8800GT vs 8800GTS?

atamdr

n00b
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Messages
32
I'm in no hurry to buy a video card as I'm putting a new rig together, but I'd like everyone's opinion on what I should do. I can wait a couple of weeks or maybe even a month and a half before I make a decision.

I'm deciding between the 8800GT which can be had for about 230-250 (512mb version) and the 8800GTS (G92 version which can be had for 300 AR right now)

After the rig is put together, I don't plan on touching it for atleast 2 years, and it's going to hook up to a 42in display, so I'd like to do everything in the 1080p resolution (gaming, etc).

So my question is: how much of a speed difference is there between the two graphics cards? Is the extra $50 worth it? Overclockability?

TIA
 
Is there a 9series card coming out that will have similar performance to the GTS for the same price? From my understanding the 8800gts equivalent will be priced well above 300.
 
I'm in no hurry to buy a video card as I'm putting a new rig together, but I'd like everyone's opinion on what I should do. I can wait a couple of weeks or maybe even a month and a half before I make a decision.

I'm deciding between the 8800GT which can be had for about 230-250 (512mb version) and the 8800GTS (G92 version which can be had for 300 AR right now)

After the rig is put together, I don't plan on touching it for atleast 2 years, and it's going to hook up to a 42in display, so I'd like to do everything in the 1080p resolution (gaming, etc).

So my question is: how much of a speed difference is there between the two graphics cards? Is the extra $50 worth it? Overclockability?

TIA

GTS 512mb hands down. Beats the GT and almost the GTX. The $50 is definitely worth it.
 
Another concern would be Direct X10.1, which the GTS seems to not support. Should I just wait and see the pricing and performance on the new 9series cards, which I'd assume support DX10.1?

This comes back to me not wanting to touch the PC for atleast 2 years...
 
8800GT, if you can find it at $250 or less, it has more or less the same power as the GTS (clock-for-clock, it performs the same as the GT) and therefore has better bang-for-your-buck. Get yourself an Accelero S1 on top of that for $20 and have better cooling than the GTS's stock cooler, which is NOT worth $50 (at the least) to $75 (more likely) more.
 
My same Dilema!

I have a brand spanking new Evga GTX sitting here sealed in the box I got for $350. The 512GTS is now $300 and I'm debating on what to do. I do all my gaming at 1920 x 1080.

Mac
 
I'm deciding between the 8800GT which can be had for about 230-250 (512mb version) and the 8800GTS (G92 version which can be had for 300 AR right now)

If you can get your hands on an 8800GT for under $250 then i would choose that over a GTS. IMO the GTS is not worth that much more than the GT especially considering that to get it at $300 you have to deal with MIR's. With the GT all you have to do is mod the bios and it runs cool enough, mine tops out at 74c which is cooler than my X1950pro was.
 
My same Dilema!

I have a brand spanking new Evga GTX sitting here sealed in the box I got for $350. The 512GTS is now $300 and I'm debating on what to do. I do all my gaming at 1920 x 1080.

Mac

Keep the GTX, it's at least as fast as the GTS, usually faster, and the extra memory bandwidth will come in handy at that resolution also.
 
Honestly, if you wanted to spend the money, try getting the 8800GT Super 1GB.

A 42" display is sweet, but depending on the games, 512MB may actually hinder it's performance (at least at that level).

Do you plan on gaming on it, HD video viewing/editing, etc?

You would be safe with the 512MB if the screen is 720p (which I doubt it is), but if it is 1080i or 1080p and above, (if I were you) get the 1GB model if your funds can afford it.


...just make sure the wife and kids approve! :D


EDIT: I just noticed something. Does my sig look like the outline of a shoe? :eek:
 
Honestly, if you wanted to spend the money, try getting the 8800GT Super 1GB.

A 42" display is sweet, but depending on the games, 512MB may actually hinder it's performance (at least at that level).

Do you plan on gaming on it, HD video viewing/editing, etc?

You would be safe with the 512MB if the screen is 720p (which I doubt it is), but if it is 1080i or 1080p and above, (if I were you) get the 1GB model if your funds can afford it.


...just make sure the wife and kids approve! :D


EDIT: I just noticed something. Does my sig look like the outline of a shoe? :eek:

LOL, a little.

And do you have a link?

I will definintely (hopefully) be doing all of that (especially the HD movies) in 1080p resolution. I'm not a huge gamer, but do like to dabble in online 3d shooters every so often to take a break, and Starcraft 2 will probably be my main game once that comes out.
 
