About ATI and Shader model 3.0?

oqvist

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Dec 24, 2001
Messages
8,936
Is there any reason why ATI wouldn´t have full support for shader model 3.0 except they running 24 bit instead of 32-bit and thus aren´t allowed to market their cards as shader model 3.0 enabled?

Are there any rumour about this? ATI is keeping their mouth too shut. It´s god damn torture that´s what it´s :mad:
 
it had them, it exceeded SM 2.0 specs, as did the r300, the problem is that the nv30 was very, very slow doing SM 2.0 ops, the features were there, just slow. (oh, btw, the NV40 is the first card to fully support dx9 as SM 3.0 was part of the original specs)
 
Not talking precision, the NV30 did not have Phong, AF or spot lighting. Of which I think some are in the DX9 spec. Its not right to mention them, because they could very well be in the hardware, but not enabled yet. I feel a little bit justified, because we are at the point where the next gen card is out, and Nvidia has not even mentioned this issue in its older cards yet.

The missing lighting is most notable here. As much as I hate quoting Tom, he has the clearest example of the missing or "different" DX9 lighthing effects in the 5950.

http://www.tomshardware.com/graphic/20040414/geforce_6800-46.html

The NV40 appears to have some sort of proprietary lighting abilities that they are trying to push, but they do seem to at least try to adhere to the DX9 lighting.

Edit: Just like the new water effects, I am so surprised that people tend to never notice that there are a lot of places where the 5950 has missing lighting...
 
Originally posted by Merlin45
it had them, it exceeded SM 2.0 specs, as did the r300, the problem is that the nv30 was very, very slow doing SM 2.0 ops, the features were there, just slow. (oh, btw, the NV40 is the first card to fully support dx9 as SM 3.0 was part of the original specs)

Notice I said DX9 which doesnt just consist of one thing
 
if you are talking about ultrashadow it is simply a faster way to render shadows on the nv35 and nv40. it has nothing to do with how the shadows are done, it just clips unseen shadows for faster calculation. (and IIRC those features are due to lack of driver support more than anything)
 
mind you the NV30 was dx9+ whereas the R300 was only following the dx9 spec. the NV30 had more dx9 features than the R300 so that don´t automatically make it superior.

But back to the subject what rumours about the R420:s shaders are there except it won´t be Shader model 3 certified?
 
In that toms link I think the 9800xt has the best looking render of that floor.
 
far cry is an exception, with the 1.1 patch they used partial precision ps 2.0 for the nv3x, that is the only way to get reasonable performance from those parts in ps 2.0 mode. unfortunately the same optimization effects the nv40 even though it is not needed, the next farcry patch will not only fix this but add eye candy for SM 3.0 compatible cards.
 
Originally posted by Merlin45
far cry is an exception, with the 1.1 patch they used partial precision ps 2.0 for the nv3x, that is the only way to get reasonable performance from those parts in ps 2.0 mode. unfortunately the same optimization effects the nv40 even though it is not needed, the next farcry patch will not only fix this but add eye candy for SM 3.0 compatible cards.

But the same optimizations is found on other PS 2.0 games like LOMAC and others so it´s yet to see the real full dx 9 performance of the NV40.

Also I find it interesting that the Crytek developers on that presentation iterates that this is also possible on PS 2.0 hardware so maybe we will have a R420 patch as well or even make it possible on old Radeon hardware though I believe the performance hit will be to much for it to handle really.

I think Far Cry will be the best comparison in how the 6800 ULTRA stacks against the R420 really. Should be a nice game to show case shader model 3 and what new effects/performance hit it brings.
 
Originally posted by oqvist
mind you the NV30 was dx9+ whereas the R300 was only following the dx9 spec. the NV30 had more dx9 features than the R300 so that don´t automatically make it superior.

Once again i'm talking about Dx9, not shader model 2.0, which is where Nvidia got it's + with arbitrary capabilities like extended PS length. the NV35 was missing support for some Dx9 features like MRT, different texture formats, and displacement mapping
 
Back
Top