939 NF3 vs VIA

scorpy

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
116
I am hoping to purchase a 3500+ here in the next week or so, but I am having trouble deciding between the two chipsets. I have been using the Nforce2, but Nvidia drivers have been less than optimal. High cpu usage for the network being a common problem with NF2 boards that comes to mind. Anyone using the NF3 that can claim the drivers work ok? I am talking straight from Nvidia, no tweaking.

As for VIA, I have never used them and do not know anything about them. How are they for stability/drivers? My only concern is the lack of the hardware firewall which is a NF3 exclusive. I am considering either a Asus A8V or the MSI K8N Neo2 (when it becomes available). I have heard problems with RAM/power supply incompatibilites with Abit, so I am avoiding them. I am open to other reasonably priced motherboards (~$150), but these are my current choices. Any input you have would be greatly appreciated, thanks!!
 
My Asus A8V is my first ever VIA chipset board and i just have to say i've had no problems with it what-so-ever and i'm pretty impressed by it. I just bought this board as a temporary one for when DFI's or Epox's s939 NF3 boards hit the market (which is taking a damned long time), but I like it and may keep it until NF4 is released. I've had 0 problems with the VIA drivers (i just used the ones off of the CD, haven't looked for any updates to them). The board has working agp/pci locks as well if you update to the 1005.20 or 1005.21 beta bios's.

As for the MSI NF3 board, i've heard that board has some issues (but so do most of the others ones as well). And personally, i wouldn't touch anything MSI with a 50ft pole so i'm kind of biased when it comes to them.

I'd either go with the Gigabyte NF3 board or the A8V like you're already considering. The gigabyte board has working locks out of the box, but once you update the Asus board to those bios's it really becomes the best choice for s939 out right now.
 
VIA has seems to have really shapen up with their new chipsets. The Gigabyte board has a few problems such as the temp sensor and OpenGL performance. Read this review here and you'll see why:

http://www.amdzone.com/modules.php?...ns&file=index&req=viewarticle&artid=37&page=1

In OpenGL the VIA was 30fps faster in Quake3, and DooM 3 will probably carry over the same % hit as some people who experience problems in Q3 usually have the same problem in DooM3. In other benchmarks the VIA matches or beats the NF3.

I'd reccomend the ABIT AV8 unless you want wireless ethernet and 2 extra SATA connectors for $30 more. Also if you do a search on google:

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&q=ASUS+A8V+PCI+AGP+lock

You'll see not everyone can get their PCI/AGP lock to work with the ASUS A8V as VIA failed to inform them of the feature in time so it is not properly implemented. It is luck of the draw with the ASUS if you want a working PCI/AGP lock.

If you don't OC then you are fine with either one, just choose the one that suits you.
 
Bop said:
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&q=ASUS+A8V+PCI+AGP+lock

You'll see not everyone can get their PCI/AGP lock to work with the ASUS A8V as VIA failed to inform them of the feature in time so it is not properly implemented. It is luck of the draw with the ASUS if you want a working PCI/AGP lock.

almost every board bought in the US will have the locks work. It's the boards sold in Europe that have problems with the bios and the locks not working at all. I bought my board the first few weeks it was released and the locks work perfectly.

http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums...1&perpage=25&highlight=Abit AV8*&pagenumber=1 (especially read the last page) The abit's locks might work, but it has many other problems...what good are locks if you can't oc that high anyway. The asus board probably has a 95-99% chance that the bios will give you locks.
 
I guess both are equal when it comes to lemons and such, that first guy seemed to be the only person with AV8 problems. They also might be using Rev 1.0, ABIT has released a new revision(1.1) and some people can get up to a 300mhz FSB :)

Some guy there hit 3.1ghz with his ABIT board:p Also Anandtech gave the AV8 the silver(the gold was given to the MSI board that isn't even out yet).

Its just up to if you want the wireless internet and the extra 2 SATA connectors. Either way you get a good motherboard.
 
Bop said:
Some guy there hit 3.1ghz with his ABIT board:p Also Anandtech gave the AV8 the silver(the gold was given to the MSI board that isn't even out yet).

if you noticed the second to last post in the thread he was using a PCI video card to get that high :p, he couldn't get over 240 with AGP. That's also a pretty old thread (6-20ish) and i guarantee they were using the old revision board...i haven't heard anything about abit's new revision. For me the extra 2 SATA's were a must, i need a minimum of 4...never tried the wireless on my board because i already had a linksys wireless pci card and i just prefer to use that.

I also haven't heard anything about the MSI one, but msi = no touchy for me. I'd search forums like here, anand, and xtremesystems for info on that board.
 
Is the ASUS rev 2.0 out yet? If so then that would be the best option.

I might be ordering my 3500+ today but if the ASUS A8V revision 2.0 isn't out yet then I'm going with the ABIT AV8.
 
Bop said:
Is the ASUS rev 2.0 out yet? If so then that would be the best option.

I might be ordering my 3500+ today but if the ASUS A8V revision 2.0 isn't out yet then I'm going with the ABIT AV8.

I don't think it's out yet
 
According to the review at Anandtech the nForce3 boards come out over the VIA boards as far as raw performance goes. Check out the socket 939 board comparison there: http://www.anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2128.

