6800 GT or x800 XT

vage

2[H]4U
Joined
Jan 10, 2005
Messages
3,038
I got a Sapphire x800 xt from zipzoomfly and it came broken so I am sending it back. I am also thinking that I wasn't right in the head when I ordered it. What would be better. A 6800 GT or the x800 XT?


P.S. I am not going to overclocking at all.
 
You're all wrong cuz the 6800 has teh pixar shador 3!!!111

Nah, it's say go with the X800XT. Great card, great drivers. Allround nice card the, X800XT.
 
Obviously an X800XT over a 6800GT. By the way, what price did that x800xt come in at?
 
What aboot an X800PRO Flaeshed to X800XT?

How succesful is this flashing buisness?
 
on vivo cards it has about a 95% success rate, on non-vivo its pretty much impossible to do as a softmod.
 
X800XT is better unless you have an SLI board and are planning on setting up SLI eventually.
 
Xt vs Gt..no comparison...x800xt, unless ALL you play is DOOM 3 and other opengl games...the XT is better...if you were talking about the ultra vs xt..that's a different story
 
Heywood Jablome said:
yeah the x800xt and well the x series arent good with the open gl games

no..reword it hehe "not as good" heh
 
To be honest, I wasn't "blown away" like I was expecting with my rig in my sig. Sure it has great graphics and what not, but I'm kinda sappin that I got a GT. I just dont like having to overclock to get the rock steady 1280x1024 4x 8x with everything maxed in HL2. Get the Ultra or X800. Coming from a GT owner.
 
Isaacav2 said:
To be honest, I wasn't "blown away" like I was expecting with my rig in my sig. Sure it has great graphics and what not, but I'm kinda sappin that I got a GT. I just dont like having to overclock to get the rock steady 1280x1024 4x 8x with everything maxed in HL2. Get the Ultra or X800. Coming from a GT owner.
i concur
 
Coming from a former 6800UEE owner, get the XT. The XT is alot smoother at highres with AA/AF.
 
aZn_plyR said:
Xt vs Gt..no comparison...x800xt, unless ALL you play is DOOM 3 and other opengl games...the XT is better...if you were talking about the ultra vs xt..that's a different story

I don't know. I've got a X800XT PE, it replaced my 6800GT, I didn't see any huge difference.

They're both very nice cards, IMO the defining question here is whether we're talking PCIE here or not- then it's GT no question.
 
X800 XT

I say this this becuase it runs the games I prefer better, and from what I've seen it beats the GT in all DX games.
 
Honestly, I'd say that either card is great now, and whether or not you got the "best" card will be seen in about 6 months to a years time; if it turns out that you prefer games coming out using either the Source engine, then the ATI card will be the better choice, whereas if you prefer the ones coming off the D3 engine, then the Nvidia card will be the better choice. Both kick ass now, but how pleased you'll be with them will, in my opinion, be largely dependant on what games come out in the future.
 
It depends on a number of things.

A. Your Price range.
- If you have a small budget then the 6800GT is your card.
B. GFX Bus
-If you are going PCIE get a 6800GT, unless you find the X800XT for cheaper or only a small amount more.

Overall I say both cards are great and either way you win.
 
Well Fidel he already spent the $ and he's just wondering if he should RMA it and get another or get refund and 6800GT. I say go with the XT.
 
Isaacav2 said:
To be honest, I wasn't "blown away" like I was expecting with my rig in my sig. Sure it has great graphics and what not, but I'm kinda sappin that I got a GT. I just dont like having to overclock to get the rock steady 1280x1024 4x 8x with everything maxed in HL2. Get the Ultra or X800. Coming from a GT owner.

Yep, I mean i got a GT as a x-mas present and im not disappointed but an X800 XT would've been better.
 
{NG}Fidel said:
It depends on a number of things.

A. Your Price range.
- If you have a small budget then the 6800GT is your card.
B. GFX Bus
-If you are going PCIE get a 6800GT, unless you find the X800XT for cheaper or only a small amount more.

Overall I say both cards are great and either way you win.

I pretty much agree with this guy, however if its PCI-E go with the 6800gt, you can eventually buy another (and a new mobo if yours isnt compatable right now) and use SLI in the future. This will help your comp. last ALOT longer. If its agp x800xt.
 
What about 6800ultra (or 6800GT at ultra speeds) vs x800xt?

