8800GTX or HD2900XT?

edliu512

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 2, 2004
Messages
102
GTX cost about 70$ more than 2900XT and has 256mb more memory, but 2900XT has 512bit memory compared to GTX's 384bit, and significantly more stream processors.

Which one is better?
 
GTX is better, 2900 is broken atm and who knows how it will perform when its fixed. The best performance drivers for it don't do AA / HDR correctly so the results are higher than they should be.
 
GTX cost about 70$ more than 2900XT and has 256mb more memory, but 2900XT has 512bit memory compared to GTX's 384bit, and significantly more stream processors.

Which one is better?

There's just no question about it. The 8800 GTX is the better card by a mile. The HD 2900 XT does have amazing specs, but when actually performing in games, it's a disapointement, since it only competes with a 8800 GTS 640.
So you'll find that those extra $70 will be more than worth it. Just remember that you also need a good CPU to feed the card or you won't take full advantage of the tremendous power of the GTX.
 
when you say this, what processor would you say is the minimum to take advantage of a gtx? I've got a core 2 duo e6420@2.13ghz...currently have an xfx 8800 gts 320 XT model, but thinking of going GTX in the next 6 months when they come down. so would the processor take advantage of it?
 
when you say this, what processor would you say is the minimum to take advantage of a gtx? I've got a core 2 duo e6420@2.13ghz...currently have an xfx 8800 gts 320 XT model, but thinking of going GTX in the next 6 months when they come down. so would the processor take advantage of it?

That's good enough.
 
GTX cost about 70$ more than 2900XT and has 256mb more memory, but 2900XT has 512bit memory compared to GTX's 384bit, and significantly more stream processors.

Which one is better?

If you got the extra 70 dollars its money well spent.
 
I can't believe this thread even exists.
OP, did you even bother reading any reviews of these two cards?
 
What is that supposed to prove? I see the 2900xt getting beaten badly by both nvidia cards in almost every game. I would cherry pick a different review if you're trying to credit the 2900xt.

I think the reason he linked to that review is to show which card the OP should buy...
 
What is that supposed to prove? I see the 2900xt getting beaten badly by both nvidia cards in almost every game. I would cherry pick a different review if you're trying to credit the 2900xt.

Haste266 was making the point that the 8800GTX is obviously superior, and evilcartman was agreeing. The linked review supports that conclusion. Since you seem to agree with both of them, what exactly are you arguing about?
 
The bottom line is that the 2900XT is a $320 video card selling close to $450 now in some places. AMD must think people are really stupid. :rolleyes:

If you're going to spend that kind of money then spend a little more and get the 8800GTX.
 
Haste266 was making the point that the 8800GTX is obviously superior, and evilcartman was agreeing. The linked review supports that conclusion. Since you seem to agree with both of them, what exactly are you arguing about?

That's true. That link wasn't meant to start a flame war. I was agreeing with Haste266 in that he was wondering if the OP actually read any reviews about the card. I just threw up a link to the [H] article and seeing that we're on the [H] forums, I thought it would be best to give the first link to our 'hosts'.


On a side note, there are a number of other quality reviews out there...some which have the same conclusion as [H] while others don't. The point of being a consumer is to make your own decision as to what is best for you to buy.
 
I am pretty sure that most of the early reviews slated the 2900XT as an inferior card... maybe now it got better, but its already too little too late for this card.
 
It doesn't matter what reviews you read. The HD 2900XT gets beaten by the 8800GTS 320MB and 640MB cards in some tests, and it wins in others. One thing is certain, the HD 2900XT gets raped by the 8800GTX 99% of the time.
 
Yep... but from the marks i saw... all of the nvidia cards won the majority of tests.
 
The bottom line is that the 2900XT is a $320 video card selling close to $450 now in some places. AMD must think people are really stupid. :rolleyes:

If you're going to spend that kind of money then spend a little more and get the 8800GTX.

People are really stupid though... :p
 
GTX cost about 70$ more than 2900XT and has 256mb more memory, but 2900XT has 512bit memory compared to GTX's 384bit, and significantly more stream processors.

