7800 GTX or x1900XT

Fistandantilis said:
7800GTX or the x1900XT?

I am buying tonight, let me know what your thoughts are, thanks
I'm assuming that you're talking about the 256MB 7800GTX.

Well obviously the X1900XT is going to perform way better then the 7800GTX will, but they're also in two totally different price ranges.

If money is not a factor, however, you obviously should go with the X1900XT since it is faster.
 
Assuming cost is not a factor, unless you already have a (256) 7800GTX and are considering getting a second one for SLI, there should be no question about it - X1900XT.
Also take into consideration the monitor you're going to be gaming on. If its an LCD with a native res of 1280x1024, more than a 7800GT would be overkill.
 
I'd go for the X1900XT becuase its easily available and its a solid card and will run the games that will come out in a while the fastest if you plan on keeping it.
 
ahhhh shat, sorry guys I misread something on new egg...I will be getting the 7800GTX. sorry for the confusion
 
Fistandantilis said:
ahhhh shat, sorry guys I misread something on new egg...I will be getting the 7800GTX. sorry for the confusion
with this monitor, the 256 7800gtx should be fine for a couple years? (ill be playing fear, css, bf2...the usual)

-jcll2002
 
RavenD said:
Also take into consideration the monitor you're going to be gaming on. If its an LCD with a native res of 1280x1024, more than a 7800GT would be overkill.

Not if you're an IQ freak. Battlefield2 @ 6xADAA+16xHQAF looks awesome on a 1280x1024 LCD, only card which is capable of doing that is Ati X1K. ;)
 
Have you considered a used X1800? You can snag em in the forums pretty cheap and imo is better than a 256 gtx.
 
if you are talking about the gtx 256 version i recommend the x1900 but if not, the 512 gtx!!
 
HybridHB said:
Have you considered a used X1800? You can snag em in the forums pretty cheap and imo is better than a 256 gtx.
at cyberpower, where im buying, its $11 more than the 256 7800gtx. Should I pull the trigger if Im on a 1024*1024 with css, fear, and bf2?

The benchies are pretty much exactly the same. Also, Ive had a nvidia and it was great and Im not sure about ati (just bias)
 
Budwise said:
i would..
I assume that youre talking about the x1800xt...

Someone said that its overkill to get over a 7800gt on a 1280*1024 monitor. Is this true?

Also, will later games take advantage of the 512 mb? Is it silly to get a 256 card now?
 
@ the original poster, x1900 is close to GTX SLI so definately get one if you can, in case you havent looked it seems like everyone and their dog owns one now by looking at the forums

Also its definately worth it for 1280 since you can crank up AA + whatever (specially kick ass for HDR + AA games) and it will last a long time at those settings
 
jcll2002 said:
at cyberpower, where im buying, its $11 more than the 256 7800gtx. Should I pull the trigger if Im on a 1024*1024 with css, fear, and bf2?

The benchies are pretty much exactly the same. Also, Ive had a nvidia and it was great and Im not sure about ati (just bias)

I would get the X1800 over the GTX any day. Even at lower resolutions, you still need power and efficiency in AA and AF which ATI has.
 
a) there is no such thing as overkill. think aboput the future, there will be games that you will want to play 2 years later, which this card will still eb able to handle well.
you might also get a bigger monitor, who knows.

b) there is no point in getting the 1800 right now.
not when the 1900 is that much better, and that close to it in price.

c) the 7800GT is still the best bang for buck.
especially if you plan to upgrade again and dont want to go all out.
 
new egg has the 1900XT for 489.00, its a powercolor but nonetheless, it should prove to be a great card right.
 
Megalomaniac said:
a) there is no such thing as overkill. think aboput the future, there will be games that you will want to play 2 years later, which this card will still eb able to handle well.
you might also get a bigger monitor, who knows.

b) there is no point in getting the 1800 right now.
not when the 1900 is that much better, and that close to it in price.

c) the 7800GT is still the best bang for buck.
especially if you plan to upgrade again and dont want to go all out.
I dont think ill upgrade again (hope not), but i do think that Ill be keeping this rig for a couple of years.

