$70k For Broadband Installation

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I found the broadband bargain of the day! Only $70,000 for a basic install! What a bargain!

A couple who want a broadband connection for their home and guesthouse business have been told by BT it will cost £45,000 to have it installed. Ray and Frei Walker have managed with an old 'dial-up' service for the last nine years at their detached Victorian home in Dufton, Cumbria
 
I would totally pay for it. I would hate to be stuck in the dial up era.
 
Two months ago it emerged that the company's chairman has been provided with high-speed broadband at his rural home - even though the rest of the Oxfordshire village where he lives does not have access.

lol, what a horrible company
 
Its old news, it was in the paper a while ago, but you shouldnt expect anything else from BT.
 
Ha, that's nothing! I've seen 'construction costs' for cable easily exceed half a million dollars because cable was not available in the area where service was needed.
 
Why not just use satellite? Yeah it's not as good as cable by any means but it's way better than dialup...
 
I don't get it. If 150 people in his village already have Broad band. Why doesn't her just setup a wireless link to one of his neighbors? Hell I'd split the bill with them and they would see no noticeable change in their speed. Sounds like this guy doesn't really DL or UL much anyway.

No doubt that Telco sucks but they all do. Take matters into your own hands.
 
I had a friend whose dad paid $30,000 for AT&T to extend their DSL service to his house.
 
We did a qoute for a client that needed Cable extended 500ft to their location... 25K - 15k of it for needing to go under train tracks.
 
It isn't profitable for companies to provide broadband access to rural areas by and large. There's a lot of upfront costs when first implementing the infrastructure of a high speed network. The costs are large enough that it might take years for a company to see a return on investment and this is enough to dissuade a lot of ISPs from even bothering. BT freely admitted they're trying to pass that cost directly to a single customer in this case.

This is why ISPs shouldn't be allowed to exist as for-profit, private entities any longer. Rather, they should operate as public utilities under government control. High speed access to information is fast becoming a basic need in the first world, Just like access to the electric grid. If you take profitability out of the equation and make it a mandate that all citizens be provided access you wouldn't see ridiculous stories like this. You also wouldn't see usage charges rising while bandwidth limitations get tighter and tighter.
 
Comcast wanted $35,000 to extend service to my parents house. My dad bought a new car instead.
 
Hmm...well I once sent Verizon an email asking if they would run fiber to my parents' community of 50 homes if each household would contribute $1,000. They didn't go for it. :(
 
Why not just use satellite? Yeah it's not as good as cable by any means but it's way better than dialup...

Why not? Take HughesNet for example. At the best home plan rate, you're allowed 500 MB of download per 24 hours (with 2.0 Mbps DL / 300 Kbps UL speeds). After that, they limit your connection to something close to dial-up. For $120/month. (After spending $250 for the equipment). Also add a minimum of .5 second lag to anything you do, so don't expect be playing anything that requires a quick response time.

Or you could go for the other popular satellite internet company, WildBlue. Their "value" limit is 7500 MB per 30 days. However, if you use 6000 MB+ (80%+), you're immediately flagged as violating their fair access policy, and your speed is reduced to 128 kb/s DL. If, within 30 days, you don't reduce your total DL to 5250 MB (70%), you're flagged as a second time offender. If you violate their fair access policy 4 times in a row, or 5 times in a 12 month period, you're stuck in super reduced access mode until you use less than 70% of your limit. Of course, should you manage to hit 100% of your limit, your connection is completely shut off for a day or two.
 
It isn't profitable for companies to provide broadband access to rural areas by and large.

The exact same reason 80% of the country wouldn't have electricity right now if it weren't for FDR's Rural Electrification Act. It bothers me when some people say "screw rural areas" when it comes to broadband. I'm sure people said the same thing about electricity before the 1940s. And it was just as short-sighted.
 
These people need to stop being dildos, offer to pay their neighbor's costs for internet and put a yagi in the window... there, simple, covered... all for just over the cost of a pringles can
 
If I had the money I'd pay that to get a sweet-ass FIOS connection out here. Seriously.

U-Verse is much better than Fios. Ask for it. AT&T is wanting to get it out there. Hell, they even give money for trying the service for 30 days. And they don't have contracts either.
 
The exact same reason 80% of the country wouldn't have electricity right now if it weren't for FDR's Rural Electrification Act. It bothers me when some people say "screw rural areas" when it comes to broadband. I'm sure people said the same thing about electricity before the 1940s. And it was just as short-sighted.

spot on. internet today is just as important as electricity was back then too. the biggest difference is the government cares much less about its citizens today then they used to. large condensed cities are favored by the feds, for obvious reasons of control, so those of us who already struggle to live just outside city limits will continue to.
 
Here in Milwaukee Wisconsin we can't even get FIOS and its one of the larger cities in the US.
 
Ha, that's nothing! I've seen 'construction costs' for cable easily exceed half a million dollars because cable was not available in the area where service was needed.

+1

When I used to work for Comcast, I submitted contracts for newly built condos and older apartment buildings to get connected. On average it cost 250K-1M+ to get the work done. Comcast paid it but it was for many people which will pay for itself. For one house to receive cable in a rural area, the company won't make any money so it's understandable that they would charge such a high amount. The equipment alone cost tens of thousands. People who live in rural areas with no access to cable/DSL service should go with satellite Internet.
 
a lot of rural towns offer wifi for a reasonable price too. they set up directional links, and the people i know who have it love it. ping times very nice compared to other services...
 
Oh yeah; forgot the mention that my parents now have mobile broadband and are fine with it.

The difference between Internet today and electricity in the 1940s is that you can't transmit electricity wirelessly (very far, anyway). I think maturation of wireless technology will be the answer to providing rural homes with broadband access.
 