Which one is better?

Another good question is, can the GTX fit in your case?

I may be able to barely squeeze in a GTX if I want. (I run a GTS at the moment because I didn't want to take any chances when they first came out).
 
Another good question is, can the GTX fit in your case?

I may be able to barely squeeze in a GTX if I want. (I run a GTS at the moment because I didn't want to take any chances when they first came out).

I don't understand this type of thinking. If I have a case that won't work for a new component, I get a different case. I don't short change myself the components I really want or need because of something relatively inexpensive like a case.

I recnetly went through this actually. My Coolermaster Stacker 830 wouldn't support the use of longer PSUs because of two metal tabs on the roof of the case that allow you to mount a fan up in that mesh area. Rather than hack my case up and ghetto the crap out of it I decided to sell the CM Stacker and I grabbed a P182 on short notice to fill the void. Not ideal but workable for the moment. I needed to buy another case anyway for my new domain controller and I thought what the hell. I'll grab this and if I can't use it for my main system I'll just use it for my server and get something else for the gaming rig. I was thinking about grabbing some kind of Lian-Li or a Stacker Evolution, possibly the older STC-T01 which I've had before and go that route. I liked the P182 so much that I tracked down a P190 and decided to go with it.

Point is a case shouldn't be that big a deal to replace if you are buying $500+ video cards. Granted some people will be in different and perhaps odd situations where this won't be possible but generally when I have the ability to buy a high end video card, which is the most important part of my machine when it comes to playing games, I make everything else work around that part if need be.
 
I don't understand this type of thinking. If I have a case that won't work for a new component, I get a different case. I don't short change myself the components I really want or need because of something relatively inexpensive like a case.

I recnetly went through this actually. My Coolermaster Stacker 830 wouldn't support the use of longer PSUs because of two metal tabs on the roof of the case that allow you to mount a fan up in that mesh area. Rather than hack my case up and ghetto the crap out of it I decided to sell the CM Stacker and I grabbed a P182 on short notice to fill the void. Not ideal but workable for the moment. I needed to buy another case anyway for my new domain controller and I thought what the hell. I'll grab this and if I can't use it for my main system I'll just use it for my server and get something else for the gaming rig. I was thinking about grabbing some kind of Lian-Li or a Stacker Evolution, possibly the older STC-T01 which I've had before and go that route. I liked the P182 so much that I tracked down a P190 and decided to go with it.

Point is a case shouldn't be that big a deal to replace if you are buying $500+ video cards. Granted some people will be in different and perhaps odd situations where this won't be possible but generally when I have the ability to buy a high end video card, which is the most important part of my machine when it comes to playing games, I make everything else work around that part if need be.

Well when you had just bought a decent case recently (a month or two ago at the time) and spent about $150 on it, plus you were pretty sure your power supply (at the time) wouldn't be able to handle a GTX (which would have been another $150-200+) and you account on the resell value of your current graphics card (7900GTX) and the performance/price ratio, plus the amount of the Dell coupon you had on hand, plus the price of the just released cards. This all amounts to more than I wanted to spend. Plus I considered the price of a second 7900GTX card for SLI compared to a faster solution of a single 8800GTS (plus overclocking it). Plus I had just recently purchased a Dell 3007WFP monitor. Plus I was only running (at that time) an S939 X2 3800+. I haven't had any issues or regrets with going the way I did. Did I eventually upgrade my power supply, motherboard, and processor? Sure because I got a bonus.

Edit: Plus I like my case!
 
but going through 2 or 3 cases at +$150 each adds up.

With proper research it doesn't need to happen. All you would need to do is find pictures of an 8800GTX inside any given case and that would yeild the answer. In my case I wasn't able to find alot of people with 1Kw + PSUs and my P182 purchase was kind of an impulse buy. Though I did measure the PSU and the case to ensure I could install it in the case. I knew it would be right but it works fine. My main reason for going to a P190 is that there is going to be more room for my hard drives. They are the reason the fan in the lower chamber had to be removed. My SAS cabling creates the clearance issues and prevent me from installing a fan in that area.
 