I had no idea that the x1900xt was that fast... Since its only $40 more than the 256 7800gtx than i might as well upgrade!

BTW, the rig that ill be getting is (dont remember if i said this already lol)

x2 4400+
x1900xt (or 7800gtx still not sure...)
1gb ballistix + 256 corsair value
74 gig raptor a8n-e
ect...
 
Fistandantilis said:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814131006

you guys think that this will be better than a GTX? let me know so I can cancel the order(I already ordered the GTX)

that thing > GTX
i dunno if OEM PC has lifetime warranty but Retail does for sure
the X1900XT is a much better choice, its ilke the whole argument , 7800gtx vs x850xt would u buy yesterdays cards at that price?
 
jcll2002 said:
x2 4400+
x1900xt (or 7800gtx still not sure...)
1gb ballistix + 256 corsair value
74 gig raptor a8n-e
ect...

Get 2 gig or ram.
Youll need it, i just recentrly upgraded to the x1900xt and only had 1gb, found that it couldnt cope with fear.
I know have 2 gig of ram, all is well.
Have the same cpu aswell, although it is oc'd
 
Slo Gun said:
Get 2 gig or ram.
Youll need it, i just recentrly upgraded to the x1900xt and only had 1gb, found that it couldnt cope with fear.
I know have 2 gig of ram, all is well.
Have the same cpu aswell, although it is oc'd
yeah...

I just dont know if im spending my money right (if there is such a thing) because

1) ive seen in many reviews that the x1900xt is extreme overkill for a 1280*1024 (or could someone find me the best, high res monitor for $300)
2) I dont game THAT much... I mean I will game 24/7 during the summer when schools out but other than that, occasionally play during school. I guess I shouldnt cheap out though because im keeping this system for a while.
 
You know what Wait a month then bro
If your not going to be playing much now then wait for the 7900s and see what they do before making a choice.
 
I say x1900 series. If you look Here at the first post of this thread you will see that all you need to do is lap the HS as it's only machined. Once completed you should lower your temps considerably. Not sure how much the Cat 6.2 will do for performance.
 
If there is ever a time to wait, then this is it. This year will see perhaps the biggest changes in power and features from the begining of the year to then end for PC's and gamers then any in the five years at least.

What we've got comming....

1) New Intel CPU's, perhaps Intel takes back the enthusiant market?
2) New AMD CPU's, Socket AM2. While a modest upgrade, its still new platform!
3) Windows Vista... probably the change with the biggest impact to gamers is here DX10!
4) DX10 GPU's

So if you can, wait for a little dust to settle, unless you just want the most poweful system you can get at the moment or don't want to wait.
 
heatlesssun said:
If there is ever a time to wait, then this is it. This year will see perhaps the biggest changes in power and features from the begining of the year to then end for PC's and gamers then any in the five years at least.

What we've got comming....

1) New Intel CPU's, perhaps Intel takes back the enthusiant market?
2) New AMD CPU's, Socket AM2. While a modest upgrade, its still new platform!
3) Windows Vista... probably the change with the biggest impact to gamers is here DX10!
4) DX10 GPU's

So if you can, wait for a little dust to settle, unless you just want the most poweful system you can get at the moment or don't want to wait.
The thing is

1) I hate intel (lol)
2) wont it take a long time for the mobos and cpus to be bugless for AM2(m2?)
3)wont that^^^ be pretty expensive at the beginning with bugs?
4)Can i just upgrade my os to vista later? (I know ill have to reformat, ect)
5) Can you explain alittle more about the technology of dx10, the prices, and the waiting time?

Thanks,
jcll2002
 
Fistandantilis said:
7800GTX or the x1900XT?

