A question about HDTV's

djBon2112

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Messages
5,279
To put it simply, I'm looking for a TV that's a good mix of computer monitor and usual HDTV, in the 46-52" range. It'll be for my basement entertainment center, which will be used for 3 main things: watching HDTV/HD movies, gaming, and some general light web browsing (I have a laptop in my room and my family has a computer upstairs so this won't be the main place for that). Can anyone recommend a decent HDTV (1080p obviously) that will serve all these purposes, if not flawlessly, at least good enough to get by? I'm leaning to HDTV/movies and gaming being more important than the web browsing part, if that matters much.
 
Essentially any HDTV will do the trick. It depends a lot on what the computer has for video (and perhaps sound).

I don't think you realize just how open ended your question is. If your PC has DVI video ports then the HDTV needs DVI, HDMI, or VGA ports on it (any one will do fine but if you get one with 2 or all 3 then all the better). You can convert the DVI output on the PC to any of those three options easily and get 1080p resolution. DVI to DVI is the easiest choice since you can simply use a normal computer monitor cable. DVI to HDMI requires either a dongle or a cable that makes the switch. Same goes for DVI to VGA (most DVI video cards these days come with a DVI to VGA dongle). If your PC puts video out on VGA then you need to do a bit of research as I'm not quite sure VGA upscales to HDMI/DVI. The obvious and easy solution to that matter is to look for a HDTV with a VGA port and you will have no problems at all.

Now, when it comes to audio output to a HDTV it really starts to get complicated. I've been pulling my hair out trying to nail down the best solution for getting my PC sound to my HDTV. HDMI is wonderful since it can carry HD video and HD audio on one cable, but there is a massive void in the PC realm when it comes to getting audio onto a HDMI cable. There are options out there, but information is very blotchy and hard to find on the matter. I've been reading for a couple of days now and still am not quite sure how to solve the puzzle. The easy solution to audio is to use a set of PC speakers the same way you would if you were using a normal computer monitor instead of an actual TV. It is also fairly easy to put audio out to a normal AV reciever and get good sound.

FYI, I am using a 47" Olevia 247T FHD LCD HDTV for my soon-to-be-here HTPC. I tested the picture out by moving my current desktop system into the living room and the Olevia had no problem what-so-ever displaying 1920x1080 resolution via a DVI to VGA cable. The 247T can be found on bargais sites these days for about $1000 USD or less.

Good luck, hopefully I didn't make this more complicated than it already was.
 
Thanks for the advice! I think my search is simplified by the fact that the video I'm getting has an HDMI out (the new ATi chipsets :p) and sound won't be going through the TV but through a separate stereo system using S/PDIF. But if as you say most HDTVs will work fine for both, then perfect! :p
 
What is your budget? That's going to have a huge impact on the recommendations.

Panasonic VIERA (Plasma) and Sharp AQUOS (LCD) are probably going to be the two best choices right now, but they're a little pricey.
 
Definately get some more desires IE inputs etc for the TV before you go. If you can (shouldnt be too hard) get a DVI input just to keep it digital. Do your research, some LCD's that have a VGA input have locked resolutions on them so you wont get 1080 out of your PC.

There are a lot of good brands, those mentioned above as well as Samsung in the LCD front, Mitsubishi in the DLP as well as Samsung with the LED bulbs, Sony has some good LCD's but you really pay for the name on those usually. There are others not yet named just do some good research before buying a less well known brand. To that end if the place your reading is all negative definately read up elsewhere to get another opinion as people love to vent online :)

I would stay away from Poleroid, Olevia's are decent but when I worked retail they had good quality but high failure rate (could be fixed). Vizio's were another good brand but we would get batches that were bad and others that were great, seemed to alternate every few weeks.
 
be careful on the choice of connection some HDTVs only allow 1024 x768 through the VGA port
 
I bought a samsung 40a550 1080P LCD tv a month ago and it is pretty nice.
I have it hooked up to my pc with a dvi->hdmi cable and it was cake to get 1080p setup properly. Just pick 1920x1080 as the resolution on the pc for that output, and then pick 'Just Scan' as the aspect ratio/zoom mode on the tv. No overscan, and im pretty sure you get 1:1 pixels - it passed a alternating black/white pixel test at least.

I have it on my desk, but 40" is too big to use as a pc monitor, 32 or 37" 1080p would probably be better if you intend to try and use it as a pc monitor.

I have not tried the vga input on it.

Im using it with a nvidia 8800GTS-640 + vista home premium. Media center works very nice on it, but is a little wonky on a dual screen setup.
 
For the record my budget is sub-$3000 CAD. I'm looking for lots of HDMI (computer will have HDMI out).
 
you also may want to expand your research to www.avsforum.com They have an HTPC section also, but their Display section is beyond what this mere mortal will ever be able to fully appreciate. Just that much information...

BTW, I think the new'ish Samsung 71 series may be right up your ally esp the 46" version.
 
Back
Top