Maybe he meant AMD thinks these people buying these cards are stupid, because AMD knows how much the price/performance ratio sucks compared to the GTX for a few dollars more.
 
Iam so glad 99% 3D card buyers don´t read these forums, because if that was the case, both Nvidia and ATI would have gone belly up along time ago. One bad card = Company in grave ;)

One of my customer is actually changing his card from 8800GTS -> 2900XT, I have tried to reason with him, but he is too fed up with Nvidias Vista drivers. The whole machine has been a disaster from the beginning, so Iam not blaiming him. Lesson learned, do not jump the gun with new OS and believe all the "[nsert OS name here] READY" stickers :p
 
Iam so glad 99% 3D card buyers don´t read these forums, because if that was the case, both Nvidia and ATI would have gone belly up along time ago. One bad card = Company in grave ;)

One of my customer is actually changing his card from 8800GTS -> 2900XT, I have tried to reason with him, but he is too fed up with Nvidias Vista drivers. The whole machine has been a disaster from the beginning, so Iam not blaiming him. Lesson learned, do not jump the gun with new OS and believe all the "[nsert OS name here] READY" stickers :p

The initial Vista drivers indeed sucked. The ones that are out now aren't bad at all really. I've had great stability and excellent performance. It's getting much closer to where it needs to be. I believe that DX10 SLI has been finally enabled with the latest drivers as well.
 
Yea the situation screams of User Fault, but who am I to argue with the customer. Customer is always right :mad:

edit:

But Iam not complaining, I intend to snag the 8800GTS from him with a rip off price :p
 
Yea the situation screams of User Fault, but who am I to argue with the customer. Customer is always right :mad:

edit:

But Iam not complaining, I intend to snag the 8800GTS from him with a rip off price :p


That works.
 
O, man!!! LOL LOL
AMD doesn't set the selling prices. The market does.
I was talking about the MSRP which was $399 upon release of this video card. That's just too high a price and retailers are taking advantage of it.
 
I don't understand this type of thinking. If I have a case that won't work for a new component, I get a different case. I don't short change myself the components I really want or need because of something relatively inexpensive like a case.

...My Coolermaster Stacker 830... I grabbed a P182 on short notice... I was thinking about grabbing some kind of Lian-Li or a Stacker Evolution, possibly the older STC-T01... I liked the P182 so much that I tracked down a P190 and decided to go with it.

Coolermaster Stacker 830 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811119103 ----------> $259

Antec P182 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811129025 -------------> $169

Cheapest Lian Li on newegg http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811112103 ---------------> $79

Antec P190 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811129028 --------------> $449



for something as 'inexpensive' as a case, we sure got to $1000 quickly. :p

good looking/well designed cases for under $100 are very hard to come by. when i found my centurion for $85CDN (3 years ago) i jumped on it immediately. for a case, i call that an expensive part and as such, that premium could have a very real impact on what videocard is purchased.


on topic, GTX is the best choice. if it wont fit in your current case and you don't have the money to buy a case + an 8800, hack a piece out of your chassis and get it in there!

...or grab a stacker 830 and use a 965G :D
 
Does anyone know how the 8800 series cards perform in BF2? I have the 2900XT and I can't get it to do 8xaa, it is a slide show at like 20-25 frames per second. Do the Nvidia cards do BF2 better?
 
I was talking about the MSRP which was $399 upon release of this video card. That's just too high a price and retailers are taking advantage of it.
Who cares about MSRP???
How much the Nvidia 8800 series cards were when they just came out, with the sucky drivers?
Give the HD2900XT a few weeks to build up inventory.
The real world prices will come down (unless the new set of ATI drivers totally rock).
Then Nvidia will have to react with lower prices.
Either way, in the summer the prices will be coming DOWN!
Especially after the release of the new 65nm ATI cards.
 
Back
Top