6150/430 completely incompatible with Antec PSUs?

Sabrewulf165

2[H]4U
Joined
Jun 23, 2004
Messages
2,978
Here's my system:

-Antec performance one P150 case
-Antec Neo HE 430, 2x Trupower II 430 2.0, Smartpower 350 2.0, Truepower II 480 2.0
-GIGABYTE GA-K8N51PVMT-9 Socket 939 NVIDIA GeForce 6150 Micro ATX AMD Motherboard
-AMD Athlon 64 X2 3800+
-Corsair Value 1 GB kit (2x512 matched)
-WD Caviar SE 250 GB SATA II 3.0 gpbs HDD
-Gigabyte 7800 GT Zalman cooled model

This setup will not work with any of the power supplies listed. It will power up once, but not POST or boot (no VGA output, no OS loading). On subsequent attempts, it will not even power, nothing at all.

HOWEVER... the entire system runs flawlessly with a wimpy 250 watt Dell power supply from an Optiplex GX270. Barring further research, this leads me to believe that my board and current Antec power supplies are incompatible with one another. I have no idea why this would be, but it's extraordinarily irritating.

Has anyone else experienced a similar problem and/or found a solution to such a problem? I'm planning on purchasing a non-Antec PSU this afternoon to see if I get different results, but regardless, I am stuck with the Neo HE 430 since that's what came with my case. I really don't feel like having to sell it off separately and buy a new power supply. This case/psu combo was already expensive enough to begin with.
 
This issue happens on all 6100 series boards, yes.... check the SFF forums too.
 
The TruePower and SmartPower series is pretty good, no issues from what I know. It is only the NeoHE that is having teething problems. If anything, it could be your motherboard, yes...
 
Yeah I'm content to blame the board as well, but that still doesn't explain why the Dell 250w PSU is powering it with no problems where 5 different Antec power supplies could not.
 
I just recieved my P150 yesterday, and I'm having almost the exact same problem as the original poster.

After hooking most of my vital components up, I decided to give it a power-test first before continuing. ....... nothing. Not even a hum or whisper of life. I took my old Antec Truepower 480 and hooked up the motherboard leads, hit the power button, and everything sprang to life.

My motherboard is an MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum.

I rarely actually see defective parts (it's almost always human error), but I can't think of anything else other than the NeoPower 430 is DOA. I haven't heard of any compatibility issues with MSI.

So I just went and bought a NeoPower 480 at a brick-n-mortar store ($140 jesus). That way if this one doesn't work I can easily return in.

There's no way I'm returning the entire case to ZipZoomFly. Too much hassle. So I contacted Antec directly to see if they can just replace the psu, in which case I will then sell it.

Moral of the story: don't ever buy a case with an included psu.
 
Supposedly there is an updated version of the neohe that can be recieved through rma which is supposed to fix the issue with asus boards.
 
Back
Top