About $700 to spend here

ShnikeJSB

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 22, 2005
Messages
223
Hello everyone!

Well, my buddy is ready to upgrade from his old rig (3.2GHz Northwood P4, 1GB DDR-333, BFG 7800GS AGP, etc.), and is willing to spend around $700, though he said he's willing to go a little higher if needed (MAYBE $100, but he'd rather not). He already has the hard drives, the monitors, and DVD-R's. He is planning on upgrading again next year when the new platform arrives, which means he'll be keeping the PSU and the case, but replacing the Mobo, video card, RAM, and GPU. So far, he doesn't plan on overclocking much, but I'm going to push him to eventually ;)

He does a LOT of gaming, uses Adobe programs a lot (Photoshop the most), and likes to listen to iTunes while gaming.

I was doing some research for him, and so far this is what I am looking at for him:

Case: Cooler Master RC-690 = $80
PSU: PC Power Silencer 750 Quad = $165 (ClubIT)
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E6750 2.66GHz 1333MHz Bus = $200 (ZipZoomFly)
Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R = $130 (ZipZoomFly)
RAM: (Not sure here, suggestions?) 2GB DDR2-800 = $65
GPU: eVGA 8800 GTS 640mb = $350 (including $30 MIR - NewEgg)

Unfortunately, that still places him at almost $1000! I don't want to dip him down into the 8800 GTS 320mb territory. I know I can get a Corsair 620HX for around $120, but that deal on the PC Power is unbelievable, and should last him through the next upgrade. The pricing on all of that is pretty darn good in my opinion. I think I can talk him into going higher than he wants, but not much. Any help and suggestions are welcome!

Thanks guys (I love this place!)
 
That power supply is a bit excessive. Go with the power supply that buffbiff21 linked to. Or if you want to get it from ZZF:
Corsair HX520 520W PSU - $105

Since your friend's budget is tight and he's planning to replace everything anyway, go with the E4400. It's still pretty fast and it's a pretty cheap C2D:
Intel Core 2 Duo E4400 CPU - $119

Now before I go on, what size monitor does your friend have? What games is he planning to play on this new system?
 
In addition to whats been said... If he's replacing it within a year, just get the DS3L instead.

If he has a 20-22" monitor, the 640MB is needed. If he has a 19" or smaller, the 320MB is fine. Although, since he's upgrading in about a year, he should hold off on the DX10 card and game in DX9 mode for now, with an X1950 instead.
 
We end up playing pretty much every good new game that comes out, LOL! He is looking forward to a lot of games that are coming out, including Crysis, the next Call of Duty, Battlefield 2, Company of Heroes with the new expansion, Unreal Tournament 3, a bunch of older games, etc...

I kinda like the idea of one 12v rail, which is partially why I like the PC Power PSU. And like I said, he will be planning on getting a different card and CPU eventually, meaning probably an nVidia 9800 and a Yorkfield quad-core, so I am not sure that Corsair 520 will be enough juice at the time, will it?

He has two 1600x1200 19" CRT monitors that he runs simultaneously (they are still good, no LCD's needed yet, LOL).

As for the motherboard, any ideas on where to get it for a good price? I found it for $95.95 on mwave.

Thanks guys, I appreciate all the help!
 
I kinda like the idea of one 12v rail, which is partially why I like the PC Power PSU. And like I said, he will be planning on getting a different card and CPU eventually, meaning probably an nVidia 9800 and a Yorkfield quad-core, so I am not sure that Corsair 520 will be enough juice at the time, will it?

Well no one knows how much power the 9800s or Yorkfield CPUs will need. Since they are based on new manufacturing processes, they may end using less power than their predecessors. With that said, if you want a bit of headroom, go with the Corsair 620HX. It's actually one rail with 50A on it:
Corsair HX620 620W PSU - $147 ($127AR)

Get the DS3L here:
GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3L Intel P35 Motherboard - $88

Since your friend only has a 19" monitor and he's planning to upgrade to the 9800s anyway, the 8800GTS 320MB is all he needs at the moment:
eVGA 320-P2-N811-AR GeForce 8800GTS 320MB PCI-E Video Card - $290

Oh and a RAM recommendation:
A-Data ADQVE1A16K 2 x 1GB DDR2 800 RAM - $78

The E2160 may also be a good choice:
Intel Pentium Dual Core E2160 CPU - $80
 
I was looking at that HX620 too. It could work well. But that PC Power is such a good deal right now, it's hard to pass up!

Thanks for the link on the DS3L, that is a HOT deal!

He may "only" have a 19" monitors, but running at 1600x1200 is still moving more pixels than 1680x1050, and that's just about your standard widescreen res. I think the 640 will be fine. Probably not going to move on that one.

That RAM has bad timings, and I haven't head much of A-Data. There's a lot of other RAM for around the same, even cheaper, from brands with a reputation and with better timings on NewEgg. Just not sure which to pick from.

Not sure about the CPU. Since he doesn't want to overclock as far as I know (right now at least), those low-clocked CPU's seem kind of moot, don'tcha think?

Keep the advice coming. ;)
 
Your friend's budget of $700 or so really do limit his options and since he's planning to replace everything anyway next year, that does necessitate the purchase of lower priced and lower performing parts.

Basically his budget doesn't allow to him to get those high-end parts that you want him to have.

You honestly won't notice the difference between lower and higher timings in video games without the aid of a benchmark. Even then the gains will be somewhat small. Also, A-Data makes a majority of the world's RAM, often rebranded under other companies. So A-Data is a decent brand.

Now I should ask, when exactly is he gonna upgrade? Jan. 08 or July 08 or even Sept.08?