BT are plebs -_-

Wireless isn't a solution, the latency on 3G/4G networks is still far to high (Anything over 150-200ms is too high) for a smooth internet experience.

If the workforce didn't sit and take 3 hour lunch breaks while reading the newspaper and drinking tea they might get some work done and possibly cut the costs down, but hey, thats our typical shiitty workforce for you >_<

Hey BT, while your at it, you might not remember but in 03 you promised me 16Mbit in 06, then in 05 you promised 20Mbit in 09, now your saying 24Mbit in 2011... I'm still on 8Mbit. Oh, and please sort out the 0.05Mbit your giving me during peak times? That is all.
 
It bothers me that the company is made out to blame here. Consider this analogy: Call a pizza place from the next city over for delivery:
  1. You will get no pizza.
  2. You will hear an explanation of why you get no pizza.
  3. You won't get any recommendation for a closer pizza place.
"Your house is not within our service footprint" is the usual response from any service delivery company. If you insist on a quote they may actually do the research for you and provide a quote. In our analogy it would be composed of the gas money for the delivery driver and time to dispatch that far. In the case of our telco installer we look at municipal licensing fees for possible digging or pole wiring and further labour and additional equipment.

It isn't profitable for companies to provide broadband access to rural areas by and large. There's a lot of upfront costs when first implementing the infrastructure of a high speed network. The costs are large enough that it might take years for a company to see a return on investment and this is enough to dissuade a lot of ISPs from even bothering. BT freely admitted they're trying to pass that cost directly to a single customer in this case.

This is why ISPs shouldn't be allowed to exist as for-profit, private entities any longer. Rather, they should operate as public utilities under government control. High speed access to information is fast becoming a basic need in the first world, Just like access to the electric grid. If you take profitability out of the equation and make it a mandate that all citizens be provided access you wouldn't see ridiculous stories like this. You also wouldn't see usage charges rising while bandwidth limitations get tighter and tighter.

I agree with everything said in your first paragraph, but suggesting municipal control as if it were a necessary utility is will only complicate a potentially simple solution as recommended here:

The solution

I don't get it. If 150 people in his village already have Broad band. Why doesn't her just setup a wireless link to one of his neighbors? Hell I'd split the bill with them and they would see no noticeable change in their speed. Sounds like this guy doesn't really DL or UL much anyway.

...put a yagi in the window... there, simple, covered... all for just over the cost of a pringles can

If you're not a DIY kind of person then find a local company that specializes in getting high speed internet to your remote location. Here in Canada there are lots (considering the huge area to cover), but in a small country like the British isle this is easy. The initial cost can be a bit steep depending on the complexity of the job and the required equipment, but no where near what a telco would charge for additional DSLAM ports or cable runs. Furthermore, these smaller service companies are often composed of starving college kids, so they are well versed in "how to keep things cheap"-fu. In the end the important thing is that it beats dial-up. And if you are running a business from home, the extra expenses can be justified.

These rogue telco companies have several ways of making this work:
  1. Contact local telcos and home security services for additional POTS or dry lines to lease and patch from your house to a central location where a high speed service is available, then load balance and split an appropriate number of telco services to each home via auto-negotiating SDSL MODEMs. Fortunately, SDSL is COMMON in the UK so buying the MODEM may be cheaper than they are here in Canada. (Around $400 CAD)
  2. Get your high-speed equipped neighbor involved to host the service splitting equipment and merely beam it via unidirectional antennae. It is honestly ridiculous how well this works for so little cost.
  3. I've also heard of getting public works involved in helping to snake additional lines to your neighbor to run SDSL from house to house, however, this is rare.

Basically, stop barking up the wrong tree and talk to the small ISPs. A little more expensive, but you learn a lot and get involved in some really cool communal projects.
 
U-Verse is much better than Fios. Ask for it. AT&T is wanting to get it out there. Hell, they even give money for trying the service for 30 days. And they don't have contracts either.
i dont know about fios but uverse isnt something to praise imo
the hd quality can be very bad and it adds a good amount of latency if you're a gamer

the only thing it gots going for it is that its price to which will good up to "cable" prices once they get the customer base
 
My dad was denied cable at his house due to the cost of installation. No direct quote, but one CSR said ~5K and another said up to 10K.

So the other day my dad was at Best Buy and a dude walked up and asked if he had cable. He said: "as much as I want it, no one will provide it."

So the guy checked the zipcode for Comcast, and said it was in the area and available.

My dad proceeded to tell the kid(as hes pulling out his checkbook) "If you can get cable run to my house, this $1000 check is yours."

He has a Comcast installer coming on Friday. Lets see if it works.
 
boosh!
713750358.png
 
Did lantec move to the UK? (You know if you get it.)
 
This is why ISPs shouldn't be allowed to exist as for-profit, private entities any longer. Rather, they should operate as public utilities under government control. High speed access to information is fast becoming a basic need in the first world, Just like access to the electric grid. If you take profitability out of the equation and make it a mandate that all citizens be provided access you wouldn't see ridiculous stories like this. You also wouldn't see usage charges rising while bandwidth limitations get tighter and tighter.

No. You don't have a basic right to live wherever you want out in bumblefuck and have the government take tax money from others to run cable out to you. If people want broadband they can move to a place that has it. By your asinine logic, nearly everything in the world should be government-owned. After all, food is a basic necessity, so why not have the govt own grocery stores since it's too expensive to put one in the middle of nowhere to serve one person? Incidentally, it's also hilarious that you regard high speed internet at as a "basic need." Although, I suppose we can all remember the dark ages where deaths from exposure to 28.8 modems were frequent.
 
Back
Top