8800 GTS 512 questions

Corbin

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 5, 2008
Messages
509
Hi, I'm planning on buying an 8800 gts 512 for the system in my sig and I want to know if my performance would be increased majorly if I put another one in and SLI. I game on a 22" 1680-1050 monitor and play games like COD4, HL2, Company of Heroes, and other games of the sort. I'm also planning on getting a new mmo. I want to be able to run a bunch of the games I have and also new ones to come out at max with AA/AF or almost max for newer games. Would one 8800 gts 512 be enough or would a second one help out a lot? I may also upgrade to a 24/28" monitor with a rez of 1920-1200 in the future (1-2 yrs) and I wouldn't want to upgrade my gpu.

I realize new cards are coming out, but they are way out of my price range and I doubt the 8800 GTS will drop that much in price. If I get the 2nd card it will be at a later time because of funds (I'm only 14 and have no job).
 
The ATI 4850 should be in the same price range as the 8800 GTS. It's worth waiting a few weeks to find out how they compare.
 
oh ok. I have an sli board though and do not want a new mobo. But I'm going to wait cause I don't have the $200 yet.
 
I have a MSI 8800GTS 512mb and I can play everything maxed out 1680-1050, except for Crysis. And thats with a weak single core 939 athlon 64.
 
I also have an 8800GTS 512Mb overclocked to 775/2000/1975 with an aftermarket cooler. I run all my games at my screens native res of 1680x1050 as well and things run very smooth for the most part. In CoD4, where I have most settings maxed except soften smoke edges and shadows, I stay around my fps cap of 80 unless fire fights get extremely heavy, or I'm in smoke where it can drop to as low as 45-50(which is pretty unacceptable for me). Half life 2 will run completely maxed at over 150 fps with my 8800GTS. I have also played Age of Conan with basically the same settings as CoD4, except having full shadows on, and it ran pretty well... about 35-50fps in Tortage and a little higher everywhere else. Its a good card but I think having two of them would be great for CoD4 and AoC. I'm a fps/graphics whore, so I usually upgrade pretty frequently.


This is all with the system specs in my signature.
 
wow thx for all the replys! I'll be sure to wait after the new cards come out but when they do I'm sure I'll wanna pick up an 8800 gts because of price/ performance and that I can SLI Later. 8800 GTS=400$ 9800gx2=500-550. I'm liking the 8800's. :)
 
SLI as an upgrade path is pretty much always a bad idea. An 8800 GTS 512MB may well be a good option for you now, as it will play just about anything without issue at 1680x1050 with a single card. SLI is generally a waste below 1920x1200 -- there is almost always a single card solution that will cost less and perform more than well enough.

I agree that you should wait for ATI and Nvidia's new offerings in mid June, as this may drive prices downsomewhat on current cards, or the new cards may prove so much better you will want to save up for one.

Forget that you have a SLI capable board -- if the ATI card proves to be the best price to performance, get it, it will work fine in your board.

In truth, were I you I'd sell that board and pick up a less expensive P35 based board.
 
how would I sell it. I've only used craigslist in the past and only buy from ebay. And I have chosen to wait.
 
The 750i is a solid chipset, really. No real reason to get rid of it unless money is very tight.

I'd recommend selling it on eBay (with reserve) or here, via the FS/FT forums, if you decide to do that.

I just noticed that your machine is built by CyberPower PC -- if you have any kind of warranty through them don't sell the board, as changing it out will probably void the warranty.

You could probably sell your 8600GT for ~$40-50 to help offset the cost of the new card though.
 
I just noticed that your machine is built by CyberPower PC -- if you have any kind of warranty through them don't sell the board, as changing it out will probably void the warranty.

You could probably sell your 8600GT for ~$40-50 to help offset the cost of the new card though.

I got a 3 yr warranty with it. Thats one reason I chose them. Wouldn't selling the 8600 gt void the warranty too?
 
I got a 3 yr warranty with it. Thats one reason I chose them. Wouldn't selling the 8600 gt void the warranty too?

Seriously doubt that. The GPU isn't nearly as integral to the system as the motherboard. You can always call them up to check, but you have more than enough power for a pair of just about any card, so its not like that's going to be a problem. I see no reason they'd care if you replaced the card.
 
I've got two EVGA's in SLI. I only play CoD4. Haven't really noticed much of a difference. I still get bad fps when smoke is popped. My fps averages have went up from a single card, but the game play doesn't seem much different. I wouldn't recommend getting two. Just get one. This is my second SLI setup, and I wouldn't recommend it. I'm done with SLI.
 
Not true, actually. 8800 GTS 512MB SLI is faster than a single 9800GX2.

do u need me to prove you wrong again?

