A64 @ 2,4 Dual-core benchmark...

Pirox

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 13, 2003
Messages
71
Source : http://www.hwupgrade.it/articoli/1193/index.html

For gamers and dual core ( Thinking unreal 3 + here ): GDC 2005

GS: Do you imagine this will give you a large cost-reduction advantage over Intel?

JS: It's going to give us a cost-reduction advantage. The other thing, too, is it gives us a huge performance advantage. Just think of it conceptually. They've got two dies, they've got the two Hershey bar squares on there. Then they've got to put something else, some other piece of logic to arbitrate, so that when an application comes in it says, OK, die 0, die 1, die 0, die 1, etc. I haven't seen it, but I can't wait to get my hands on it. They'll have a package, they'll have some little pieces of silicon, and they'll have the two die cut together and stuck on the package, and that's how it'll look, right?

We're not going to have that.
The way things happen is that requests come in, and this system request interface will arbitrate, and the caches are going to communicate. The communication for the CPU to check to see if this cache is using the information or not, that's all at the speed of the processor. There's no front-side bus. It's not going across the front-side bus and checking and then coming out and back. It's right there. It's natively there, and it's going to be a huge performance benefit, and that's on top of our natural AMD 64 performance benefit. I think Intel is going to be grossly disappointing. I think for anyone who's buying it for what they think they can get out of it, they're not going to get what they expect. And I think with our case, they're going to get more than they expect.
No comment.

Pirox - no BW leeching please. Leave them as inline links.

TechHead
 
yup, i saw that pop up somewhere else..
if it's based on the E4 stepping and from what i've seen, the max power is 95w (though i read 110 too, 95 seems more reasonable).
sounds like they took two mobile cores and slapped em together and bumped the voltage to 1.4.
there's probably a bit of engineering behind fitting the two cores into one socket. there may be a crossbar memory controller so cpu's don't interfere with ram access (someone who knows more about memory architecture, feel free to step in here) and the cores should be linked with a HT link, similar to the dual opterons.

dunno what else i could theorize about it though

(note: all conjecture of course :D)
 
Wow thats very impressive for 2.4 mhz, quick question if any1 knows is 2 physical CPUs two dual core processors, or just using both cores on one processor?
 
everything i've seen for these indicated dual core = two cores on one die.
 
I'm gonna assume that the chip above is gonna be one the higher end ones at launch (if not the fastest one).

I'm guess I'll just sit patiently and wait for some gaming benches to pass judgement. But i want my turion first.
 
agreed. esp since the fastest chip right now is 2.6ghz, it would be insane if they could have dual core at the same speed too. though i'd respect them a lot for that, i think it would kinda divide up sales.
 
wouldn't they want to transition over to dual core if that is the future of computing.

I wouldn't worry too much I'm sure there'll be a nice price difference, esp. on the higher end ones.

I'm guessing oc'ing them will suck since the slower core will limit the oc.

dual core's coming to opties first and that's supposed to be like 2nd half of '05 so they should have more then revision E by then *crosses fingers*.
 
Everyone is so worried about gaming...

How about this, just make sure you have a top end vid card and you wont have to worry about gaming... I can see people bitching now... Dual core sucks for games, I got no FPS inprovement - and their using a damn 9600Pro or something.

Its logical really, people just think about it...

Dual Core 2.4Ghz will perform in games equal to... or better than a single core 2.4Ghz core....
So whats the problem? Its not like Dual Core CPUs are going to be worse...

You will have 1 core focus on games... 2.4Ghz... and the other 2.4Ghz core to do background tasks, OS stuff, input device utilization, network CPU utilization, SATA CPU uilitazation...

So logically.... the dual core will be a little faster, because you will have 1 core all to the game as opposed to sharing among things.

I could see if the dual core cpu was going to cost 2x that of a single core cpu... but even intel released prices.... the extra core is only about an 80$ premium....

Gaming may not have big increase.. but its not gonna be worse

so why is everyone wanting to see game benchies? cant you people figure it out on your own?
 
Intel did put together some relatively decent demos showcasing the benefits of dual core, the first was a video rendering test. Two systems rendered a single frame, one system was a Pentium 4 3.73EE, the other was a Pentium 4 3.2EE Dual Core. In this particular test, the dual core CPU rendered the scene in 45 seconds, compared to 67 seconds of the single core, higher clocked, Pentium 4 3.73EE.

Similar Cinebench *
Source
 
Dual core is going to be good. For anyone who has used a P4 with HT knows the difference it makes. This will only be better, For all users.
 
sounds like amd's dual core implementation is better then.
amd = 87% improvement
intel = 48% improcement

if course, there might be differences in the render, but they're both using the same program. my only guess as to why amd gains so much more is due to hyperthreading; intel already had an advantage, and dual core isn't going to improve on ht as much as it will on a regular single core. (if that makes sense)
 
NO. that's not true. AMD's dual-core implementation is not a hack. Thing is.... the way AMD has done it makes it possible for both caches in the core to communicate through the system request interface with CPU speed. Unlike INTEL's implementation the cpu's need to go back to memory to fetch*, because it's cache's are not separated but shared unlike AMD's :). In other words...the cores are not aware of what the other is doing and the only way to find out is fetch cpu->.memcontroller->mem->mem controller->cpu..but AMD is CPU -> interface->cache that's like 3 steps...all @ CPU speed :)... it also means that in a Dual - Dual core system the opteron will leave the Xeon in the dust :).
 
