7900 GTX or X1900 XT?

Lucid Faia

n00b
Joined
May 21, 2006
Messages
3
I was about ready to pull the trigger on a 7900 GTX, but decided to do some research. It seems that the X1900 XT has a slight edge in most games, but runs noisier and louder than the 7900 GTX. If I paired the X1900 XT with an Accelero X2 (which, together, would cost about the same as a stock 7900 GTX), do you think that would be a better video card overall?

Performance and overclockability are what I'm looking for. I would greatly appreciate some insight. Thanks.
 
the x1900xt is not comparable to the 7900gtx. The x1900xtx would be though.
 
Just get like a 9600 or a 9800 max, it can play any game max and is probrolly the best bang for the buck right now. I can play HL2 and Fear full force on my system with no problems.
 
your a century off.

you mean X1800?

I'd get the X1900XTX myself.
 
Scotch77 said:
Just get like a 9600 or a 9800 max, it can play any game max and is probrolly the best bang for the buck right now. I can play HL2 and Fear full force on my system with no problems.

first of all, thats AGP and not PCI-E

and i dare you to play FEAR on max at 1600x1200 with a 9800 compared to the GTX or XT :rolleyes:

and yeah, id got with teh x1900xt, since its only a small diff fromn the XTX and can be OC'd up
 
Another vote for X1900XT. It can reach XTX speeds easily, so anyone recommending an XTX over the GTX is pretty much recommending an XT, whether they know it or not.
 
If I'd known about the problems with the factory oc'd 7900s before I bought mine, I would have gone for the 1900. I like the arctic cooling stuff too, I had an ati silencer on my x850 and it was excellent. Haven't tried/heard the acceleros though.
 
I recommend the x1900xt. It easily OCs to XTX speeds. It cost a whole lot less than the GTX.

Don't forget that the x1XXX series are the only ones that can do HDR+AA in Oblivion, Far Cry, future games.
 
Go for the X1900XT, and this is coming from an nVidia user(with regrets).
 
add up 1 more vote for the X1900XT :p its a bad ass card regardless, and mixing it with a accelero X2 would only make things better. dont get me wrong the 7900GTX is a great card also. but hey its expensive you can get a X1900XT OEM for $359 on newegg and a XTX OEM for $399. most video card coolers are loud but i would not hold that against a card because most stock coolers just barley get by with cooling in the first place, im about to buy an accelero for my X1800XL ;)

And for the guy that said buy a 9600 or 9800 max, he must be playing a different fear :p because i dont even recall a X850XT running that game to well lol.
 
New
the 1900xt is not 369.99 on newegg, the lowest price is 399.99 after mir... and the 1900xtx is 459.99 after mir, (New prices)

Unless you want to get an OPEN BOX then its 400 for xtx and 392.99 for xt.

comparatively 7900gtx new is
439 after 10 instant and a 20$ mir.
 
Scotch77 said:
Just get like a 9600 or a 9800 max, it can play any game max and is probrolly the best bang for the buck right now. I can play HL2 and Fear full force on my system with no problems.

Absolutely not true.

After going through three 7900GTX cards I decided to go X1900XTX. Great card and I don't even notice if it's loud because I have my headphones on.

They are both pretty damn close in performance. The ATI may have a small image quality advantage and will do AA and HDR at the same time which the Nvidia card will not.

I loved the 7900GTX when it worked and I love the X190XTX that I have right now.
 
They just changed the prices at newegg. the X1900XT's were just 359$ now back to 392$

Just pay close attention newegg bounces there prices up and down all the time.
 
cesium666 said:
first of all, thats AGP and not PCI-E

and i dare you to play FEAR on max at 1600x1200 with a 9800 compared to the GTX or XT :rolleyes:

and yeah, id got with teh x1900xt, since its only a small diff fromn the XTX and can be OC'd up

QFT.
I am the not-so-proud owner and user of a 9800. I tried to play FEAR on max. The results were: <1 fps. Immesurable. It was great. Took me 10 minutes to walk down a hall. =D

Also, shouldn't this be a poll?
 
Man thats horrible, i just got done playing fear maxed.. it ran great! i always run my textures at medium because of only 1GB system memory but..the game is sweet! :) maybe i should get 2GB lol
 
DeadlyAura said:
Also, shouldn't this be a poll?

Polls are somewhat useless. You have people that just view the thread long enough to point and click without explaining any reasoning behind their choice.
 
XT for sure. Mine is running completely stable at 680/1590. I came from a 6800GT and the image quality difference IS noticeable. 7900GTXs are great cards, but a reduced feature-set combined with the technical difficulties people have been having with them, make ATI the winner this round.

