8600GT or 9600GT

AndonSage

Gawd
Joined
Jan 19, 2007
Messages
897
I'm putting together a config for my parents for a new computer. They do e-mail, Internet, Office applications, and my Dad does occasional CAD work (he's an architect). Anyway, the config so far is (this is from AVA Direct):

CUSTOM COMPUTER, Core™2 DDR2 Mainstream Series System $709.38
COMPUCASE (HEC), 6C28 Black/Silver Mid-Tower Case, 585W PSU, ATX
MICROSTAR, P35 Neo2-FR, LGA775, Intel P35, 1333MHz FSB, DDR2-1066 8GB/4, PCIe x16 CF /2, SATA 3.0 Gbit/s RAID 5 /5, HDA, GbLAN, ATX, Retail
INTEL, Core™ 2 Duo E4500 Dual-Core, 2.2GHz, 800MHz FSB, 2MB L2 Cache, 65nm, 65W, EM64T EIST XD, Retail
KINGSTON, 2GB ValueRAM (2 x 1GB) PC2-6400 DDR2 800MHz CL5 SDRAM DIMM, Non-ECC
MICROSTAR, NX8600GT Twin Turbo, GeForce® 8600GT 580MHz, 256MB DDR3 1600MHz, PCIe x16 SLI, DVI /2, HDTV/S-Video-Out, Retail
WESTERN DIGITAL, 320GB WD Caviar® SE16 (WD3200AAKS), SATA 300MB/s, 7200 RPM, 16MB cache
LITE-ON, LH-20A1S Black/White 20x DVD±RW Dual-Layer Burner, SATA, Retail
MICROSOFT, Windows XP Home Edition w/ SP2b, OEM
WARRANTY, Silver Warranty Package (3 Year Limited Parts, 3 Year Labor Warranty)

Windows XP is required due to my Dad's CAD problem not working with Vista. He also wants to get a 20" LCD widescreen monitor.

My question is would he be better off with a 9600GT instead of an 8600GT? The difference in price is only $46.40. I'm just concerned that the 8600GT won't be enough to run the 20" monitor, especially when he's using his CAD program. I'm not familiar with the 8600GT.

Thanks for any advice.
 
So long as your parents arent planning on playing any games, the 8600GT is more than adequate for a 20" widescreen. :D
 
I'm putting together a config for my parents for a new computer. They do e-mail, Internet, Office applications, and my Dad does occasional CAD work (he's an architect). Anyway, the config so far is (this is from AVA Direct):

<snip>

Windows XP is required due to my Dad's CAD problem not working with Vista. He also wants to get a 20" LCD widescreen monitor.

My question is would he be better off with a 9600GT instead of an 8600GT? The difference in price is only $46.40. I'm just concerned that the 8600GT won't be enough to run the 20" monitor, especially when he's using his CAD program. I'm not familiar with the 8600GT.

Thanks for any advice.

Seeing that gaming is not going to be part of your father's routine, the 8600 GT is more than enough. It does the job in terms of gaming too (even if limited in terms of in-game options and resolution), but when compared to the 9600 GT, it's only half as fast.

I'll put it this way: If eventually, someone plans to play any games on that machine and wants a smooth experience, I say that the extra $46.40 for the 9600 GT are worth it. If not, the 8600 GT is more than adequate.
 
Yes but AutoCAD is a 3D program. If he makes a lot of polygons and wireframes are all over the screen, it could get laggy. It's probably better to go with a 9600GT because I too experienced lag on AutoCAD with the school's 7600GT. If you have an extra $50 laying around, it's worth it for an extra graphics horsepower.
 
Back
Top