865G finicky about memory?

gamz247

Gawd
Joined
Jun 9, 2003
Messages
655
Over the past month, I've set up two systems with Intel 865G based motherboards. The first was an ASUS P4G800-V, the second was a Shuttle SB61G2 SFF PC.

When I was setting up the machine with the ASUS board, Windows XP setup would crash halfway thru, and, after setup finally worked, would randomly reboot during normal use. At the time, I was using some old Kingston HyperX PC2700 with a P4 2.8B. The HyperX is set to run at CAS2 2-2-5 at 166MHz. This memory has worked, and worked well, when used on my ASUS A7N8X Deluxe. Well, after deciding that the memory may be the problem, a half-gig of Hynix PC3200 was purchased. This stuff runs at CAS2.5 3-3-7 at 166Mhz... and the machine hasn't randomly reset since!

Similar thing with the Shuttle. SPD puts my Mushkin "2-2-2 Special" memory at CAS2.5 2-2-6, and I had trouble installing and running Win2K. I change the timings to 3-3-7 and bam, things are running smoothly.

Sure, the 865G isn't the best Intel-based motherboard, but damn I didn't think it could really be that bitchy.

Is this the norm for Intel-based motherboards? My past two home-built rigs have been AMD, and I haven't had any troubles like this with them.

I'm gonna be building another Intel rig for a friend in the next couple months. I'll probably recommend an 875P for him, cuz he wants top-of-the-line. Should I prepare for such troubles with that, or is it a little more easy-going?
 
low latency ram usually needs more volts than stock, use memtestx86+ to check for mem errors and find a stable voltage.
 
Originally posted by Merlin45
low latency ram usually needs more volts than stock, use memtestx86+ to check for mem errors and find a stable voltage.

Y'know, I don't even remember seeing anything about voltages in the P4G800-V BIOS. It's a little late to go switching the memory around in that system though, since it's not mine... and there'd be a restocking fee for returning the DIMMs, if I could get it to work. Funny though, memtest86+ never did work on that motherboard, no matter what DIMMs were in the slots.

I guess I could up the DDR voltage of the Shuttle and see if that has any effect.
 
Back
Top