Just looked through the article, it seems to offer practically no noticable gain whatsoever over the 8800GT. Its overclocking abilities are attractive though.
 
The GT used to be the better deal but at current prices the GTS is a way better deal. 300 shipped for a GTS from Buy.com versus 250 plus shipping for a GT, So essentially the price is even less than 50 dollars difference and the GTS will clock at least 100 mhz higher than the GT and also perform noticeably better in shader intensive games clock for clock, as well as push all that hot air out the back of your case as opposed to heating up the inside of your case like the 8800 GT does.

I used to think the GTS was a waste but after owning both cards I would definitely recommend going with the GTS over the GT at the current prices. I ended up selling my GT and kept the GTS .

Cheers
 
Just looked through the article, it seems to offer practically no noticable gain whatsoever over the 8800GT. Its overclocking abilities are attractive though.

There really isnt much of a gain but given the price its not really that bad especially considering the nice cooler. Thats basically double the ram and a better cooler for $50.

The GT used to be the better deal but at current prices the GTS is a way better deal. 300 shipped for a GTS from Buy.com versus 250 plus shipping for a GT, So essentially the price is even less than 50 dollars difference and the GTS will clock at least 100 mhz higher than the GT and also perform noticeably better in shader intensive games clock for clock, as well as push all that hot air out the back of your case as opposed to heating up the inside of your case like the 8800 GT does.

I used to think the GTS was a waste but after owning both cards I would definitely recommend going with the GTS over the GT at the current prices. I ended up selling my GT and kept the GTS .

Cheers

Are you just making up prices because there is no $300 shipped GTS on buy.com. The cheapest GTS on buy.com is $314 after a $20 rebate, while they have an 8800GT for $245 no rebates and they both have free shipping thats a $69 difference counting the MIR even.
 
When you add on the price of an after market cooler,which most people end up wanting with the GT,the price difference goes down.So the GTS is a better choice,in my opinion.
 
The cooling and small fan is why I dumped the 2 GT's I had. The smaller fan when turned up to around 60% which is where it needed to be to keep the temps down was slightly noisy. My GTS's fan at 60% is not even noticeable.

Mac
 
The 1gb model offers essentially 0 over the 512mb model. At 720p youd likely be fine with even a 256 mb card, but i would still recommend at least 512mb. If you want to spend the extra money, go for the GTS.

Also, 1080i is equivalent to 720p. I see your planning to play at 1080p, so i were you id buy the 8800 GTS now, preferrably an eVGA and step up to the new 98xx whatever that will hopefully come out if the 8800GTS isnt enough for you, or just wait a bit for the new cards.

As for OCing the 8800 GTS will be better, and already had a better cooler. FWIW i returned my 8800GT and just bought an eVGA 8800 GTS with intent to step up so long as something better comes out.
 
My opinion would be, if money is no object; wait until the new X48 chipset and CPU's come out that support SLi. All quad-core intel mobo's support cross-fire, not SLi. Once that happens, decide what video card to buy. Don't forget, Direct X 10.1 support doesn't much matter if 99.8% of games currently in DX10.0 don't look better, and definitely don't perform better. Waiting between now and this fall might be the best solution for those being future-conscious. Also, PCI-X 2.0 will be very important. It isn't so much now, but reports are that it will be in the next gen of DX10 games.
Either way, do your research. I bought 2 8800gt's just because I'm still on Socket 939 and don't have the $800+ I would like to spend to upgrade platforms.
 
Thanks everyone, I didn't consider the fan noise issue, and don't want to deal with replacing heatsinks/fans so I think I'll go for the GTS, and in 2 years or so I'll upgrade again if needed. Now the next question...which GTS should I get? I want to stay in the ~300 range, and don't mind dealing with rebates.
 
Also, PCI-X 2.0 will be very important. It isn't so much now, but reports are that it will be in the next gen of DX10 games.

This dont make any sense at all. PCI-E 2.0 is just an interface games cant even tell the difference.
 
And from my understanding, the adapters today don't even come close to utilizing PCI-E 1.1 bandwidth.
 
