939 Support ECC?

Kingofl337

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Nov 18, 2003
Messages
850
I'm looking to build a server for a customer who wan't ECC but the current line up of Opteron MB's aren't anything special and usually cost quiet a bit. Do the 939 CPU's support ECC?
 
It was a requirement for the socket 940 Athlon FX's to have ECC memory but i believe any processor will support ECC memory. Although i could be wrong :).
 
since only the 940 uses it. At this point in time, i believe it would be a choice between the Opteron or no ECC
 
The memory controller in the Athlon 64 CPU supports ECC. Most of the product descriptions of motherboards on the manufacturers' web sites claim that the motheboards don't support ECC. That means that either the people who write the product descriptions get it wrong a lot, or some motherboard manufacturers aren't accomodating the processor's ECC capability (I suppose they could do that by leaving out the extra data lines from the CPU socket to the DIMM sockets that are necessary for ECC).

I've seen at least one motherboard - Asus A8V Deluxe - where the specifications on the web site say "no ECC", but the product manual says that it does support ECC.

I suspect that in most cases it's a mistake in the published specifications.
 
I belive most motherboard product descriptions say something like DDR400/DDR333/DDR266 non-ECC un-buffered DDR SDRAM memory. They dont really say that it doesn't support ECC. There just isn't any point in using ECC unless your building a server so they say to choose non-ECC so nOObs dont purchase ECC RAM.

http://usa.asus.com/prog/spec.asp?m=A8N-SLI Deluxe&langs=09

The ASUS A8N SLI board says ECC and non-ECC in its product description.
 
The Thunder K8W is a mad opteron board, though a little pricey. Does it have to be Athlon btw? if you don't like the opteron line up, why not go with xeon? theres a larger selection of boards and dual-xeon would own any 939 no matter what when it came to doing constructive stuff.

If its for a workstation or desktop PC, then ECC is just a waste of money. Buy a P4 or 939 with normal DDR memory instead and tell them to stop being a sucker for advertising :p
 
Back
Top