Yeah, AMD has alot more to gain to the simple fact that HT was already used on Intel Cores... however... Maybe AMD has implimented some sort of way the cores can communicate to eachother, to access eachothers cache etc.... something like a HyperTransport Link between the CPUs? OR Maybe AMD is just more efficent due to the fact their is no limiting FSB like on Intel processors?
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Yeah, AMD has alot more to gain to the simple fact that HT was already used on Intel Cores... however... Maybe AMD has implimented some sort of way the cores can communicate to eachother, to access eachothers cache etc.... something like a HyperTransport Link between the CPUs? OR Maybe AMD is just more efficent due to the fact their is no limiting FSB like on Intel processors?


Exactly. it's the system request interface that does that. That way the cores can communicate with each other without doing Memory lookup. ;)
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Everyone is so worried about gaming...

well i never thought they'd perform worse at the same clock but for sure teh 2.4ghz dual core will not be rated the same way as a single core.

also price is always a concern.
 
Pirox said:
Exactly. it's the system request interface that does that. That way the cores can communicate with each other without doing Memory lookup. ;)
yeah, i was just reading an old pdf from amd. it goes something like this

Code:
  cache 0      cache 1
   core 0      core 1
system request interface
    memory controller
   ram ht0 ht1 ht2 ht3

which means that for one core to get the other core's cache.. well it's fast. pirox's breakdown is definitly right for amd's side of things, but i'm not sure how intel is doing it.
 
Anyway you look at it, SMP on one one socket sounds pretty cool to me. PhotoShop should love it. The folding at home project will love it as well.

If the price is right it will be the poor mans dually. I want one :D
 
hmm so no connection directly between cores but could they go through the SRI to get to each other?
 
I think I found my new birthday present to myself. Dual Dual core AMD64.... drrrooooolllll
 
I fear that intel maybe too bandwidth starved to compete with the AMD dual-core solution. Current 2P Intel systems cannot outperform AMD 2P systems due to bandwidth. I heard Intel is looking into an integrated memory controller solution. They need to do something, or else AMD may just walk over them with their chip.
 
The hardware is there... we just need the software devs to start threading their games !
 
I doubt I'll upgrade to it. My machine is fast enough for what I want. As long as Valve fixes the CS:S issue I'll be 100% happy with every component I own (especially my Enermax 350w powering the thing). Even if they don't the 6800GT still runs it fairly well.
 
Sorry for a stupid quetion but i can't find any confirmation on it. Will dual core AMD work on existing nforce 4 chipsets ?
 
a bios update will definatly be in order for the chips to work but supposedly that's all.
 
Some how I think Intel will release Dual Core First... However I do beleive that AMDs version, even tho released later, will be a much better platform
 
Forgot where I read it (maybe even here) but it was mentionned that A64 duallies are a no-show in the '05 timeline.

If this is true, I'm expecting Q1 '06 at the least.
 
I dont want to poke fun or whatever but... Do you think they will call this the Bi-Athlon?

seriously... no joke intended...
 
haha, that would be so great, but i highly doubt they well.
i'm still hoping for my a64-DX :D
 
The new AMD BI-Athlon processor, slides past the competition and doesn't shoot a hole through your wallet. ;)
 
I'm wondering how these things will overclock, it would suck if one core was able to get a nice OC but the other got a crap OC. Overclocking seems to be getting more difficult these days :(
 
Bop said:
I'm wondering how these things will overclock, it would suck if one core was able to get a nice OC but the other got a crap OC. Overclocking seems to be getting more difficult these days :(

just weeding out the boys from the men ;) .

But yeah it would suck big time if one core couldn't oc at all but the other one is an awsome oc'er.
 
Either way, as soon as they come out, Im gonna get one.. and Its going right on a VapoChill LS... And that Thing is going to Fly
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Either way, as soon as they come out, Im gonna get one.. and Its going right on a VapoChill LS... And that Thing is going to Fly

where do you live and where do you keep your computer?

Early adoption is usually pretty expensive but if you have the cash that's great. Usually i'd say oc'ing won't be that great at first but since it's two low wattage cores together i wouldn't think that's much of an issue.
 
DryFire said:
just weeding out the boys from the men ;) .

But yeah it would suck big time if one core couldn't oc at all but the other one is an awsome oc'er.
think about it this way: two dies are right next to each other on the wafer. since all dies from a wafer are inherently similar, and dies close to each other are even more similar, i doubt this will be the case unless you get one die that has a defect in it. if that's the case though, it'll be hard to tell that it's one core or the other limiting you.
 
I am getting off Deployment in September ish Time frame... and I will have about 12Grand... Not all for the computer :) I wish

I am going to hope these are out, or close to comming out by then.... I am going to spend 5G on the Comp and 1G on the Monitor... I cannot wait. But I wont get a single core, i want dual cores.... I am spoiled with Hyperthreading and will never go to a Single core solution again.

My Goal is to Hit 3333Mhz each core. sooo if that is say 2.4Ghz Stock (200x12). I want a 333 HTT x 3 (1000) and 333 x 10 (3333) and I will be happy. I will spend whatever it takes. I know I have to get good ram too, thats gonna be the kicker. Because I also want to run my memory at 1:1 :)

2005 is a good year for hardware isnt it? :p
 
Back
Top