7900GT or X1800XT

Predator_CITF

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 24, 2005
Messages
200
The X1800XT's have come down to around the price of a 7900GT (well, only one X1800XT on Newegg, the first Sapphire version)..

So, what should I get? I can't find any reviews cross-benching an X1800XT with a 7900GT...

The 7900GT runs cooler, is smaller, and uses up less power. But the X1800XT is bigger, hotter, and uses up more power, but I've seen in some benchmarks that it performs better than the 7900GT @ higher resolutions.
 
I was in this dilemma a couple weeks back. I choose the 7900GT. Cant give you a exact answer why, I just did. I think the 7900GT is faster but the 512mb on the X1800XT would help out a lot later down the road. Its basically a toss up as I found it, and just went with the 7900GT. Also back then it was 350 so I actually saved 40 bucks. Now they are the same.
 
Do a search, you'll find threads blabbering on for pages and pages about which to get.
 
been a couple threads on this already (search is your friend). link

x1800xt seems to be a bit faster and has more features, but everything is always a trade-off. both perform very well, and which is best may be more determined by what's most important to you.

if heat, power output, noise (and a generally more efficient design) are important, the 7900GT is the way to go.

if you prefer superior texture filtering, or the ability to be able to do both HDR and multisampled AA at the same time, then the XT is the way to go.

some other concerns right now are price and availablity. most of the GT's have "spotty" availability, and some etailers are charging premium price because of this. many of the GT's are "overclocked" versions, and are selling for $330 on up. for that you can get a 512mb XT (the 256mb version is around $280).

performance-wise they are pretty close, tho the XT seems to edge out the GT (even beating the 7900GTX in a couple of games). nv continues to have an edge in most OGL games. ati's architecture seems to take less of a performance "hit" when running higher image quality settings (aa/af, and other quality "features" such as grass shadow in oblivion), and due to this edges out nv in the image quality dept. this, of course comes at the cost of increased power consumption and noise (unlike the GT tho, the XT will vent the hot air out the case rather than recirculate it inside).

both cards offer fantastic performance in the $300 range, and which is best for you kind of depends on what features are most important, and of course the price/avail. of the GT as overall value certainly hinges on street prices avail to you.

i went the x1800xt 512mb route, and am happy with it. i'm sure others have gone the GT route and are happy as well. in the end, they are comparable parts, and "which is better" for the most part comes down to "different strokes for different folks".. imo either card is a solid choice.
 
I will be playing Halo, Battlefield 2, Command and Conquer Generals: Zero Hour, Splinter Cell, and possibly Half Life 2.
 
the x1800xt for 300 has 256 mb of vram. i would get the 7900gt. it's cooler and is similar in speed, but apparently can be overclocked like mad.
 
johnnq said:
the x1800xt for 300 has 256 mb of vram. i would get the 7900gt. it's cooler and is similar in speed, but apparently can be overclocked like mad.

theres also the option of an easy voltmod....
 
johnnq said:
the x1800xt for 300 has 256 mb of vram. i would get the 7900gt. it's cooler and is similar in speed, but apparently can be overclocked like mad.

Nope
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814102629

If that is the one he is talking about....

Yeah the 7900GT's do overclock insanely with Volt Mods, but you severly decrease the life span by doing Volt Mods. If you dont plan on upgrading for a while, the X1800XT might be the choice for you because the if you are a gamer the 512mb of memory is really starting to make a diffrence and by next year im sure its going to have a pretty good impact on what settings you can play on.
 
7900gt can do 800mhz core on a volt mod..and murder the 7900gtx! although the x1800xt has 512mb which u need in oblivion.. even with 2gb of ram with a256mb card it will sputter
 
X1800XT FTW until the 512mb cards run out which is soon. Then against the 256mb X1800XT vs the 7900GT the 7900GT FTW.

X1800XT 512MB > 7900GT 256M

X1800XT 256MB < 7900GT 256M
 
Toms Hardware have an Interactive VGA Chart where you can compare cards in different games and resolution.
Unfortunately they don't have the 7900 cards in the list yet (updated regulary) so the best
I could find was a X1800XT 512mb overclocked against a 7800GT 512mb overclocked.
Both highlighted in blue and there's no question the X1800XT is the better card and the
difference grow the higher the resolution and the more AA AF you add.
In some cases it even beats 7800GTX Extreme 512mb in SLi.

