• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

9800Pro vs 6600GT

karmasore

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 1, 2005
Messages
68
Hey all,

I'm ordering a new video card after work tomorrow and I having problems deciding between a 9800Pro or a 6600GT....any suggestions guys?

Thanks in advance!
 
The 6600 GT blows the 9800 Pro out of the water. The 6600 GT is able to crank up the eye candy, and AF has almost no performance hit (on non uber-high resolutions).
 
have to agree with booya... this was something i had thought about a few months ago. from all i've researched, the 6600gt is the way to go
 
9800 Pro = ~2500 in 3DMARK05
6600GT = ~3800 in 3DMARK05

i personally get 4K with my 6600GT at 550/1050
 
arman01 said:
9800 Pro = ~2500 in 3DMARK05
6600GT = ~3800 in 3DMARK05

i personally get 4K with my 6600GT at 550/1050
Don't start giving him the idea to purchase hardware based off of 3dmark scores! :p Anyways, I agree with the above posters, the 6600GT is quite a bit better.
 
Pozotron said:
Does the 6600GT come in a 256mb version?

ive seen one newegg, but only 1 company i think, not sure, good luck finding it
 
0810 said:
ive seen one newegg, but only 1 company i think, not sure, good luck finding it

DO NOT GET A 256MEG 6600GT. That is about as silly as the people who bought the 256MB 9600XT. :confused:

The 6600GT has a fairly "light" memory bandwdith and also since it is only a 8pipe device you will not be able to crank the AA/AF to levels where 256MB would be needed. Just please don't think that more memory = much faster card. It has already been shown that 512MB cards are a joke.

It is an easy slope to slide down...just trying to keep your wallet a bit more full. Also the more memory typically cripples your OC.

-tReP
 
Trepidati0n said:
DO NOT GET A 256MEG 6600GT. That is about as silly as the people who bought the 256MB 9600XT. :confused:

The 6600GT has a fairly "light" memory bandwdith and also since it is only a 8pipe device you will not be able to crank the AA/AF to levels where 256MB would be needed. Just please don't think that more memory = much faster card. It has already been shown that 512MB cards are a joke.

It is an easy slope to slide down...just trying to keep your wallet a bit more full. Also the more memory typically cripples your OC.

-tReP

true dat. if you need the 256ram... best to skip lunch for a few weeks save the $ and get the 6800gt
 
Thanks for your suggestions, guys! I really appreciate it...I'm kinda noobish when it comes to video cards...in March, I bought an openbox ati 9550 256mb card for 90 bucks at Circuit City and it sucks so horribly bad...I used it for a while and noticed some improvement over my GeForce2 TI 64mb card, but I've been playing a lot of WoW recently and my 9550 seriously chokes hard...

One thing that I'm curious about, however, is that the 9800Pro is a 256bit card while the 6600GT is a 128bit card...what is the difference? Should I worry about such an issue?

Thanks again!

EDIT: I suppose I should ask...where can I find a decent (and reasonably cheap!) 6600GT?
 
256mb on a 6600GT is a marketing ploy and a waste of money, get a 128mb 6600GT or spend a wee bit more and get a nice 6800NU
 
newegg. There's one for $144. I think that's about the lowest I've seen a 6600GT.
 
karmasore said:
Thanks for your suggestions, guys! I really appreciate it...I'm kinda noobish when it comes to video cards...in March, I bought an openbox ati 9550 256mb card for 90 bucks at Circuit City and it sucks so horribly bad...I used it for a while and noticed some improvement over my GeForce2 TI 64mb card, but I've been playing a lot of WoW recently and my 9550 seriously chokes hard...

One thing that I'm curious about, however, is that the 9800Pro is a 256bit card while the 6600GT is a 128bit card...what is the difference? Should I worry about such an issue?

Thanks again!

EDIT: I suppose I should ask...where can I find a decent (and reasonably cheap!) 6600GT?

It isn't how many bits you have it is how fast you can move those bits. The RAM on the 6800NU is only 700MHz. The RAM on the 6600GT is 1GHz (min). Even though the 6800NU has double the memory width it can't get the data 2x as fast (only about 1.4x). My order of preference is pixel pipelines --> bus width --> core speed --> mem speed --> amount of mem.

The architecture of the 6600GT is also superior ot that of the 9800pro. The 9700/9800 series was rocking during its time, but the nVidia 6xxxx pounded the snot of them (increase in core speed, pipelines, and efficiency per clock). Just the facts. I think Toms and Anand both have fairly good reviews. I'm pretty sure Toms just had a AGP and PCIe round up (excluding the 7800GTX). Be easy to compare.
 
karmasore said:
One thing that I'm curious about, however, is that the 9800Pro is a 256bit card while the 6600GT is a 128bit card...what is the difference? Should I worry about such an issue?

Yes, but in both performance and feature set the 6600GT is still better performance. This is where the number of bits versus work performed makes a big difference.

If a 32-bit card were to be released that had the performance and featureset in performance of everything today, I'd buy it. It's the performance that's important, not the number of bits.
 
I currently have a 9800pro...I figure to make only one more video upgrade on this board before i overhaul everything. (because the board is AGP). If we're saying there isn't a big difference between 128 or 256mb of ram, should I go for the 6600GT or the x700pro?

I'm just trying to get the best bang for the buck for BF2, without the overhaul just yet.
 
Pozotron said:
I currently have a 9800pro...I figure to make only one more video upgrade on this board before i overhaul everything. (because the board is AGP). If we're saying there isn't a big difference between 128 or 256mb of ram, should I go for the 6600GT or the x700pro?

I'm just trying to get the best bang for the buck for BF2, without the overhaul just yet.

The X700 Pro is not that good a card, compared to the 6600 GT. The 6600 GT performs very well with BF2. I run it at 1024x768 and I have 4x AA and 8x AF turned on, as well as almost every setting on high (shadows are off and lighting is at medium).
 
Back
Top