6990 or 590 to replace a 5870.

Despotes

Gawd
Joined
Aug 27, 2005
Messages
821
After reading many reviews it appears the 2 cards are almost equal in performance if you average all the different games. (Future games? BF3 ect)
I'm leaning towards the 6990, but just not fully convinced the 6990 is the right upgrade.
Is the 6990 the better deal w/ current and mostly future games and is the performance jump from the 5870 significant?
 
To replace a single 5870? I'd recommend a good reference 6950 and unlock the shaders. If performance is a little low, get another matching 6950. It'll still be cheaper than a 6990.

My2c.
 
If you are only running the single monitor in your sig, I would not bother with either one. You are better off waiting for the next gen.
 
Why not just go with a single 6970 or 580? Should be enough for that resolution. But of those two, I'd get the 6990 - just seems like the more solid product this time around.
 
An Nvidia gtx 580 or an Amd radeon 6970 would do you very good. But if you do decide to go with a dual gpu card, either one of them would be good. The Gtx 590 has phyx and cuda while on the other hand radeon 6990 has 4 gb gddr5 memory.
 
I also agree that with that monitor, a 6990 is a little overkill.
but to answer your question, I would go with the 6990 over the 590 because it really is a higher quality card, though it is a little loud and a waste to keep the stock cooler (I've seen numerous 1ghz core clocks on the stock cooler though).

the card is nearly fully 6970x2 spec, and AMD really pulled out all the stops for it and tried their hardiest to make it king of the hill.
The 590 by comparison appears to me as Nvidia's half assed attempt to put out a dual gpu card and making it "good enough".

just my $.02 though
 
Looking at your system I would probably get a new cpu/board and an ssd before upgrading the video card.

Agreed. While an SSD won't have any benefits to your FPS etc it does make for an amazing experience when using a computer. It quite literally speeds up ... everything. SSD and a 6970 would be all you need on a single monitor.

Heck even a 6950 unlocked with slight overclock would probably be more than sufficient.

2500k + 212 cooler = $260ish
ASRock extreme4 = $150
6970 = $340
128GB C300 SSD = $200
$750 W/O SSD
$950 W/ SSD

VS

6990 = $710
590 = 729 (out of stock newegg) to $850 on amazon


Personally i'd go with a more balanced system rather than tossing a huge video card into a system that couldn't expect to max it out. Actually when it comes to that i'd just get a 6950 and crossfire it later (as I plan to do with my system;) )
 
Great. More options thrown my way. I probably do need a mobo/cpu upgrade. The 2500K is on my list, but not sure which chipsets are almost here and if they're even worth the wait. (X68 X79 ect)
Wouldn't a videocard upgrade provide the best performance at 1920X1200 rather than cpu/mobo?

Are all 6950's capable of being bios flashed to 6970 specs? If not, which are?
 
Great. More options thrown my way. I probably do need a mobo/cpu upgrade. The 2500K is on my list, but not sure which chipsets are almost here and if they're even worth the wait. (X68 X79 ect)
Wouldn't a videocard upgrade provide the best performance at 1920X1200 rather than cpu/mobo?

Are all 6950's capable of being bios flashed to 6970 specs? If not, which are?

The 6950 I linked above unlocks. Only reference cards unlock and there is plenty of information on the internet and even a large thread here on these forums about it. The easiest way to tell is to simply read the reviews on newegg. You probably don't have to read more than 3 comments to look for

"doesn't unlock! :mad:"

or
"shaders unlocked!:D"

I think the reason for the suggestion to do a more balanced upgrade is that there is not REALLY a good reason to blow money on high spec video cards if you are only on 1 monitor right now. A 6950 unlocked plays basically everything maxed out anyways.

Also, you might be right about not needing a cpu/mobo upgrade as games tend to not be cpu limited at this resolution. So my suggestion is still SSD + 6950/6970 or just a 6950 and save the rest of your money...
 
The 6950 I linked above unlocks. Only reference cards unlock and there is plenty of information on the internet and even a large thread here on these forums about it. The easiest way to tell is to simply read the reviews on newegg. You probably don't have to read more than 3 comments to look for

"doesn't unlock! :mad:"

or
"shaders unlocked!:D"

I think the reason for the suggestion to do a more balanced upgrade is that there is not REALLY a good reason to blow money on high spec video cards if you are only on 1 monitor right now. A 6950 unlocked plays basically everything maxed out anyways.

Also, you might be right about not needing a cpu/mobo upgrade as games tend to not be cpu limited at this resolution. So my suggestion is still SSD + 6950/6970 or just a 6950 and save the rest of your money...

define maxing out
 
define maxing out

Above playable resolutions with eyecandy on? With the exception maybe of metro 2033 but who actually plays that game.