Benchmarks say 9800GX2 is faster than 8800GTS SLI in UT3, Crysis, CoD4, and Bioshock at 1900x1200. And no, I didn't just look at fudzilla. I feel like u just like to bash me down even though you know I'm right.
 
do u need me to prove you wrong again?

Benchmarks say 9800GX2 is faster than 8800GTS SLI in UT3, Crysis, CoD4, and Bioshock at 1900x1200. And no, I didn't just look at fudzilla. I feel like u just like to bash me down even though you know I'm right.

Links?

The 9800GX2 is based on 8800GTs, which have less stream processors and slower clock speeds.
 
I've got two EVGA's in SLI. I only play CoD4. Haven't really noticed much of a difference. I still get bad fps when smoke is popped. My fps averages have went up from a single card, but the game play doesn't seem much different. I wouldn't recommend getting two. Just get one. This is my second SLI setup, and I wouldn't recommend it. I'm done with SLI.

First of all, which driver where you using? Second, did you change the FPS cap? (I set /com_maxfps to 125 which allows you to do more jumps)

I get a solid 125 in all games at 1920x1200 with occasional drops to 100.

E8400 @ 3.8Ghz, 2GB DDR2-800 CAS4, Asus P5n-e SLI, 2x PNY 8800GTS 512 @ 700/1000
 
do u need me to prove you wrong again?

Benchmarks say 9800GX2 is faster than 8800GTS SLI in UT3, Crysis, CoD4, and Bioshock at 1900x1200. And no, I didn't just look at fudzilla. I feel like u just like to bash me down even though you know I'm right.

actually, you're wrong, the only bencmark I saw that shows the GTS is slower is Crysis, and thats by .7fps. in COD 4 8800gts 512 SLI is faster

http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQ3NSw1LCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==
if you notice, the GTS SLI has 4x aa in both rez, were the 9800GX2 has 2x, and then no aa.

why would the 8800gts sli be slower? it has the same hardware, with higher clocks, naturally you'd think it's faster

Links?

The 9800GX2 is based on 8800GTs, which have less stream processors and slower clock speeds.

the 9800GX2 is 2 8800GTS not GT, with lower clocks, the GX2 has 128SP per core the GT has 112, but the GX2 does have lower clocks then a GTS, i think it has same clocks at a GT
 
Benchmarks say 9800GX2 is faster than 8800GTS SLI in UT3, Crysis, CoD4, and Bioshock at 1900x1200.

as I stated before I will be running in 1680-1050 for a long while (1-2 yrs) and I'm only 14 and don't want to be one of those people who upgrade their gpu every 3-6 months. I'm also not a hangover guy. So I'm not gonna buy a cheaper evga or bfg then step up. I just wanna get a card maybe sli and be done with video cards for the next 1-2 yrs. One of my questions though is 2 8800 gts good for 1920-1200 later in life. And I want to be able to run the games that are to come out.
 
Chances are /nothing/ current will be "good" for 1920x1200 later in life, as games are likely to become more demanding (looking to Crysis and World In Conflict) and we're just barely able to game at 1920x1200 in some current titles. Of course, no one knows for sure.
 
actually, you're wrong, the only bencmark I saw that shows the GTS is slower is Crysis, and thats by .7fps. in COD 4 8800gts 512 SLI is faster

http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQ3NSw1LCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==
if you notice, the GTS SLI has 4x aa in both rez, were the 9800GX2 has 2x, and then no aa.


9800GX2 wins in all of those games in that article...ya there's more AA on CoD4 but the 9800GX2 also wins by over 11 fps. This is why I don't use hardocp benchmarks..cause they don't make the game settings equal when comparing.
 
9800GX2 wins in all of those games in that article...ya there's more AA on CoD4 but the 9800GX2 also wins by over 11 fps. This is why I don't use hardocp benchmarks..cause they don't make the game settings equal when comparing.

maybe because you don't understand them :p? do you play a game at 1600x1200 medium settings if you can blast it it to full with 4x aa? obviously no, so why do you care if a vcard performs better with this setting, you want to see how far you can push your game at the settings you play... anyway

no it doesn't it wins crysis by .7fps? and it wins jericho only @ 1920x1200, it loses at 25xx. and it loses in COD 4, the reason it has 4x aa, is because the 8800 GTS SLI was able to play with 4x aa, where as the GX2 could not handle it and provide smooth game play.
 
maybe because you don't understand them :p? do you play a game at 1600x1200 medium settings if you can blast it it to full with 4x aa? obviously no, so why do you care if a vcard performs better with this setting, you want to see how far you can push your game at the settings you play... anyway

no it doesn't it wins crysis by .7fps? and it wins jericho only @ 1920x1200, it loses at 25xx. and it loses in COD 4, the reason it has 4x aa, is because the 8800 GTS SLI was able to play with 4x aa, where as the GX2 could not handle it and provide smooth game play.

how can you say it loses in CoD4 when there are no stats for it with equal settings? If someone wants to compare two cards, they should do it with identical settings.

