7800gt to x1900xt

VivaItalia

n00b
Joined
May 8, 2006
Messages
30
I was thinking of going from a 7800gt to x1900xt but do you guys think I will actually see any difference? my monitor is a 17" sony widescreen which I play games at 1280x960 or 1024x768.

From the benchmarks Ive seen, the x1900xt compared to the 7800gt does not show any significant speed increases at those resolutions but it seems when you get to the 1600x1200 resolutions you start to see the x1900xt breakaway from other vid cards like the 7800gt.

Do you guys think this would be worth the upgrade, or should I just stick with what I got until the DX10 cards are available?
 
VivaItalia said:
I was thinking of going from a 7800gt to x1900xt but do you guys think I will actually see any difference?

At 1280x960? No, not really. If you can't already max your games out at those settings, make the small jump up to a 7900GT or a 512MB X1800XT. For right now, those cards should be able to play almost everything maxed at 1280.
 
There is no reason to even get the 512MB x1800xt, the 256MB will perform nearly identical and is an unmatched deal for $239 nowadays.
 
I would honestly either a, keep the 7800gt (I would probably just keep it), or sell it and get the x1800xt 256, which would be better and less expensive.
 
my 7800gt plays everything at those resolutions I stated earlier flawlessly. I think I will just wait until the new dx 10 cards come out since my 7800gt is running nice.
 
VivaItalia said:
my 7800gt plays everything at those resolutions I stated earlier flawlessly. I think I will just wait until the new dx 10 cards come out since my 7800gt is running nice.


Yea, the more I think about it, the more I say just keep your current.
Im doing that with my x850xt till dx10 comes out. I run at around the same resi's and everything I throw at it can have most, if not all eye candy/aa turn all the way up.
 
Those high end cards are only good I believe if you have a 20inch widescreen or a monitor that supports really high resolutions as that is when you see the 7900gtx or x1900xt really show its might against other video cards.

I figure the $400 or more that I would spend on a x1900xt would be better spent if I just hold on to it until DX10 cards come out. Just look at how long DX9 has been around, if you get a dx 10 card it should be awhile until we start seeing dx11.
 
VivaItalia said:
my 7800gt plays everything at those resolutions I stated earlier flawlessly. I think I will just wait until the new dx 10 cards come out since my 7800gt is running nice.

The 6800gt/gs will play Oblivion on fairly high settings @1280, so I imagine the 7800gt is capable of full settings. The real b*tch is FEAR and AA. When the expansion comes out I might get the bug for a faster card too.
 
I actually play Oblivion at 1280 on my XT; Anyone claiming max settings at this res off a 7800GT isn't telling the whole truth. My XT is currently at 670/1580, and even with these clocks, I have Item and Object draw distance at half (the only way to avoid sub 20's in some cities).

I also run with HDR and 2AA, and countryside areas have reduced grassminsize (120). This gives me an average of around 35-40fps in country areas. I do however have grass drawn out to 10000 (which is far more immersive), starttofade at 5000, and grasspointlighting enabled.

Everything else runs max, and the combination of HDR and AA is bloody amazing!

Every other game runs happily at 1600/1200 max, but for Oblivion the jump in resolution is not worth the associated frame loss (although surprisingly it is quite minimal, can anyone say cpu limitation).

In your case I might wait to D3D10, but don't believe the hype about X1900s only being for 1600/1200 plus; At 1280 you can pump out friggin amazing image quality.
 
xtasyindecay said:
The 6800gt/gs will play Oblivion on fairly high settings @1280, so I imagine the 7800gt is capable of full settings. The real b*tch is FEAR and AA. When the expansion comes out I might get the bug for a faster card too.

LOL you must be joking right? the X1900XT drops to 20 in oblivion at 1024/768 my brother just stepped up from 7800GT to 7900Gt and both choke horribly in oblivion. im not saying the cards are not fast, by all means no! 7800Gt is great also the 7900GT. but dude if you get a X1900XT you will kill your 7800GT..i mean no doubt about it..id say the 7800Gt taps out in 3dmark05 at about 8500-8600 highly OCed and a highly OCed CPU. so your proubly gonna do about 12K with a X1900XT.. go for it, its my next card for sure.
 
burned-ati said:
LOL you must be joking right? the X1900XT drops to 20 in oblivion at 1024/768 my brother just stepped up from 7800GT to 7900Gt and both choke horribly in oblivion. im not saying the cards are not fast, by all means no! 7800Gt is great also the 7900GT. but dude if you get a X1900XT you will kill your 7800GT..i mean no doubt about it..id say the 7800Gt taps out in 3dmark05 at about 8500-8600 highly OCed and a highly OCed CPU. so your proubly gonna do about 12K with a X1900XT.. go for it, its my next card for sure.

Well considering you can't do a HDR + AA comparison... yeah I bet if I had AA enabled with HDR my card (6800gs) would choke to death... but with HDR only, its not that bad. Added the 2048 textures with all the video settings turned 3/4 up it looks good (minus canopy shadows & shadows on grass).

I'm not delusional, I meant fairly high within reason compared to the 7800gt. Yes, you are right, better IQ, hdr + aa and being much faster makes the 1900xt much superior.
 
i run 1024/768 HDR distance land/trees/building/ the rest of meters are 50%. i run 50%interior shadows 50% exterior shadows tree canpoy shadows/self/grass all on. large textures, with the 4,000 resolution ground texture pack. and low shadow filtering, i can clock my card to 685/685mhz

But after about 60 hours of oblivion im sick of it! havnt played the game in weeks lol 60 hours is damn good for single player though.. so i really wouldnt upgrade just to run 1 game lol
 
Edit to post above: Mistake by me, grassminsize is at 140, not 120; Simply because of grasspointlighting (it looks amazing!).
 
The 7800GT is fast, But Definately not as fast as a X1900XT. You would see a sizeable difference. Enough to warrant buying it? Im really not sure. Depending on your bank and how much you want it. If you don't care all that much and are just curious, I wouldnt do it. But that's just me. Ofcourse unless you can get a nice deal and sell your 7800, then go for it.
 
I went 7800gt -> 1900xt, and oh my it was NICE. FEAR made me wet my self, the shadows, the AA, the AF, wow. I mean it was a $270 jump at the time, but it was worth it. I say go for it since the 1900's are coming down and can be found for $390 on newegg
 
Back
Top