9600 GT or HD 4670?

The 9600GT is just a wee bit faster. The 4670 slots in between the 9500GT and the 9600GT.
 
In terms of performance, it's not. The 9600 GT is faster, so if you want the best performer, get the 9600 GT. The HD 4670 is a decent performer, but it's big advantage is really the fact that it's very small, which makes it a good choice for small cases and doesn't need external power.
 
The 9600GT is just a wee bit faster. The 4670 slots in between the 9500GT and the 9600GT.

The 9600 GT is quite a bit faster actually, especially as you go up in resolution, due to the HD 4670's "weak" memory interface of just 128 bit.
 
The 9600 GT is quite a bit faster actually, especially as you go up in resolution, due to the HD 4670's "weak" memory interface of just 128 bit.
You sure about that? It's about even with the 8800GS/9600GSO.
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3405&p=7

The 8800GS/9600GSO with 768MB is consistently faster than the 9600GT, let's say the 384MB is "only" comparable.
http://lly316.blogspot.com/2008/11/8800gs-vs-9600gso-vs-9600gt-bechmark.html

Edit:
Those tests aren't at hi-res, I'm trying to find some.
 
In terms of performance, it's not. The 9600 GT is faster, so if you want the best performer, get the 9600 GT. The HD 4670 is a decent performer, but it's big advantage is really the fact that it's very small, which makes it a good choice for small cases and doesn't need external power.

This. The 4670 is great for adding gaming functionality to a mediocre store bought PC. If the PC is custom built by you and you're just adding a video card to it, then I would go with the 9600GT.
 
Touche.

(Just curious about the 9600GT/9800GT placement here. *Confused*)

It happens. HL2 specifically is extremely CPU bound, so @ a low res, the 64 Stream Processors of the 9600 GT are more than enough and the clock and memory frequencies play a higher role. Tech-Report's 9600 GT is a factory overclocked 9600 GT, with clocks far superior to the 9800 GT reference model, which give it the edge.
 
C2D E8400
just 2 GB DDR2 800 for now
Gigabyte P45 mobo with PCIE 2.0
WD 7200 RPM HDD, 16 MB Cache

Obviously not a hard core gaming machine. I've been battling between various passively cooled cards in the $100 range that'll give me good midrange capability. These seem like the best deals I can find.

EDIT: I'd grab this up in a second if it'd just become available on Newegg, it's the overclocked 9600 GT I think you're talking about:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814125098

I've been waaaaaiting.
 
You sure about that? It's about even with the 8800GS/9600GSO.
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3405&p=7

The 8800GS/9600GSO with 768MB is consistently faster than the 9600GT, let's say the 384MB is "only" comparable.
http://lly316.blogspot.com/2008/11/8800gs-vs-9600gso-vs-9600gt-bechmark.html

Edit:
Those tests aren't at hi-res, I'm trying to find some.

1. Those tests have been massaged to find instances where the 384MB 192bit 9600GSO's larger number of stream processors overrides the higher clocks and larger memory bus width on the 512MB 256bit 9600GT. That is, low res.

2. The 768MB GSOs that I've seen are made with GDDR2, not GDDR3. This is a HUGE nerf and is why those GSOs are overpriced. The 9600GT owns those.

3. I browsed newegg's selection of 9600GSOs. What a bizarre mix of custom-nerfed cards. There's a 1GB version... with GDDR2 on a 128bit memory bus - that is going to suck. There's 128bit and 256bit versions of the 512MB 9600GSO. You have to be really careful to look at ALL the specs when buying a 9600GSO. They are messing with you.
 
Really the thing that threw me was the 1 GB in the 4670 vs. the 512 in the 9600 GT, as well as the 4670 having five times as many stream processors. But it sounds like evilsofa is saying the 128bit bus on the 4670 is a decisive disadvantage.
 
Yah, the 4670 is a great htpc card, for moderate gaming, or a card to throw in dell/hp store bought computers, but not really a good dedicated graphics card.

I would almost look for a 4830 in comparison, if you can swing the extra cash for it.

Looks like on new egg, 4830's are around 100-120 out of pocket, with many rebates, around the same range as the 9600gt, and the 4830 is a bit faster.

Although if your looking for passive cooling, the 9600gt is better
 
Ultimately the 9600GT gets to be faster than the 4670 because it can draw more power - the 9600GT needs one 6-pin PCI-E power connector, while the 4670 needs none. The 4670 is probably the best card that needs no power cord plugged into it.

1GB versus 512MB RAM is not going to make any difference on a 4670. More than 512MB isn't necessary unless you're gaming at 1920x1200 or higher - and at those resolutions, yes, 128bit is going to be a major nerf; for those resolutions you should be looking at the 4850 or better. The 512MB versions go for as little as $70 - you should look at those instead of this $115 version.
 
Wait wait wait, what are you doing looking at those cards? They each cost about 120, when you can get a 4830, which outperforms both by a fair margin, for 20 bucks less?
 
Wait wait wait, what are you doing looking at those cards? They each cost about 120, when you can get a 4830, which outperforms both by a fair margin, for 20 bucks less?


Did you see post #12 where he said he is looking for a passively cooled card?
 
Back
Top