I am buying tonight, let me know what your thoughts are, thanks
I orderes this card asus EN7800gtx 256 for the new puters that I am building for my twin's. They are very good card's for the buck. I put them in 4 different system's and they have NOT gone down in any way. I do not own or know anyone who owen's the X1900XT but this board does every thing that you ask it to do
 
jcll2002 said:
1) ive seen in many reviews that the x1900xt is extreme overkill for a 1280*1024 (or could someone find me the best, high res monitor for $300)
.

I run at 1280x1024
depends on how bothered about IQ you are.
You can run at 1280x1024 and bump up AA and AF

IMO you cant run fear at 1280x1024 smoothly on 7800GTX
COD2 could also have done with a performance boost, although i havent tried it on the x1900 yet, ive heard it runs better.
 
So I shouldnt bother with the x1900xt, its $40 more

Bothered by IQ? lol I have no idea what that means.

BTW, ill be keeping this system for a LONG time, if that matters.
 
I'd say X1900XT or X1900XTX no question. However, I'd say that if you are interested in Crossfire or SLi type configurations, it might be worth going NVIDIA. Fact is the Crossfire chipsets are still not that great. Plus Crossfire itself still has some issues.

Just as NVIDIA's SLi did for months after it's initial release. Not that it's perfect mind you, but definately more mature driver wise.

heatlesssun said:
If there is ever a time to wait, then this is it. This year will see perhaps the biggest changes in power and features from the begining of the year to then end for PC's and gamers then any in the five years at least.

What we've got comming....

1) New Intel CPU's, perhaps Intel takes back the enthusiant market?
2) New AMD CPU's, Socket AM2. While a modest upgrade, its still new platform!
3) Windows Vista... probably the change with the biggest impact to gamers is here DX10!
4) DX10 GPU's

So if you can, wait for a little dust to settle, unless you just want the most poweful system you can get at the moment or don't want to wait.

Pretty good advice. That's what I am doing. I am not hurting in the performance department so I'll wait a while before tackling major upgrades.
 
jcll2002 said:
The thing is

1) I hate intel (lol)
2) wont it take a long time for the mobos and cpus to be bugless for AM2(m2?)
3)wont that^^^ be pretty expensive at the beginning with bugs?
4)Can i just upgrade my os to vista later? (I know ill have to reformat, ect)
5) Can you explain alittle more about the technology of dx10, the prices, and the waiting time?

Thanks,
jcll2002
Sir frag, can you answer the concerns i have?
 
jcll2002 said:
So I shouldnt bother with the x1900xt, its $40 more

Bothered by IQ? lol I have no idea what that means.

BTW, ill be keeping this system for a LONG time, if that matters.

Sorry IQ means image quality.
Also if you are keeping it for a long time i would go with the x1900, its more future proofed than the 7800 with the extra shader pipelines.

I bought the x1900xt and flashed it to an x1900xtx
saves a bit of money.
 
I want to see how nvidia counters ATI before I buy any other video card. I have two 7800 gtx 256 meg in sli for now.
 
a few months later there will always be something better.
the question is kinda like this

to buy a vid card = ((new games comming out i want)*(IQ levels)) / (available funds)

if you have the cash... why wait?
just like when doom 3 and HL2 came out Novermber 2 years ago.
everyone went out and got a new card, but that caause there were games that they wanted to play.
If there isn't a game out there right now, that you really want to play! then you dont need to get a new card unless you have the cash for it and just want it.
 
jcll2002 said:
I assume that youre talking about the x1800xt...

Someone said that its overkill to get over a 7800gt on a 1280*1024 monitor. Is this true?

Also, will later games take advantage of the 512 mb? Is it silly to get a 256 card now?
Yeah. Ignore that. Wasnt thinking straight - not taking into account things like 6xAA 16xHQ AF :p Go for the x1900xt, will definitely last longer than a GTX.
 
Back
Top