Does the ultra do much better in HL2/CSS?
 
in cs:s you won't notice a difference between a x800pro/xt/xtpe 6800ultra/gt/gt@ultra

its cpu limited...

in HL2..the x800xt/xtpe will be a bit faster than the 6800's
 
aZn_plyR said:
in cs:s you won't notice a difference between a x800pro/xt/xtpe 6800ultra/gt/gt@ultra

its cpu limited...

in HL2..the x800xt/xtpe will be a bit faster than the 6800's
Wicked. Definitely getting a 6800GT then.
 
aZn_plyR said:
in cs:s you won't notice a difference between a x800pro/xt/xtpe 6800ultra/gt/gt@ultra

its cpu limited...

in HL2..the x800xt/xtpe will be a bit faster than the 6800's


not true at ALL

sure, maybe not for an x800 pro. but with an X800XT your getting a %20 performance boost (especially with higher resolutions)

http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2278&p=3

if ur going to be playing HL2 and such, it's pretty obvious to get an ATI card///
 
dnottis said:
I don't know if this would interest you guys but we just posted a 6800 Ultra vs X800XT PE review - HL2, CSS were very close at 1600x1200 4/8.

http://www.3dxtreme.net/index.php?id=atix800xtpevsevga6800ultra1

Enjoy.

Thank you, this is actually the kind of comparisane I've wanted for a while. Also, the PCI-E version of the ultra is quite a bit more expensive then the PCI-E version of the x800xt.

Looks like its ATI all the way for me.
 
NP, I'm hoping Kyle or Steve link it on the front page - I've sent it to the News email.
 
The only problem with the Ultra is that it's EXTREMELY expensive here in canada. It's hard to find one UNDER $700. I'll just get an XT, and OC it to over X850 XT-PE speeds/

Edit: Even finding in GT under $600 is hard, But I've found an X800XT ofr $585 which will do me fine/
 
Hate_Bot said:
The only problem with the Ultra is that it's EXTREMELY expensive here in canada. It's hard to find one UNDER $700. I'll just get an XT, and OC it to over X850 XT-PE speeds/

Edit: Even finding in GT under $600 is hard, But I've found an X800XT ofr $585 which will do me fine/
NCIX.com has eVGA 6800GTs on for like $490 or $500 Canadian this week.
 
heres the deal its all about price vs performance x850xt pe is the best available period but its like $700 then theres the evga 6800UEE at like $600 then below that is the x800xt at $500 then theres the BFG 6800gt OC at like $380 then theres the other 6800gt's and then the x800pros (i do not recommend the pro) frankly the best card for the money is easily the BFG 6800gt OC wich can be overclocked to well over 6800ultra levels (im running mine at 420/1100) and with a voltmod it can reach 6800UEE speeds (youll need an nv5 silencer though)...that card at 420/1100 is more than enough to compete with the x800xt pe at a fraction of the cost but if you got the cash then what the hell get the x800xt pe
 
PCI-E 6800GT is Over $600.

While I can get an X800XT for $585.

Seeing as how an XT beats a GT, (for me at least) theres really no hard choice/

But if your talking AGP, then I would suggest an 6800GT.
 
Hate_Bot said:
The only problem with the Ultra is that it's EXTREMELY expensive here in canada. It's hard to find one UNDER $700. I'll just get an XT, and OC it to over X850 XT-PE speeds/

Edit: Even finding in GT under $600 is hard, But I've found an X800XT ofr $585 which will do me fine/

R U Kiddin' GT's PCIe are everywhere and well under $500.
 
X800 XT goers, I have no intention to start a war but based on my recent experience with X850 XT, 6800GT and 6600GT. I'd say you can tell the difference on a good monitor. Im not talking about comparing them in Doom3 or HL2 'cause those games are kinda card biased.
With ralatively card neutral games, GT renders a bit better images than XT.
Plus, did anybody mention SM 3.0? OK, let me put it this way, just run 3DMark 03 on both and watch Game 4 Mother Nature and you will see. Speed isn't everything not to mention you can easily OC a 6800GT close to the Ultra. Also, XT generates tremendous amount of heat and will jack up the temp in your case BIG time..."Watch out, boy! She's a maneater..."
 
ImLazZzy said:
X800 XT goers, I have no intention to start a war but based on my recent experience with X850 XT, 6800GT and 6600GT. I'd say you can tell the difference on a good monitor. Im not talking about comparing them in Doom3 or HL2 'cause those games are kinda card biased.
With ralatively card neutral games, GT renders a bit better images than XT.
Plus, did anybody mention SM 3.0? OK, let me put it this way, just run 3DMark 03 on both and watch Game 4 Mother Nature and you will see. Speed isn't everything not to mention you can easily OC a 6800GT close to the Ultra. Also, XT generates tremendous amount of heat and will jack up the temp in your case BIG time..."Watch out, boy! She's a maneater..."
Erm.. 3dmark03 doesn't even use SM3, nor do either cards look alot different at default settings.
And "Temperature wise the cooling design really proves it works. At idle, normal operation expect ~42 Degrees C. At 100% VPU utilization we measured a 60 Degrees C temperature, which is quite good actually."
http://www.guru3d.com/article/Videocards/176/2/
As Spock would say, you logic is flawed.
Btw, a X850XT isn't an X800XT.. the X850XT is clocked the same as the X850XT-PE, it's the same thing, but easier to produce.
I'm not going to brother any more with you, I think pretty much everyone here will notice got ignorant you are by your post alone.
 
Back
Top