64 or P4

Myorthos

n00b
Joined
Jun 21, 2004
Messages
31
I'm putting together a computer to use while in college for mostly gaming, general web browsing, and school work (which may include graphic design or programing).

I could go with a P4 (Socket 775), PCI-E video and DDR2 RAM, or a 64-bit AMD with DDR and AGP video.

Pretty much everything else in the systems is the same, serial HDs, same amount of RAM, same expansions. The P4 processor would probably be a 3.2 or 3.4, while the AMD processor would most likely be 2.4 and the video card for the P4 would be something around a 5750 and the AGP would be a 5950 or there-abouts.

So which would be a better investment over the next four years (while I'm in college and can't afford a new computer). I know the P4 would be better for now, but the AMD would be better in the future after an introduction of 64-bit programs.
 
Since you didn't post actual model numbers (I haven't memorized speeds), it is hard to say. However, typically the athlon is going to be a better buy now and in the future.
 
Intel if gaming isn't a top priority. Even then though an athlon 64 would give you some nice futureproofing.
 
64-Bit machine
----------------------
Asus A8V Deluxe VIA Socket 939
AMD 3500+ 2.20GHz 64bit
3 sticks of 512 DDR400 RAM
2 200GB SATA150s
2 80GB ATAs (RAID 0)
Geforce 5950 or so (but I havn't really looked around at cards yet)


P4 machine
--------------------
550 / 3.4GHz socket 775, 800 FSB Pentium 4
3 sticks of 512 DDR533 or higher (PC4300 or better, depending on mobo).
2 200GB SATA150s
2 80GB ATAs (RAID 0)
Geforce 5750 PCI-E (but then I havn't even looked at more than a few PCI-E video cards yet).

I've got a couple of socket 775 motherboards in mind, but I havn't decided on one yet, so I'll just leave that out.

The only reason I'm looking at a P4 system is because of the PCI-E and DDR2 support.
 
But the amd solution won't have pci express until nForce 4 so ....

It will future proof you WHEN the nForce 4 mobos come out which is Dec onwards :rolleyes:

From what i read A1-A2 are faulty. A3 should shoud solve the Hyper transport problem i read.

Amd definately is a better gaming rig :cool:
 
alright, thanks for the input. It'll go to mind.

I think I'm probably going to wait a couple more months (work some more ;)) and wait for some more stuff to come out before I buy, I just have to do it before I go to college or else I'll be too broke to get it.
 
BUT neither PCI-E and DDR2 show any speed improvements that are worth while! Just get a amd 64 system and a gf 6800 GT/ultra or a ati x800 and u'd be all set and less waiting! :p
 
Tazman2 said:
BUT neither PCI-E and DDR2 show any speed improvements that are worth while! Just get a amd 64 system and a gf 6800 GT/ultra or a ati x800 and u'd be all set and less waiting! :p
That's because no current cards could even utilize the increase in performance from AGP 8x to PCI-E, hell, even now there is barely a difference between AGP 4x & 8x. Today, I wouldn't ditch my AGP 6800 for a PCI-E, it just doesn't make sense; there is absolutly no incentive, or reason, for people with existing reasonably new systems to upgrade their DX9 powered graphics cards and go PCI-E, that's not what I'm saying here. What I am saying is if you are making a new system and want to have it as futureproof as possible, then PCI-E is the way to go. In three years it is legacy.

Just think, AGP 8x is 66MHz. PCI-E is 2.5GHz...

Now that's futureproofing.
 
Back
Top