8800gtx->9800gtx stepup ?

_G_

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
1,378
Got an 8800gtx recently(299amir) and was wondering if its worth it to step up(some would say side step) to the 9800gtx. main question is how they compaire overclocked (will be on water) and if the 9800 has alot of headroom compaired to the 8800.
thanks
 
Don't bother, 9800 GTX is aimed at people with older cards. The 8800 GTX and 9800 GTX will perform virtually identically, whether you OC them or not.
 
they are pretty much identical, though some places online are showing them with very nice OC's. I mean why not upgrade, how much will it cost? cuz you get a card that runs, cooler, quieter, OC's more, it gives you like 3-5 fps more i would venture a guess.


its personal preference
 
9800GTX is a little bit faster than 8800GTX, I just did the stepup and have been playing with the new cards today. There seems to be a problem where when the cards go over 60c the fan speed drops to 35% which is causing some problems with the overclocking for me but on water i would say the 9800GTX will be significantly faster than the 8800GTX.

With fans running at 35% I can OC the 9800GTX to 810/2000/2350 stable and it is just a couple FPS faster than my 8800GTX's OC'd to the max with fans running 100% in Crysis benchmark @ 1920x1080.

With fans running 100% i've had the card up to 860/2200//2450 with room still to go further but the problem is the higher you overclock the quicker the fans reset to 35% because the temp goes up faster. So until Nvidia fixes the fan speed issue I am just going to leave it at the 810/2000/2350.

So far though the nicest thing about the cards is the fact that my room is so much cooler with them in the computer. With 8800GTX SLi my computer room was always blazing hot making it miserable to be in at times but with 9800GTX SLi the room is much cooler now and actually comfortable to be in!

Anyway that is my mini review, will post up a more in depth review in the future with comparative benches from both cards once I get some more time on my hands to properly evaluate the cards.

Cheers
 
I'm in exactly the same boat - bought in late feb @ 299 for the 8800GTX. I am considering getting a 30 LCD - isn't the 8800GTX with 768mb better suited for 2560x1600? I don't want to do SLI. Looks like $50 or so gets me to some version of a 9800GTX but...why?

Any ideas if anything fun might be released before end of May?
 
isn't the 8800GTX with 768mb better suited for 2560x1600?
(and 384-bit mem giving higher bandwidth). Yes, even though the difference in performance is hardly noticible. Imo the reason to go 98GTX is less heat/watts, runs cooler, and is usually quieter.
 
9800GTX in my opinion is not as great as i thought it would be and i recommend the 8800GTX on higher resolutions
 
50% more memory-path width and 50% more RAM, FTW.

Why "step up" to 33% less bandwidth/clock and 33% less RAM, again?

The rendering horsepower in the 9800GTX (and other 256-bit memory sub-system cards) is only needed for playable/optimal frame rates with higher shader/processing settings in a few games like Crysis. But, with a neutered amount of RAM (and memory-path width), other settings would need to be reduced when running those same high-end titles w/ the 256-bit memory sub-system cards.

If they were giving you money, then it would make sense to me to "step up". If it is a wash by $, but you are out the use of a card for a while and S/H costs to them (or worse, you actually had to spend some $ for the new card in the swap), I don't see the point.

Of course I only see the point of the 9600GT out of Nvidia, of late. It took them way too long to come out with a 64SP part for the midrange/low-end.

BTW OP: Do what makes you happy. Good luck!
 
Back
Top