At 1920x1080 I can't think of a game off the top of my head (aside from metro 2033) that *needs* a better videocard. Mine plays black ops, civ 5, etc with all settings max.

If he had a higher res monitor or multiple monitors it would be a different story...
 
Id be willing to bet a 4.0ghz or better 2500k with a 5870 would be faster than your current processor with any card

*Or at least to where its a wash, then you get the added speed of the cpu in everything else you do
 
I throw my voice behind the peeps saying spend the money upgrading CPU and mobo over getting a 6990.
Might be worth waiting for bulldozer though
 
6990 FTW if you had to choose, however if your using only one monitor stick with what you got until the 7000 series or Kepler.
 
After reading many reviews it appears the 2 cards are almost equal in performance if you average all the different games. (Future games? BF3 ect)
I'm leaning towards the 6990, but just not fully convinced the 6990 is the right upgrade.
Is the 6990 the better deal w/ current and mostly future games and is the performance jump from the 5870 significant?

What game(s) are focused on? If it's Battlefield 3, then I would wait for Kepler or Souther Islands. AMD and Nvidia has bled as much as they could from 40nm If you recall in the past Battlefield series, it usually required in the past, for you to either upgrade your RAM or Video card. Something I remember very distinctly. Battlefield 3 has actually forced me not to upgrade mt 5970 to a 6990 and put my ZR30w on standby.

Dual GPUs is the way to go. I was a single GPU user for awhile. Tried SLI, it was OK nothing special. I did encounter those "microstuttering" aloooong time ago. But not with the 5970.

You can't go wrong with the modern Crossfire or SLI setup now. It's much better when I first started dual GPU setup. Also there is more support now for Dual GPUs.

Now with your 5870, if you are stilling playing games maxed with your resolution there is really no compelling reason to upgrade. You didn't specify what resolution you play, so I assume it's 1920x1200 or below? With that resolution you should be able to handle all the console ports us PC users can muster :)
 
The thing is the 6970 is not significantly faster than a 5870, something like 10-15% (and in DX9 situations it's occasionally slower), and the GTX 580 is only another 10-15% above that, and we are talking about optimally.

So he pretty much has to go CF or a dual GPU card for a significant performance gain.
 
5870 Crossfire is plenty for 1920x. I only suggest that because you already own one and new 5870s are cheap.

http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/300?vs=298

The ones I have in my AMD comp do 1000|1275 with zero problems. I've had them since 5870s were released.

If you're planning on moving to Eyefinity, I'd get the 6990 for the 2Gb frame buffer. Price and performance wise it would be better to get two 6950s and unlock them rather than buying a 6990. If you want a single PCB two GPU card then sell the 5870 and get the 6990. You'd be covered with that card for a while and moving to Eyefinity would be an option too.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, my 790i won't do Crossfire.

I'm thinking...
Intel Core i7-2600K
ASUS P8P67 DELUXE
G.SKILL Ripjaws Series 8GB (2 x 4GB) or
CORSAIR Vengeance 8GB (2 x 4GB)
 
Currently on a 5870 as well and have done research on possible replacements with the current set of cards out now.

I've decided to wait until the HD 7xxx series hits in a few more months and upgrade to that. I recommend the same. :)
 
Not sure if ATi still has driver issues, but yeah I am liking the 6990 alot. It has better reviews and wins more benchmarks. Price is the same, and if the drivers and games ahead will work, then why not. But it also depends on your moniter, I wouldnt upgrade to becuase your gfx card is awesome aswell!
 
I am surprised it hasn't already been suggested, but your q9650 will not bottleneck any of the above cards. And with you already OC's to 4Ghz I would not spend the money on a CPU/Mobo upgrade right now. Especially not with new technology so close (bd)..

That said for the best bang for buck performance upgrade if I were you I would get a pair of these (GTX 560 ti's) Your looking at 410 after rebate for the pair. Here is a 560 ti SLI review. it doesn't have the 6990 on there, but you can judge the relative performance. Also with the cost savings compared to a 6990 you can pick up a 128gb Crucial c300 ssd & still have cash left over.
 
I am surprised it hasn't already been suggested, but your q9650 will not bottleneck any of the above cards. And with you already OC's to 4Ghz I would not spend the money on a CPU/Mobo upgrade right now. Especially not with new technology so close (bd)..

