7950GX2 or X1900XTX?

Johnboat said:
Roadkill,

I'm curious, what are your settings for EQ2 and your high and low framerate? I recently upgraded to a Athlon 64 3200 and overclocked it to 2.6 GHz and I also got a Geforce 7900GT.

After not playing EQ2 for over a year I decided to reactivate it since I have a much nicer system now. I have my settings at balanced with character shadows on at 1600x1200 resolution.

On the high side I can get up to 50 to 60 fps, on the low side I get as low as 12fps, this low side I'm getting sick of, it mostly happens in the city. I would love it if I could get like 20 on the low side.

I'm just wondering what you happen to get.
Thanks


I'm running Extreme settings. I set it to extreme and tweak from there. But, i can tell you I do hit framerate droppage in city zones in both Freeport and Qyenos no matter what settings I tweak. I chaulk that up to just poor coding in the city zones. In some heavy raid settings I drop back to Balanced mode. But 90% of the time during my game play I run tweaked extreme. To assume that a person wont run across ANY framerate droppage in EQ2 is foolish. EQ2's coding is both a graphic and CPU hog and even the most top of the line "current technology" machines will have trouble putting out a smooth full all out Extreme Settings game session. I'm happy with how my gameplay is. Nothing is ever perfect....period. And I accept that.


But I am surprised that you with a 7900GT can only run on Balanced and you are seeing "frame droppage" down to ~12 frames. At my tweaked extreme setting I'm seeing droppage to about that level depending on if there are a large amount of people in the East Freeport zone.

EQ2 Settings:
X1900XTX 512mb @650mhz GPU/800mhz mem (1.6ghz) 1.4voltage

AA x6
AF x16 Trilinear
1280x1024 resolusion
Graphics Res 1.000
Lighting Res 1.000
Rendering Dist. 1000
Complex Shader Dist 300
Texture Resolution Maximum
Character Texture Resolution Maximum
Character LOD Texture Resolution Maximum

Bloom Effect Enabled
Atmospheric Bloom Enabled
Heat Shimmer Enabled

Underwater Distortion Enabled
Water Interaction On (Foam+Reflect+Refrac)
Splash Particals Enabled
Animate Procedural Textures Enabled
Ocean High
Environment Cube Map Updates Fast(periodic)
Reflections Mirror+Cube Map(Best)
Reflections inside a House Cupe Map (Good quality)

Partical Quality High
Max Spell Result per Character 6
Particals in Reflections Enabled
Particals in Reflections in House Enabled
Partical Level of Detail (Far) Max 0.200
Partical Level of Detail (Near) Close
Maximum Partical Size Max

Light Quality High
Max Player Torches 4
Max Torch intensity Full 1.000
Max Lights 8
Specular Lighting Enabled
Additional Specular While Raining Enabled
Max Spec lights 4
Max Bumpy Point Distance 25
Minimum ambient light 3/4 setting bar

Shadow Quality High
Shadows Enabled
Torch Shadows Enabled
Character Shadows Enabled
Environment Shadows Enabled

Model Level of Detail bias Max High Res 0.100
Maximum triangle density High Res Max
High Detail Characters Max
Low Detail Characters Medium

Minimum animation rate High
Fast animation distance High
Animation weight quality High
Cloth Simulation Enabled

Flora Enabled
Flora Displacement Enabled
Flora Radius 3/4 Bar Far
Flora Density 3/4 Bar Dense
 
Damn Roadkill,

Thats crazy! You have a dual core CPU but EQ2 doesn't take advantage of that does it? I'll try your settings but your playing at 1280x1024 and I play at 1600x1200, I like the realestate.

I'll try it though to just to see what kind of results I get and I'll keep you posted.
 
Thanks for all the advice. I have been looking at the 7900gts but with all the problems plaguing the series with OCability and only 256mb, I have decided on a XT/XTX. Right now I have a pre-order in for an E6600 and there's a retail Asus X1900XT @ the egg for 389$ish, soon as I get it up and running, gonna knock it up to XTX speeds. And right now since my highest resolution is 1680x1050, I think it'll suit me well. I'd go for the 7950 is I was pushing over that for sure. I think I'll be quite satisfied with the choice, maybe I can spend the extra money on something else.
 
All the talk about direct X 10 shows how easily people buy into Microsoft's Vista marketing scheme. You should know better.
 
I'd say go for an X1900XTX - it will hold its ground for a good while yet, until DX10 comes along in the next year or so. It really does depend on if you want to upgrade again soon or not. Personally, I still game on an OC'd 9800pro (256MB version) with some custom-rigged air cooling, and that suites me just fine (will upgrade soon), but I'm not so much of an enthusiast (I spend a max of $700 - usually less - on a system when i build it, then put money into upgrades as newer titles come out that demand more power). But from your standpoint, the 1900XTX is probably a better deal, 48pixel shader pipelines will serve you well with games becomming increasingly shader-driven (look at Oblivion), not to mention HDR&AA at the same time!
 
Johnboat said:
Damn Roadkill,

Thats crazy! You have a dual core CPU but EQ2 doesn't take advantage of that does it? I'll try your settings but your playing at 1280x1024 and I play at 1600x1200, I like the realestate.

I'll try it though to just to see what kind of results I get and I'll keep you posted.


My X2 load balances the processing between the two cores. That's why my 3800+ X2 is overclocked lower than your single core 3800+ but I get better overall performance. EQ2 doesn't totally use multi-cores to their fullest advantage, but up until about 4-5 months ago it wouldn't run right on multi-cores period. But they have patched it since then. /shrug

I'm sure there are several other mitigating factors that alow me to have good performance in EQ2 but not knowing what they could be, I dunno what more to say.

All I know is it works well on my box and I'm happy. Might not be the smoothest top notch flawless gameplay, but then again. I only have to satisfy myself.