Thanks everyone, I didn't consider the fan noise issue, and don't want to deal with replacing heatsinks/fans so I think I'll go for the GTS, and in 2 years or so I'll upgrade again if needed. Now the next question...which GTS should I get? I want to stay in the ~300 range, and don't mind dealing with rebates.

it looks like you've already made your decision, but i want to bring this up: evga and other companies are now shipping the 8800GT with a revised cooler using a larger fan. I have an evga GT with the larger fan and it stays nice and cool and is very quiet. under full load the temps never break 70ºC. the sound level of the fan is subjective of course.
 
Thanks for the info, but impatience overruled me and I ended up ordering the XFX Alphadog 8800GTS for around 300 after a $20 MIR.

If anyone thinks I can get a better card for similar pricing, please let me know and I'll cancel the order and do a little bit of research.

From the little research I did however, there seems to be no difference between the 8800gts cards between manufacturers, and the XFX lifetime warranty with leniency towards overclocking was attractive.
 
wel the different between the GT and the GTS is 112 Steam vs 128 Steam the GTS is alittle bit faster you might see something like the GT Core Clock 600 (MHz) and GTS Core Clock 650 (MHz) , GT Shader Clock 1500(MHz) GTS Shader Clock 1625(MHz) and so on and so on. but the different going to see in 1080I not much that HDTV different channel going into that video card your not going to see much at all. mabe in games your see into a 42" your see something like 25 or 10 FPS better than the 8800GT not much but it help some.Resolution 1920 x 1080 watching moives or AVI or anything that is on desktop. i'm sure your able to watch TV at Resolution 1920 x 1080 but not much your might notice that the 8800GT might get alittle more heat compare the GTS not much the GTS handel about 18 more watts compare the 8800GT not much.so i let you think it over i'm still in the 7800GT class i'm waiting hehe. hopeing 9800GTX is going to be my last video card for the next 3 yrs after that. i say go with the GTS more handeling power for bigger gameing handeling at a large resolution
 
I googled the product number on the card I ordered just to make sure, and it is indeed the G92.
 
After reading all sorts of reviews and benchs and whatnot it seemed that the GTS was pretty much on par with the GTX at resolutions at or below 1600x1200 (which is what I run). Although for $250 the GT is probably your best bang for your buck the GTS is indeed faster. I purchased my GTS at Newegg. At the time GT was selling for around $280, and the evga GTS were going for $360, a $20 MIB and Crysis bundled. Which brought it down to roughly the same price so the choice was simple.
 
Are you just making up prices because there is no $300 shipped GTS on buy.com. The cheapest GTS on buy.com is $314 after a $20 rebate, while they have an 8800GT for $245 no rebates and they both have free shipping thats a $69 difference counting the MIR even.


Maybe you should read the hot deals forum before accusing folks of making things up: XFX Alpha Dog g92 8800GTS 298.99 shipped after 20 dollar rebate http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1261528 includes free Company of Heroes. Also Your 8800GT for 245 is a PNY no thanks...don't like paying to ship my cards to China for warranty LOL and on top of that it is not even in stock.

Cheers
 
Maybe you should read the hot deals forum before accusing folks of making things up: XFX Alpha Dog g92 8800GTS 298.99 shipped after 20 dollar rebate http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1261528 includes free Company of Heroes. Also Your 8800GT for 245 is a PNY no thanks...don't like paying to ship my cards to China for warranty LOL and on top of that it is not even in stock.

Cheers

The same coupon for 5% off can be used on the 8800GT. Point is you where trying to say that its less than a $50 gap between the GT and GTS and thats not true its thats a difference of $66 after the rebate.

PNY is based in jersey not china you RMA them here in the states...
 
The same coupon for 5% off can be used on the 8800GT. Point is you where trying to say that its less than a $50 gap between the GT and GTS and thats not true its thats a difference of $66 after the rebate.

PNY is based in jersey not china you RMA them here in the states...

Your not taking the free Company of Heroes into account, regardless though 50 dollars 65 dollars I would still rather have the GTS. I got my GT's for 222 and still preferred to keep the GTS at the 78 dollar difference. It's just a much nicer card. I felt the same way as you before I actually tried the GTS for myself, I thought it was a waste over a GT but after owning both cards it is most definitely worth the extra money. Better cooling, Better clocks, significantly better performance in shader intensive games clock for clock and significantly better performance in every game given the higher clock speeds you can run the card at. Quieter fan, better cooling etc...it's just a much better card worth way more than an extra 50 or 60 bucks. If you look at some of the benches out there the GTS at over 800mhz clocks performs stride for stride with the Ultra! The GT just can't do that :)

Cheers
 
Back
Top