Just so you know, all P35 chipset motherboards will support Intel's new Yorkfield and Wolfdale CPUs. So your friend won't have to replace his motherboard when he upgrades to those new CPUs. Also, he may not have to replace his RAM at all since DDR3 won't be worth it in terms of performance and price until early 2009 I believe.
 
Yeah, I know it limits him, which is why I am going to try to get him to go for my original config that was posted. But I doubt that will happen, which is why I am trying to get alternatives, and so far I have been given some excellent suggestions.

He was buying new stuff when the new Eaglelake mobos were out next year (supposedly
2nd quarter, but we'll see), and popping in whatever nVidia has to offer at the time plus a Yorkfield quad-core. DDR3 will have to wait until like you said, 2009 or end of next year.

The higher/loose timings may not be all that big of a difference in games, but when it comes to things like Photoshop, Premiere, and other things like it, I thought lower timings helped more noticeably?
 
$700?

Antec Sonata III case, includes well rated Antec Earthwatts 500W psu (a jonnyguru recommended psu) $119 + $20 ship http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811129024
This is a quiet case, psu will run e4400, 8800GTS, no prob.

e4400 cpu (mine did 3ghz easy, now at 3.4ghz) $126 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115014


EVGA 8800GTS 320, $269 AR http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130082

CORSAIR XMS2 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 675 (will run DDR2 800 easy, with e4400 and a 10X multi you don't need a high fsb) $65 AR (or Corsair 800 for $75 AR)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820145015

XFX 650i Ultra mobo, $79 AR - solid enough mobo, I've added a fan to the NB sink
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813141004

$658 AR, + ship + tax
 
The lower timings may help, but not enough to warrant any price premium.

A-Data is one of the world's largest memory manufacturers. They've been making DRAM for a while, but its only recently that they started marketing it themselves under their own brand. Their customer service isn't up to par with the major players (corsair, kingstong, crucial, ocz, etc), but they are a good budget-oriented alternative. Since they're a global manufacturer, they make everything to spec... and DDR2-800 JEDEC spec is 5-5-5-15 @ 1.8v. All ram you buy should have those numbers for SPD, and you can just lower them in the BIOS. Of course, some sticks won't go as low as you want, lol. If you're friend won't raise his budget, these sticks are fine for $80 pre-rebate ($65AR).

Though, if you go for an E4400 like everyone is suggesting, you won't need DDR2-800 as markintosh13 mentions. You only need the cheapest DDR2-667 kit you can find. Fry's usually has 1GB sticks for $30, and so does the egg... so shop around. Though, if 2GB of DDR2-667 will cost $60-$65AR, you might as well buy the A-Data DDR2-800 that Danny recommended instead, lol.

FYI, upgrading so soon won't show much improvement over his last rig. In other words, whatever he gets in less than a year won't be a huge improvement over what he's about to build now, unless he goes for much cheaper parts now, and much more expensive parts later.
 
That's actually his plan. He just wants something relatively cheap to tide him over until he can get an Extreme Quad Core and the next nVidia top-line cards in a full on expensive new system. It's kind of just an interim 1-year update before the REAL substance, LOL!

And the DDR2-800 is just about the same cost as the DDR2-667, and the A-Data is not much (if at all) cheaper than the other brands that come stock with better timings.
 
Right, as I said, they're good for budget systems with compatibility in mind. They'll work in any board that complies with the JEDEC specs.

Extreme chips are an extreme waste of money.
 
Also, just a little more input about the PSU... there are a lot of good 700w-800w options in the $100-$150 category, so I would do some looking into that before buying a 500-ish watt PSU for around the same price.

For instance, there's the ThermalTake Toughpower 750W at Fry's.com for $125 or so... that's what I would recommend, but there's also an Antec 800W for close to that price...

Good luck with the new build!
 
Shrug - the $65 Antec Earthwatts 500W psu that's included in the Sonata III will power the above rig just fine - mine's OC'd to 3.4ghz (I can bench at 3.6) with it's 8800GTS 320 OC'd to 665mhz core, with an HD and an optical. I have no doubt that one could add a few more HD's no problem.

Jonnyguru's review: http://www.jonnyguru.com/review_details.php?id=51
It scores 9.5 out of 10 for performance, and 10 for value.

It's a good psu for a $700 budget build.
 
Shrug - the $65 Antec Earthwatts 500W psu that's included in the Sonata III will power the above rig just fine - mine's OC'd to 3.4ghz (I can bench at 3.6) with it's 8800GTS 320 OC'd to 665mhz core, with an HD and an optical. I have no doubt that one could add a few more HD's no problem.

Jonnyguru's review: http://www.jonnyguru.com/review_details.php?id=51
It scores 9.5 out of 10 for performance, and 10 for value.

It's a good psu for a $700 budget build.

I agree.

There are a bunch of good $50-ish PSU's as well that would work well for this build, and I don't think you need to spend more than that for this build. For instance, I'm running an 480w Antec TruePower II in my rig, and it's just peachy. Just make sure to look at the total amps on the 12v line, and read some reviews before you buy.
 
For instance, there's the ThermalTake Toughpower 750W at Fry's.com for $125 or so... that's what I would recommend, but there's also an Antec 800W for close to that price...

Yah, that toughpower was a great deal, but its gone now. Its $180 at frys.com now.

Just make sure to look at the total amps on the 12v line, and read some reviews before you buy.

Yes, and you don't just add the different +12V rails' amperages. You need to look at how much the combined +12V rails amperage is, or the wattage. If neither of those are given on the label, then look at the max combined power for the +3.3V and +5V rails, then subtract that from the total wattage, and divide by 12 to get the approximate combined +12v amperage.
 
Back
Top