That said for the best bang for buck performance upgrade if I were you I would get a pair of these (GTX 560 ti's) Your looking at 410 after rebate for the pair. Here is a 560 ti SLI review. it doesn't have the 6990 on there, but you can judge the relative performance. Also with the cost savings compared to a 6990 you can pick up a 128gb Crucial c300 ssd & still have cash left over.

Do we know when the new cpu/mobo tech is coming out?
If only a month or two then I'll (Itching to upgrade) hold off on the cpu/mobo upgrade.
 
Last edited:
Currently on a 5870 as well and have done research on possible replacements with the current set of cards out now.

I've decided to wait until the HD 7xxx series hits in a few more months and upgrade to that. I recommend the same. :)

Yep I'm going to replace my 5870s in my AMD rig when the 7000s hit too and move to Eyefinity. Saving up some cash to buy 3 H-IPS or S-IPS LCDs.
 
Just doing some more researching today and at 1920X1200 the 6990 is literally twice as fast in most games compared to the 5870. Not sure how it would scale on my relatively old system.
A new cpu/mobo should do the trick then I'll upgrade when the 7000 series arrive or if BF3 performance is not so nice.
 
just went from a 5870 to a 6990 and noticing a nice increase. About double fps in the games I have tried so far- Crysis 2, and NFS Shift @2560x1600
 
Do we know when the new cpu/mobo tech is coming out?
If only a month or two then I'll (Itching to upgrade) hold off on the cpu/mobo upgrade.

Bulldozer should be out in June. Weather or not it will be faster then SB is yet to be seen. All the leaked benchmarks appear to be faked (way way lopsided to one side or another). But following AMD's track record if it ain't faster then SB it will be priced way lower then SB. But with them releasing up to like 8 core chips for desktop with turbo speeds up to 4.1 Ghz stock. Personally I would not buy a new CPU/Mobo right now unless your getting a hell of a deal.

On the GPU front it will be several more months before anything really new for the enthusiast is released I think.
 
Bulldozer should be out in June. Weather or not it will be faster then SB is yet to be seen. All the leaked benchmarks appear to be faked (way way lopsided to one side or another). But following AMD's track record if it ain't faster then SB it will be priced way lower then SB. But with them releasing up to like 8 core chips for desktop with turbo speeds up to 4.1 Ghz stock. Personally I would not buy a new CPU/Mobo right now unless your getting a hell of a deal.

On the GPU front it will be several more months before anything really new for the enthusiast is released I think.

I'd be really jelly if Bulldozer ends up quicker than SB since I just built my SB system last month oh well.

As for the new 7xxx series, I'm hoping for the 7870 or 7970 whichever is the successor to the 5870. I need it for Battlefield 3!
 
Shift 2- 30-35 fps@ 2560x1600 maxed (60fps with no other cars on the track) game either has poor performance or doesn't scale with multiple GPUs?

If it is basically maintaining 60 fps and seemingly capped, it could be that you have vync on.
 
Shift 2- 30-35 fps@ 2560x1600 maxed (60fps with no other cars on the track) game either has poor performance or doesn't scale with multiple GPUs?

Thx for the input Martha Stewart ;)
I've played that game for the past few weeks and can't figure the FPS barrier out, it is a very frustrating game to run. It seems like the FPS is locked or something weird is going on.
I played Dead Space 2 today and it seems to be capped at 30 fps with VSync and 60 fps without Vsync, seemed weird. It might not scale, I wish these ports could actually be pushed correctly on the PC platform. :(
 
I've decided and ordered:
Intel Core i7-2600K
ASUS P8P67 DELUXE
G.SKILL Ripjaws Series 8GB (2 x 4GB)
Antec KÜHLER H2O 920 w/ Indigo Xtreme.

X68 is not worth it to me. I'll skip it for now and wait for a high end 7000 series videocard.

My current system will go on sale in a few. ;)
 
Either is superfluous with a single monitor. However the 6990 is the better card.

I'd say, take the $700 and blow it on a weekend in Vegas...

Or a good SSD and a 6970.

Nah, Vegas.
 
Last edited:
Bulldozer should be out in June. Weather or not it will be faster then SB is yet to be seen. All the leaked benchmarks appear to be faked (way way lopsided to one side or another). But following AMD's track record if it ain't faster then SB it will be priced way lower then SB. But with them releasing up to like 8 core chips for desktop with turbo speeds up to 4.1 Ghz stock. Personally I would not buy a new CPU/Mobo right now unless your getting a hell of a deal.

On the GPU front it will be several more months before anything really new for the enthusiast is released I think.

According to purported leaks, Bulldozer is slated for a shipping date of June 20th in the US market, though I wouldn't be surprised at all if it came later than that.
 
Back
Top