Which one of these do you think is better, in general, at 1680x1050? I'm planning on getting a gift for someone who currently has the 8800GT SLI setup, but if a 4870 is better, it might be a nice little (in magnitude of performance) upgrade.
Well, the person already has the 8800GT setup, and I just wanted to know if it would be a wow-worthy upgrade. If not, I'll keep looking for other things to get.
In most games he'll get less FPS, though if he's one of the microstutter-haters he might experience a smoother gaming experience in the few games where those two setups would struggle fps-wise.
I'd get him/her something else. A VelociRaptor maybe( unless he's already running raptors or raid0 )?
Going to a GTX260 from two 8800GT's in SLI, I can tell you that I did in fact see real-world performance gain moving to the GTX260. The FPS is just so much more stable on the GTX260 - and the added VRAM helps in games like GTAIV. It's also nice not having to deal with SLI application profile BS. It's also a good time to sell off the 8800GT's right now. I'm selling both my 8800GT's on ebay right now - and they will easily recoup the $200 I had to spend on the GTX260.
If you wait any longer to sell off the 8800GT's, they won't get you nearly as much money.