Check it out here.
http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics.html?modelx=33&model1=302&model2=282&chart=88
 
burned-ati said:
7900gt can do 800mhz core on a volt mod..and murder the 7900gtx! although the x1800xt has 512mb which u need in oblivion.. even with 2gb of ram with a256mb card it will sputter

in theory.. a lot of ppl have been trying this over at the AT forums, and not one has succeeded. there have been a couple hit 700mhz, but most are in the mid-upper 600mhz range, and none have gotten close to 800.

you also can't ignore the x1800xt overclocks to 700mhz and above as well (and no hard mod is required); it's not like one overclocks and the other doesn't.
 
yes your right.. the x1800xt is a good video card for sure! if i had about 50$ more i would have gotten one.. as i ordered the x1800xl for 248$ instead
 
Go for the X1800XT and don't look back. With Sapphire's "Platinum Edition" BIOS flash, you can ramp it up to 700/800 without having to touch it. It runs perfectly well with the stock cooler too.

If you get the X1800XT, drop me a PM and I'll upload the BIOS flash for you :)
 
I am just making another note that does not have to do with performance.

EVGA has lifetime warranty even with heatsink changed!
 
The Tech Report's 7900GT review includes X1800XT numbers as well.

Personally, I'd go with the 7900GT simply because it draws way less power (over 60W less under load) than the X1800XT. That adds up when you've got to pay your own electric bill :p
 
The problem with the 7900GT is alot of them are lemons. Mine can't even do 500mhz on the memory, I had to underclock it. :(
 
fromage said:
The problem with the 7900GT is alot of them are lemons. Mine can't even do 500mhz on the memory, I had to underclock it. :(

500MHz on the memory? Out of which asshole did you pull this number?
 
krameriffic said:
500MHz on the memory? Out of which asshole did you pull this number?


Uhmm...

nvidia.jpg


Stock speed is 790mhz on the memory. Anything higher than 500 and it crashes. The memory is faulty, I know. The fact is, a ton of people on eVGA forums are having the exact same problem, and I hear it is not vendor-specific. I'm in the process of RMA'ing my card anyways. Had I known about this problem before hand, I would have gotten the ATi.
 
Bona Fide said:
Go for the X1800XT and don't look back. With Sapphire's "Platinum Edition" BIOS flash, you can ramp it up to 700/800 without having to touch it. It runs perfectly well with the stock cooler too.

If you get the X1800XT, drop me a PM and I'll upload the BIOS flash for you :)

Yeah I ordered one when I saw it go to $299. From what i've seen performance between 1800xt and 7900gt are similar, but for 299 it is cheaper and has 256mb more memory. This will be my first ATI card, previously I have had 3dfx (long time ago) and more recently nvidia.

The sapphire BIOS works fine with the stock cooler?
 
ironforge said:
The sapphire BIOS works fine with the stock cooler?

It should. Of course the fan will be running at higher speed.
You might want to pull off and clean the oem paste off the H/S and reapply w/ AS5.
I've read it makes a noticable difference.
I plan to do it with my card but have been too lazy.
 
you also can't ignore the x1800xt overclocks to 700mhz and above as well (and no hard mod is required); it's not like one overclocks and the other doesn't.

don't forget the X1800's also have the most insane OC's as well, h aving a better track record for the core OC's then the X1900's i believe someone achieved over 1ghz on the core back when they were just coming out back in december
 
Predator_CITF said:
I can't find any reviews cross-benching an X1800XT with a 7900GT...

The 7900GT runs cooler, is smaller, and uses up less power. But the X1800XT is bigger, hotter, and uses up more power, but I've seen in some benchmarks that it performs better than the 7900GT @ higher resolutions.

Sounds to me like you already read all the reviews. You summed it up in a nutshell. Enough said!
 
I got a 7900GT and with the new cooler, an extremely simple volt mod to 1.55V allows me to go to 690/440. All in a small, quiet package.

I just plan on going SLI and I can't stand the ATI dongle madness they chose to use.
 
