A bit of a rant

Buford

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 16, 2004
Messages
130
My current workstation is about 2 years old. It is a P4 2.8 system, with IDE RAID. I have a few dimes and I want a new monster system. My last AMD system never resolved problems with USB interrupts so I am resolved to stay with Intel.

Well I start looking at ASUS P5AD2 because I want to keep some DVD+RW and large IDE drives but I read the P5AD2 have teething problems.

Then I read about the newest and fastest Intel CPU but they only make a lot of heat and are only 30-40% quicker than what I have.

With a new system, the most I can reuse is my old case and floppy drive. The AGP video card, power supply, MB, memory, SATA HD and CPU would all have to be new.

In the past I could upgrade to new system in parts for $1000-$1200 and get 8-10 times faster every few years. This upgrade looks more like $1,800-$2000 for only 40% quicker, most of the improvement due to SATA drives.

I am thinking wait another 6-9 months but I don’t know if Intel will have what I expect even then, the way their road maps keeps slipping.

Should I be angry at Moore or the laws of physics?

While I am ranting, last P4 3.2 system I built was quick until I loaded a firewall and virus protection then the apparent speed dropped by half. If it wasn’t for the little snots writing worms none of us would need a new PC. I would like to meet those guys someday.
 
You do realize if you go with an Athlon64 system you can keep everything except the motherboard and CPU. I guess you're resolved to spend a lot of money too. I'm not sure what problems you had with USB, but I can't imagine you running into any on a current AMD platform.
 
I am tempted to give AMD another try. I just ripped 2 DVDs to disk (at the same time)while checking E mail and doing a few print jobs. I am told (asking, not picking fights) Intel does a much better job of multitasking then AMD.

If I was a game player, I am not, AMD would be the way to go.

I could also get a $90 MB and a $250 Intel CPU and gain SATA which I want and save $1500 and consider that close enough for a year.

On a typical day I may get 3-4 DVDs by mail at about noon and the goal is to rip them to disk and get them back in the mail on the same day. The goal is to rip faster, I would buy another DVD drive and rip 3 at a time if I had the HP.
 
Yes, an Intel motherboard with a Hyperthreading CPU is going to probably suit your usage better.

To me, when I'm looking at an upgrade, it's all about cost vs benefit. If I have to swap out a lot of components, that's a major upgrade and in that case I would be concerned about maximum future upgradability, meaning get support for all the latest technologies. PCI-E, SATA, socket 939 (Athlon64) or 775 (Intel with DDR2), 24pin ATX power supply, etc.
 
At the same time my laptop is getting tired, I may go Dell XPS or Alienware in a laptop first, then wait 6 months before I upgrade the workstation. If I wait for new chipsets, better (cooler & quicker) CPUs it is for the best.

Thanks for the come back. I haven't spent much time on Hardforum since my last major upgrade 2 years ago. If I lurk & research here for a while when I do move I'll have a better system for my bucks.
 
Back
Top