I went with the Gigabyte board and it's smokin fast. I don't see any lackluster OpenGL performance (Call of Duty runs perfectly with all settings jacked up, and I get an 81fps timedemo in Doom 3). The temp monitor is something I can't confirm since I am not currently using one in Windows. In BIOS it says my CPU is 38C, which seems right. Hopefully they release a BIOS update very soon to fix this problem for all those who have it.

I was planning on getting the MSI nForce3 board but it's still not out yet. I guess they're still trying to iron out all their issues with the previous nForce3 Neo Platinum board. The Gigabyte is pricey but I'm happy with it. Rock solid
 
Can anyone here comfirm or deny whether these motherboards make any component noise? eg- turn off ALL your fans and any other noise producing items (hard drive etc) for several seconds and listen to see if the inductors or other components on the motherboard itself are making any noise? Yes, I'm a silence freak.

Even better if SETI was running at the time, as that's what really sets mine off.

My current motherboard is noisy bastard -- The inductors hiss. If I'm spending $500+ on a 939 combo, I want to get my money's worth.
 
v3rt1g0 said:
Can anyone here comfirm or deny whether these motherboards make any component noise? eg- turn off ALL your fans and any other noise producing items (hard drive etc) for several seconds and listen to see if the inductors or other components on the motherboard itself are making any noise? Yes, I'm a silence freak.

Even better if SETI was running at the time, as that's what really sets mine off.

My current motherboard is noisy bastard -- The inductors hiss. If I'm spending $500+ on a 939 combo, I want to get my money's worth.

I'm a noise (silence?) freak myself. I'm such a silence freak that I bought this case (Lian Li PC-V1100) when I was making the rest of my upgrades: http://www.silverpcs.com/product/CS_PCV1100b

Totally insulated, quiet 120mm fans, baffling everywhere, great layout, space for days, and it's awesome. My PSU is an Enermax 470W Noisetaker, my CPU heatsink is a Thermaltake Silent Boost, and my videocard is the Leadtek 6800GT with the big (quiet) HSF. It is the quietest one on the market as far as I know.

As far as I can tell, my Gigabyte board doesn't seem to make very much noise at all, despite having two tiny fans on it. I can barely hear my system at all, but I wonder how much the case has to do with it. The only thing I can really hear is when my WD 10,000 RPM Raptor is working. Otherwise, dead quiet.
 
For now I think the best option is:

A. If you have the money get the VIA for now, and when the Neo2 Platinum is released wait for some user feedback and if its good jump with that.

B. Wait for the Neo2 Platinum period.
 
Other than the price, there hasn't been a resounding reason to go VIA. I dunno, maybe it is all the fascination surrounding the Nforce3 hardware firewall. I like having the added security of that firewall. I just hate to switch over if it will cause more headaches. I do not needed SATA or wireless at all currently, so those features make me consider the Abit. No sense paying premium for unneeded features.

All other whining aside, does the onboard audio for the Abit sound crisp, and full? I hate having audio that lacks a good bass when needed. I know I can't complain about onboard sound, but for a simple 2.1 audio setup this works ok. I can't spend $100 on a Audigy if I am only using 2 speakers. My biggest issue is audio crackling in games. My current setup did that for as long as I can remember before a successful driver release fixed it. I would like to avoid a repeat of that. Hopefully someone can help me, as you can see I am hard to please. I appreciate all the posts though, I love info!
 
I forgot the one problem with the Abit board. Some people were reporting it was picky about power supplies, and did not like the Antec series. Considering that will be my new power supply, I am concerned about that. Also there was something about memory incompatibilities, but I think that a 512 stick of Corsair PC3200 should be ok. I can't remember the exact details, maybe someone else remembers better?
 
I ordered an ABIT AV8, I can tell you whether it works with my Antec PSU or not when it gets in. I read about the issue too, I hope I don't have that problem.

If you want good audio I'd reccomend getting a $50 Audigy LS if that is cheap enough fr you, I don't plan on using onboard audio so I can't tell you how good it will be.

EDIT: I was browsing the ABIT forums and the moderator says that ABIT will be releasing a temp monitor fix within 48hours, and they said that yesterday. That will fix the problem of people seeing temps of up to 78C by just burning a CD lol.
 
So to get back on topic. Anyone used the current Nforce drivers with the NF3 boards? Are they the usual Nvidia (questionable) quality, or truly good drivers? There is always issues to be fixed by the community before I touch them. I keep hoping Nvidia will release a really good, stable set of drivers. Time will tell......
 
Im a bit biased towards MSI, I really like them. All of my motherboards that I am using currently are manufactured by MSI and I have had no problems at all with them. I would suggest that you buy an MSI board but the Nforce3 options seem to be a little less stable than the Via equivelant. I would suggest the MSI k8t Neo2 FIR board, it has been awarded a couple of editors choice awards and has beaten its Asus competition in a majority of benchmarks (although the margin was negligable)
 
nighthawk said:
Im a bit biased towards MSI, I really like them. All of my motherboards that I am using currently are manufactured by MSI and I have had no problems at all with them. I would suggest that you buy an MSI board but the Nforce3 options seem to be a little less stable than the Via equivelant. I would suggest the MSI k8t Neo2 FIR board, it has been awarded a couple of editors choice awards and has beaten its Asus competition in a majority of benchmarks (although the margin was negligable)

I would go the VIA route, but I was REALLY surprised at how much more performance the Nforce version of their board offered. I've never seen such a large gap in performance offered by simply using a different motherboard.
 
Back
Top