ATI X1800XT is the way to go, Stock cooler is not that loud and the 512MB version can be had for $299 and for the most part scores better in Direct X games then the 7900GT.
 
ironforge said:
Yeah I ordered one when I saw it go to $299. From what i've seen performance between 1800xt and 7900gt are similar, but for 299 it is cheaper and has 256mb more memory. This will be my first ATI card, previously I have had 3dfx (long time ago) and more recently nvidia.

The sapphire BIOS works fine with the stock cooler?

Yeah, I'm running the stock cooler right now, no problem. But, as previously mentioned, it might help you to reseat the heatsink with some AS5.
 
Also Bona Fide, I've heard that most 7900GT's go past 500/1600 too. A couple that even get into the 1800's..
 
Also Bona Fide, a good bunch of this cards 7900gt/gtoc cant even run stable at its stock clocks ,

so there is not much room to talk about overclocking them
 
Alright guys, there are about three posts starting with "also bona fide"

Let me sum up the pluses and minuses so that we don't need thirty posts:

x1800xt 256
Pros: -Cheaper
-Almost as quick
-Easy to find
Cons: -Hotter
-Consumes more power
-Louder

7900GT
Pros: -Faster than the x1800xt 256
-Can be voltmodded to hit mid 600s+ core and 900+ memory (obviously not for everyone, but still a consideration if you'd like near GTX speeds)
-Quiet and cool
-MOST overclock very well, unless you got one of the superclocked "broken" editions.
-Lifetime warranties are available from most manufacturers.
Cons: -Bit more expensive
-Availability can be difficult to find, though some xfx cards seem to be returning
-Some of the ultra-high end superclocked cards were simply clocked too high stock, and are therefore unstable.

x1800xt 512
Pros: -Faster than the 7900GT stock
-Overclocks well
-Can be found at around the same price as, or a little less than the 7900gt.
Cons: -Louder
-Hotter
-Consumes more power


So there you go, I think that's a fair summation of each of the card's pros and cons.
 
7900GT is on par with X1800GTO...

X1800XT is much better than 7900GT and 7800GTX.
 
Rithina said:
7900GT is on par with X1800GTO...

X1800XT is much better than 7900GT and 7800GTX.

Please do not go spouting bullshit. the X1800GTO is on par with the 7600GT.

Don't post things like that just because you'd like someone to go ATi. Post real benchmarks, and be objective. Nobody likes !!!boys.
 
quadnad said:
Please do not go spouting bullshit. the X1800GTO is on par with the 7600GT.

Don't post things like that just because you'd like someone to go ATi. Post real benchmarks, and be objective. Nobody likes !!!boys.

Thank you :).

Here's my thought on the issue:

Do you have a monter PSU and do you watercool?
Get the x1800xt

Do you aircool and have a lesser PSU?
Get the 7900GT.
 
BlackKoala said:
Here's my thought on the issue:

Do you have a monter PSU and do you watercool?
Get the x1800xt

Do you aircool and have a lesser PSU?
Get the 7900GT.

Although I see what you mean BlackKoala, I don't really agree.

You don't have to watercool or have a monster PSU to support an x1800, I just feel that depending on how sensitive to noise you are you may want to consider factoring in a vf700 or an arctic cooling solution into your purchase price. Also, I think you just need to be more conscious of your PSUs output when considering an x1800, but you certainly don't need a 1kW PCP&C PSU to get it done. A simple, good quality 450 should do you more than fine.
 
i'm sure nvidia could have made their 7900gts faster if they were willing to make it twice as large, produce more heat, and consume more power. The x1800xts are monstrous and the performance of the 512MB version barely edges out the much smaller, quieter, and energy efficient 256mb 7900gt.
 
Yeah, but does it matter??? most of us want PERFORMANCE for our $$$$

The way I see it that in stock form the 1800XT is a better card Vs 7900GT, you get the HQAF you get HDR+AA (Although you might not use it due to perfromance) and of course the 512MB... But if you plan on OCing & voltmoding the 7900GT will be a bit faster (actually much faster) ...

All this info I got first hand from my and friends experience.
 
Well I have a DFI LanParty nF4 Ultra-D...so if I bought the ATI card, it would reduce any chance for me to upgrade to SLI in the future anyways.
 
Back
Top