Also take into account that all major recent and upcoming titles are extremely shader heavy, and the choice becomes clear (at least for me; this is my opinion with experience of both vendors, and not flame material).
 
I noticed that Newegg has the PowerColor and Sapphire X1900 XT's for $429.99 each. Which would be the better buy out of the two?
 
ElMoIsEviL said:
That should read wait for G80/R600... or grab an x1900XT.

Except it looks like R600 won't launch until the end of the year at the earliest. Whereas the rumour mill has G80 forecast for this summer, with ATi doing a GDDR4 X1900 refresh to compete in DX9 (G80's DX10 support is just future-proofing until the API is there to support it) and waiting until DX10 is out or at least much closer to release before the big-hitter comes out to play. I would have included R600 otherwise.
 
Lucid Faia said:
I noticed that Newegg has the PowerColor and Sapphire X1900 XT's for $429.99 each. Which would be the better buy out of the two?

Well, they're the same card and the Powercolor has much better warranty. Sapphires 'select' games are also really old, so the bundle is probably better on the Powecolor as well.
 
all u guys talk about overclocking and flashes the xt... but you'll probably need some really good cooling cuz these video cards run hot.

i have the 1900xtx with vf900 and it runs at 50c idle and up to 80c on a full load.

i cant imagine how hot the XT will run overclocked.
 
Litfod said:
If I'd known about the problems with the factory oc'd 7900s before I bought mine, I would have gone for the 1900. I like the arctic cooling stuff too, I had an ati silencer on my x850 and it was excellent. Haven't tried/heard the acceleros though.
QFT!
I would have done the exact same had I known.
But I have been quite lucky and my 7900GT is running like a champ (thought it was going out on me a week ago, but turned out to be a corrupt driver issue).

SO.... X1900XT with a better cooler and flashed/overclocked to XTX speeds is my vote

D.
 
I have owned X1900XT and X1900 Crossfire and had it run in Crossfire mode for over 2 months.

It was excellent. However, the cards ran hot because the default fan speeds on the cards were slow and I had to manually set them to higher speeds just to keep the cards cool for normal use. I had running display cards at over 40 degrees C for normal use. Gaming is a different thing which ran the x1900 cards at very high temps. Setting the fan speeds to the highest speeds solved the temp problem but it was loud and therefore very annoying. Yes, I tried to tell myself that it is okay since I use headphones to play games but then when not playing games it really gets annoying. X1900 Crossfire also uses alot of power. Also ATI really needs to do something about hte doggle. It is annoying. They need to figure out how to connect two cards internally.

I then switched to Geforce 7900 GTX Extreme SLI and the cards ran faster, cooler (not more than 40 degrees C when gaming) and consumed less power.

Both cards are good for gaming. It all depends how you like to run your system.

I like to try out every new card that comes out so here is hoping that ATI comes out with something new soon. Because I am tempted to try out Geforce 7950GX2 soon.
 
ya try after market coolers buddy........ and plus 40c for a gfx card is nothing.. u dont have to start worrying until about 80-90c
 
Narius said:
ya try after market coolers buddy........ and plus 40c for a gfx card is nothing.. u dont have to start worrying until about 80-90c

I remember that with Geforce 7900 GTX Extreme SLI the cards were running at 29 degrees C in SLI mode when Idle and all the way up to 40 degrees C at full load. The stock fan was not loud.

ATI X1900XT Crossfire was very hot at full load. I think it reached about 50 degrees Cor something with full fan speed. The fan was loud.
 
Lucid Faia said:
I was about ready to pull the trigger on a 7900 GTX, but decided to do some research. It seems that the X1900 XT has a slight edge in most games, but runs noisier and louder than the 7900 GTX. If I paired the X1900 XT with an Accelero X2 (which, together, would cost about the same as a stock 7900 GTX), do you think that would be a better video card overall?

Performance and overclockability are what I'm looking for. I would greatly appreciate some insight. Thanks.

Or you could just get the HIS XT, with the AC cooler on it.
http://www.monarchcomputer.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=M&Product_Code=190878

$400+shipping after a $20 rebate. And it still exhausts the hot air out of the case. HQ AF, HDR+AA, and 6xAA are a few reasons to get the XT. The GTX does run cooler though.
 
1900XT for sure. Just got mine Open Box from Newegg for 359 last week. Just keep an eye on it, they go fast at that price. I used to use a 7800GTX, and the image quality of the XT is much better. I had my doubts about how noticable HQ AF would be in game, but its definitely worth it.
 
Back
Top