

<img src="http://img225.imageshack.us/img225/9311/dsc02904mo3.th.jpg" border="0" alt="" /><br />

<img src="http://img70.imageshack.us/img70/7382/dsc02911dx4.th.jpg" border="0" alt="" /><br />

<img src="http://img218.imageshack.us/img218/8154/dsc02915sq4.th.jpg" border="0" alt="" /><br />

<img src="http://img218.imageshack.us/img218/1109/dsc02916lv5.th.jpg" border="0" alt="" /><br />

<img src="http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/9360/dsc02917ke7.th.jpg" border="0" alt="" /><br />

What do you guys think? There may be a panel lottery with this panel...
 
Your pics definitely show a VA panel, and judging by the semi-reflective screen, it's most likely P-MVA.
 
I used flash in some cases but my camera sucks at taking dark pictures. mchan's images show the same features as mine. Semi glossy screen, large viewing angles without color shifting. And hardly any back lighting.
 
same here, just picked one up yesterday and it looks the same as the pictures posted. Not a single dead pixel... For $296 I am very pleased.
 
yea considering that I got it for 294$ and the fact that this turns out to be an M-PVA panel which go for over 500$, it's an absolute steal. Bestbuy says that they have put all of their 550$ X241 on clearance so any one, picking it up right now, has a highly likely chance of getting an M-PVA panel at only 294$.
 
Here is what a TN typically looks like from angles;

IMG0020635.jpg


The Acer looks nothing like it.
 
Picked up one last night, It looks almost exactly like my soyo 24 inch right next to it from officemax and both have amazing viewing angle both verticle and horz. Now I just need to decide if I should keep it or get a second soyo instead.

I want to get a 2 screen mount so that I can view them both side to side 90 degrees so its like a giant book and I'm afraid that if I'm reading something two page it won't look right since the screens might not line up.
 
I was in Best Buy yesterday and looking at the 24" monitors comparing this Acer, the Westinghouse, and LG and I thought the Acer looked the best. I was utterly confused since the specs said 5ms, 170/160 viewing angles which clearly describes a TN. Maybe Acer switched the panels? For $296 I'm incredibly tempted.

Best Buy website says 6ms, 178/178 viewing, 1000 contrast. I think it's an S-PVA.
 
Got one in Kissimmee FL. Manufacture date 03-07, no dead pixels. There are still two in that store. I had reservations about getting it because floor is definitely TN model.

Rolled the dice and this monitor is for sure not the same as the floor. The floor model vertical viewing was horrible where as this one you can look straight down on the monitor just as demonstrated earlier in the thread. What that means as to the panel type I got, I don't know.

As well,goto the post office and ask for a moving pack which will contain a 10 % off BB coupon, 286 out the door, I am happy!
 
Here is what a TN typically looks like from angles;

IMG0020635.jpg


The Acer looks nothing like it.

I can't see the pics??? :confused: I might considering picking one of these up tomorrow if I know what TN looks like from an angle.

Help anyone? pics?
 
did you check out the first page of this thread... I posted quite a few pictures, just scroll down and follow the conversation. You'll know the difference!
 
Can anyone give a quick review of this? I was debating dropping the 24" idea to save some money but a S-PVA (I believe) for $300 sounds like a fantastic deal. I assume I don't have much time, the sale ends soon correct? How's the stand too?
 
Online specs are mis-leading, the x241's sold in Best buy are mostly S-PVA's and if you compare their price with the one's in the market, they are about 250$ more expensive.

The stand is quite sturdy and the monitor looks gorgeous too. The nice metallic silver finish matches up nicely with all the hardware I have!
 
Ok, step away from the monitor. The PANEL police are surrounding your house as I type. You are harboring alien TN technology that was not supposed to be released until 2015.

ahaha you nut.. i could almost picture that
 
This is not a TN. I just went to BB, and they had 2 more left. I checked all viewing angle, directly next to another TN and this is certainly not a TN panel. Picked one up for $294 :eek::D
 
Hey um.. just wanted to let you guys know that um ya...

This is not a TN panel, from all the testing and reading/research I've done today.. this seems to be a S-PVA panel that Acer made,and only Best Buy had purchased. If you look up this monitor online, everywhere will tell you its a TN. But the one I have is NOT a TN. Viewing angles are SUPERB.. and the best part?

No ghosting, at all.

So for $294 I got a 24" non TN (likely S-PVA) panel, that has zero ghosting. Call me silly, but wouldn't this be the steal of a lifetime?
 
What about input lag? Don't S-PVAs typically have more input lag like TNs with overdrive do? If all is good, I'm picking one up tomorrow (if the sale is still on and there's stock left).
 
I have been pawning everyone in TF2 thanks to the largly clear and smooth game play on this LCD. Considering that the S-PVA's normally go above 600$, it's a steal!
 
What about input lag? Don't S-PVAs typically have more input lag like TNs with overdrive do? If all is good, I'm picking one up tomorrow (if the sale is still on and there's stock left).

Not basing anything on a manual listed refresh rate I jumped in games and could not detect any ghosting. Input lag seemed minimal, however I'm not the LCD wizard. Its subjective, but I'm very happy, and for $294 ... it is likely unmatched.

The only thing I need to figure out is the right calibration for this monitor. First large LCD at home (plenty at work) and its hard on my eyes. I know I just need to calibrate it, but I'm working on that.
 
I am using a contrast of 80 and 50 for brightness. Acer also has this auto-calibration feature but I prefer not to use that and instead manually set the Contrast/brightness.
 
Back
Top