6800gs or x850xt?

Yes, I'd recommend getting the X800GTO2. Unlock it and OC it past X850XT PE speed. 6800GS and X850XT are really in different leagues, and ATi has been very good with driver support, their recent 5.13 boosted the performance of X850XT by a good 30-40% in some games.

BTW, you can't unlock 6800GS's pipe in PCIe, only in AGP.
 
Brantoc said:
6800GS is by far the better stock and OC card, performance is almost no difference with the human eye (68.9 to 69.2 might as well be the same for all you can tell). The reason I like the 6800 is the company Nvidia. Enless ATI has seriously changed there driver updates are a yearly event.

The 850 is a good OCer, and since the GS is comming with faster memory and a simular core to the 7800GT I would expect OCs to at least GTX speed, which is far and away faster than the 850. If you get an ATI other than the X1900 XTX .. Hope you don't play FEAR. :)

You seem to be confused.... 6800gs is more like the 6800 vanilla with faster ram and possibly newer revision of gpu core. Ati cards also perform generally on par with Nvidia cards in fear.

The SM 3.0 argument also has been brought to a new low here, 6800gs + farcry+ hdr= slideshow. Im pretty sure the same can be said about Oblivion to.

Anyways, if its not obvious already, my vote is for the xt.

Edited for moderation.
 
rmed64 said:
6800GS ftw. SM3 and oced ~X850XT speed and cheaper.

I don't necessarily agree. SM3.0 is nice, but I got my X850XT for $189 AR and I haven't seen any single card 6800GS in our 3DMark05 thread here on [H] score better than my X850XT. Sure, we're talking OC'ed vs. OC'ed, but still. The highest X850XT score documented here is 8152. The highest 6800GS score here is 6730, which was done with an AMD 3700+. I scored 6745 with an old school socket 478 Pentium 4 3.0c.

Stock clocks vs. stock clocks, the X850Xt is even further ahead. I really think the 6800GS is a cool card, with a little better features than the X850XT. But speed vs. speed the X850XT is just a small step ahead.
 
ewb302 said:
I don't necessarily agree. SM3.0 is nice, but I got my X850XT for $189 AR and I haven't seen any single card 6800GS in our 3DMark05 thread here on [H] score better than my X850XT. Sure, we're talking OC'ed vs. OC'ed, but still. The highest X850XT score documented here is 8152. The highest 6800GS score here is 6730, which was done with an AMD 3700+. I scored 6745 with an old school socket 478 Pentium 4 3.0c.

Stock clocks vs. stock clocks, the X850Xt is even further ahead. I really think the 6800GS is a cool card, with a little better features than the X850XT. But speed vs. speed the X850XT is just a small step ahead.


Easy now... I'm only about 800 points behind your 05 score with my GS and p4 system ;)
 
I tried to fluff it :) I honestly really like the 6800GS, but I think the X850XT has more brute power. The X850XT is crippled in the sense that it does not have SM3.0, but I can live with that for a while. If you search my user name, I made a post a while back getting advice on whether to buy the 6800GS, or the X850XT. They are both great... if I would have bought the 6800GS, I would be here hyping it up right now I'm sure. People love to "defend" what they have. I like them both :)
 
ewb302 said:
I tried to fluff it :) I honestly really like the 6800GS, but I think the X850XT has more brute power. The X850XT is crippled in the sense that it does not have SM3.0, but I can live with that for a while. If you search my user name, I made a post a while back getting advice on whether to buy the 6800GS, or the X850XT. They are both great... if I would have bought the 6800GS, I would be here hyping it up right now I'm sure. People love to "defend" what they have. I like them both :)


I completely agree...

I love the people that don't read up on the opposite card just because they are tried and true dedicated fans of 1 particular brand... Then come in and start thumping their chest about their particular card.
 
Was just looking on this forum, some guy is selling his 7800gt for $220 GET THAT!!!
 
air2k6 said:
Was just looking on this forum, some guy is selling his 7800gt for $220 GET THAT!!!


QFT, but you do realize how many people have already jumped all over that?
 
Back
Top