Oh, and by the way....I play EQ2 on Dial-up. HAHA :D
 
dad11345 said:
All the talk about direct X 10 shows how easily people buy into Microsoft's Vista marketing scheme. You should know better.

Why don't you go play some Dx7 games or something?
 
Here's a really random question. I *really* like Nvidia's monitor wizard that lets you set color/contrast/etc. very easily with slider bars. Does ATI's driver have something comparable? I know it's nit-picky and there are other programs that do it and whatnot...but right now my decision is based on a lot of little stuff.
 
Riptide_NVN said:
Yes Catalyst Control Center has slider bars for gamma, contrast, and brightness.

This is a full-on calibration program. It's tough to explain, but based on the colors you see it gives you the "ideal" color based on your monitor's settings. With my Sony LCD I tried using all sorts of calibrators for the color and none of them worked as well as the internal Nvidia one, so I was curious if ATI also had a calibration program. I know all cards have color sliders, but this is a little more automated.

If gives you 3 bars with red/blue/green and you move the bar until you "can't see the cursor" for all 3 to give you the ideal RGB settings for your monitor.
 
Nope. Color settings in the Control Center are fairly basic, as nVidia's control panel used to be.

There are some off-the-shelf programs that involve a number of calibration steps, though they still aren't fantastic. To get the job done, you really need a hardware calibration device.
 
phide said:
Nope. Color settings in the Control Center are fairly basic, as nVidia's control panel used to be.

There are some off-the-shelf programs that involve a number of calibration steps, though they still aren't fantastic. To get the job done, you really need a hardware calibration device.

I know, but of all of the software solutions I've ever tried, I found this one to work best...and it was a freebie built into the drivers. It's the main reason I'm leaning toward a single 7900GT until DX10 hits.
 
venturi said:
hard to argue against sheer power : dual 7950 is my vote

spec:
Dual Dual Opteron 285s
Tyan K8WE motherboard
16 GB Ram
Quad SLI xfx 7950 572/1556
Ageia Physx PPU
(4) Seagate 750GB SATA 300 drives RAID 0 ~ about 3 terabytes
8GB RamDrive- virtual
Dual linked power supplies
Apple Cinema 30inch @ 2560x1600 res
Windows Server 2003 64-bit


^ HOLY HELL!!!... looking to adopt a son? :)
 
You know, I think I'm leaning toward using a single x1900xt IceQ3 for the moment. It seems to put up good numbers, ins't THAT expensive and like others have mentioned I could use it for physics later when the DX10 cards come out. I guess I could even just get another for a Crossfire setup, although I'm still a little wary of 2-card setups.
If I run a typical high-end game like FEAR in 1680X1050, should this provide enough horsepower to crank the details?
 
Whatever you decide, don't let "going SLI with a second card sometime in the future" affect your decision.

Most cases, it'll make more sense to sell your current card and then buy a new faster single card.
 
eastvillager said:
Whatever you decide, don't let "going SLI with a second card sometime in the future" affect your decision.

Most cases, it'll make more sense to sell your current card and then buy a new faster single card.

QFT

i was in the same boat you're in. ended up goin w/ an X1800XT

works great, blows my 68U away :p
 
kinda a thread jack im thinking of getting a new card are there any single slot cooled X1900XTs?
 
venturi said:
hard to argue against sheer power : dual 7950 is my vote

spec:
Dual Dual Opteron 285s
Tyan K8WE motherboard
16 GB Ram
Quad SLI xfx 7950 572/1556
Ageia Physx PPU
(4) Seagate 750GB SATA 300 drives RAID 0 ~ about 3 terabytes
8GB RamDrive- virtual
Dual linked power supplies
Apple Cinema 30inch @ 2560x1600 res
Windows Server 2003 64-bit

I still wonder to myself why someone would dump that kind of cash and not have every option available to them today and get out image qualitied by an X1800XT (ie. no HDR+AA).
 
Trimlock said:
kinda a thread jack im thinking of getting a new card are there any single slot cooled X1900XTs?[/quote

no

oh well guess ill stay with NV then

X1900XT is great card from the numbers just wish it had a single slot cooler
 
Honestly i don't see that as a deterance, unless you were very cut for space, which is pretty hard to do unless you are going for dual configurations...

there are X1900 AIW's, they come in single slots, aren't nearly as power full, but have the same thing as every other X1900's just with lower clocks
 
i have the 7950 so you know what i am going to say.

I can honestly say its a good card for me that is , it may be a bad choice for you though.
I had a xfx6600gt 256 (512mb)in sli before and the ammount of difference this has made inside my case is a vast ammount.

I was at the time of releasing the 7950 waiting for Ati to release something so i would have more choice. Also with the dx10 around the corner i too have to be wise.We also have the PPU changing the industry and i also have a elite pre sound card so this was the perfect solution for me.

In the near future (5 months time) i will by a PPU . But without this card this whould not have been possible. So if space is your concern then this is a good card. But if that really does not bother you then what ever tickles your fancy and serves the pocket right.
 
Trimlock said:
Honestly i don't see that as a deterance, unless you were very cut for space, which is pretty hard to do unless you are going for dual configurations...

there are X1900 AIW's, they come in single slots, aren't nearly as power full, but have the same thing as every other X1900's just with lower clocks

And half the RAM.
 
I hope it does or i have been wooped by Nvidia..

Honestly this card eats games , before with my other setup it always bothered me. Also i have the XXX version which can stand up in front of a 7900gtx sli setup. But space was the thing that made me buy this..

As a enthusiast you keep on adding and you like to try all what is around , so the slots for ME are very important. But everyone is different.

I did want to buy a ati card but then crossfire would have took another two slots and it all adds up.
 
Back
Top