The difference between these 2 set ups is minimal..people aren't going to notice 1-2 FPS difference.

http://www.fudzilla.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6392&Itemid=40

this shows that GX2 wins in most situations, and wins 21% in crysis at 4xAA/8xAF.

Don't even tell me the GX2 can't handle CoD4 in 4x aa...
 
First of all, which driver where you using? Second, did you change the FPS cap? (I set /com_maxfps to 125 which allows you to do more jumps)

I get a solid 125 in all games at 1920x1200 with occasional drops to 100.

E8400 @ 3.8Ghz, 2GB DDR2-800 CAS4, Asus P5n-e SLI, 2x PNY 8800GTS 512 @ 700/1000

I'm using the 169 drivers, prolly need to use the new ones. My cap is set to 275. I will lower it to 125. I know punkbuster is kicking ppl for setting that cvar to "0". I play at 1900x1200 as well. I don't play with AA, but I do play with AF. That's weird that your fps doesn't drop when smoke is popped. My main problem is that since I went to SLI in my gaming rig, i've had nothing but problems with my motherboard locking up and taking forever at the bios screen during hot reboots.

It worked perfect prior to that. I just seems that everytime I start messing with SLI, it causes me problems that I never seem to have with a single card solution. I also had issues with my other rig that is SLI'd, but it was awhile ago. I said I wasn't going to ever mess with it again, but I gave in and now I'm gonna have to start RMA'ing parts to figure out what is causing my problem. Glad your's is working for you. 100FPS constant is nice.
 
how can you say it loses in CoD4 when there are no stats for it with equal settings? If someone wants to compare two cards, they should do it with identical settings.

The difference between these 2 set ups is minimal..people aren't going to notice 1-2 FPS difference.

http://www.fudzilla.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6392&Itemid=40

this shows that GX2 wins in most situations, and wins 21% in crysis at 4xAA/8xAF.

Don't even tell me the GX2 can't handle CoD4 in 4x aa...

don't use fudzilla for reviews. EVER

how can I Say that? Becuase the 9800GX2 COULD NOT play smoothly at those settings, and the 8800GTS 512 SLI, could
 
If you clock the 9800 GX2 at the same rate as a pair of 8800 GTS's it should be pretty much the same. The only difference at that point is drivers. If there is a major performance difference at the same clocks its probably driver releated.

That said, the 9800 GX2 is dead. A pair of 8800 GTS probably won't beat a GTX 260 at much so the point is moot.

On June 17 the debate will change.
 
don't use fudzilla for reviews. EVER

how can I Say that? Becuase the 9800GX2 COULD NOT play smoothly at those settings, and the 8800GTS 512 SLI, could

you tell me not to use fudzilla's benchmarks, yet you have no other proof of anything. so..w/e u say
 
I play at 1440x900 and have 8800GTS 512 in SLI. I max Crysis and hold around 40-45 FPS. If I disable SLI and run off 1 card it drops to about 22-25 fps.

So I would say, any reso higher than that, if you can't already max your graphics then go for it. Thing is, with just 1 8800GTS you'll be able to max HL2/COD4 etc. And as long as they maintain at last 30fps you won't know the difference from 200 fps. Once I hit about 26 fps gaming, I can start to tell it's slowing down but anything above 30 is wasted, so I just turn up options.
 
i think u mean 60...30=lagging. And it's a huge difference from 60, and even more from 200.
 
you tell me not to use fudzilla's benchmarks, yet you have no other proof of anything. so..w/e u say

Well you told us you didn't use fudzilla for your benchmarks, so I'm going to patiently wait for these other benchmarks from your other sites you said you could provide.

But whatever, this is a silly argument anyways, and even sillier is arguing over benchmark testing methods from [H] and another site. This is how we do our tests around here, and a good majority of the time they are dead on for that game.
 
Well you told us you didn't use fudzilla for your benchmarks, so I'm going to patiently wait for these other benchmarks from your other sites you said you could provide.

But whatever, this is a silly argument anyways, and even sillier is arguing over benchmark testing methods from [H] and another site. This is how we do our tests around here, and a good majority of the time they are dead on for that game.

I said I didn't JUST use fudzilla. Why do you think fudzilla is a joke anyway?

http://lly316.blogspot.com/2008/03/geforce-9800-gx2-vs-8800-gts-sli-vs.html

Again, 3/4 games 9800GX2 wins. (Dunno what prostreet is)
 
Back
Top