5850 Crossfire or GTX 570...

pandora's box

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Sep 7, 2004
Messages
4,976
Wondering if I should add another 5850 for some crossfire action or if i should go to GTX 570.

I play games at 1920x1080 with atleast 4xAA when possible.


Currently running a 5850 at 975 core 1225 memory with a core i5 750 at 4GHz.

I can get a Asus DirectCU 5850 for $220 or I can get a 570 for $350 and sell my current 5850 for around $175.


Thoughts, opinions?
 
I'm going to guess CFX 5850 would yield better performance.
 
I vote for the 570. It will be ultimately cheaper and you won't have mutli-GPU issues. It also gives you the option to SLI sometime down the line.

Two 5850s are roughly the same as a 5970, which is roughly on par with a 480, which is roughly a 570
 
Two 5850s are roughly the same as a 5970, which is roughly on par with a 480, which is roughly a 570

No they're not - roughly a 5970 is a 580.

At this point though, I'd just wait to see what the 69xx's bring out..
 
Depends. If your willing to potentially deal with the headache that is CF, then at 1080p the 5850s will spank the 570.

If you want a trouble-free experience, and in the future you might upgrade monitors, then the 570 is a safer bet.
 
I'm sitting pretty with my 5850's...have had them for a while, and doubt Cayman will be much faster....take from that what you will.
 
I think 1 GTX570 would be plenty of gaming power.
 
My 5850s crush everything I throw at them using my 1080p TV. Only Metro 2033 at very high dx11 settings sees any noticeable slowdown. I see no reason to upgrade my system until late next year when socket 2011 and the 28nm gpu's are out. I also fail to see these CFX issues people always talk about, mine runs flawlessly as long as I download the latest profiles which takes a whole extra two minutes to do with each driver update..
 
Yeah I'd for sure take crossfired 5850's over a single 570.
 
keep in mind that the 5850s will not support the new features... including 3D... if that matters to you in any ways. Just something to keep in mind

I run two 5850s and very happy with them... OC them a little and they get even more amazing
 
Wondering if I should add another 5850 for some crossfire action or if i should go to GTX 570.

I play games at 1920x1080 with atleast 4xAA when possible.


Currently running a 5850 at 975 core 1225 memory with a core i5 750 at 4GHz.

I can get a Asus DirectCU 5850 for $220 or I can get a 570 for $350 and sell my current 5850 for around $175.


Thoughts, opinions?

Doubt that the next 5850 you get will allow you to get 975/1225. Neither of my 5850s broke 900.
 
reference 5850s break 900 easy... I don't know anyone that has not been able too.

but agree, if you cant get a reference card I wouldn't bother getting another one
 
Wondering if I should add another 5850 for some crossfire action or if i should go to GTX 570.

I play games at 1920x1080 with atleast 4xAA when possible.


Currently running a 5850 at 975 core 1225 memory with a core i5 750 at 4GHz.

I can get a Asus DirectCU 5850 for $220 or I can get a 570 for $350 and sell my current 5850 for around $175.


Thoughts, opinions?

3rd option, pick up a used 5850. at your res crossfire 5850 will spank the 570GTX for the same money. (H showed the advantage of the 580GTX at 4mp being the larger frame buffer) then again both will max most anything out at that res.

right now my only issue with the 570GTX is the price. the irony here is that at any other time 350 would have been an awesome price for that card. but right now with the price war in the midrange it puts it too high. right now you can pick up a 5870 for around 250 (have seen it for 215AR). the 570GTX is the better card (performance wise) but its not a 100 dollars better. (if you look at the H reviews the 5870 give more or less the same real world game play as a 480GTX, the same as a 570GTX.)
 
Do you even need it ?

Single 5850 should take care of almost any game at that resolution.
 
Do you even need it ?

Single 5850 should take care of almost any game at that resolution.

yeah i decided 1 5850 is good enough and spent the money i was going to use on a PS3 instead. Been wanting to check out some of the exclusives on the PS3 for a while now.
 
My 5850s crush everything I throw at them using my 1080p TV. Only Metro 2033 at very high dx11 settings sees any noticeable slowdown. I see no reason to upgrade my system until late next year when socket 2011 and the 28nm gpu's are out. I also fail to see these CFX issues people always talk about, mine runs flawlessly as long as I download the latest profiles which takes a whole extra two minutes to do with each driver update..

Where do you get the profiles?
 
yeah i decided 1 5850 is good enough and spent the money i was going to use on a PS3 instead. Been wanting to check out some of the exclusives on the PS3 for a while now.

i think that's a good choice! ;) the 5850 rocks :D
 
Why would you need a PS3? Its like a PC for those without the intelligence to assemble a pc.

No point if you have a decent PC.

And I doubt 69xx will lower the prices of 58xx as 68xx has already done that
 
Why would you need a PS3? Its like a PC for those without the intelligence to assemble a pc.

No point if you have a decent PC.

And I doubt 69xx will lower the prices of 58xx as 68xx has already done that

Stop posting.

PS3s are great and serve a purpose beyond a computer, I am using my PS3 right now.

I think it was a great decision to get a 5850 and a PS3...
 
Stop posting.

PS3s are great and serve a purpose beyond a computer, I am using my PS3 right now.

I think it was a great decision to get a 5850 and a PS3...

Consoles are for economicaly disadvantged (relativlley) people and little kids, and those to stupid to asmeble a pc.

Op clearly wealthy, is not stupid, can work with hardware.

What does he need a PS3 for?

Just buy a B ray drive for 50$ and a second 5850 and be done with it.
 
Consoles are for economicaly disadvantged (relativlley) people and little kids, and those to stupid to asmeble a pc.
Always relevant.
Sometimes we argue with each other here at [H], but I think we can all agree, we look amazing in V-necks.

PC_Gaming_Master_Race.jpg
 
Consoles are for economicaly disadvantged (relativlley) people and little kids, and those to stupid to asmeble a pc.

Op clearly wealthy, is not stupid, can work with hardware.

What does he need a PS3 for?

Just buy a B ray drive for 50$ and a second 5850 and be done with it.

If your a gamer, the PS3 is a good bet. Titles on that thing we can only dream of seeing the light of day on a PC, unfortunately.

I've got one to play stuff like Uncharted 2.

Also have a 360 to play Red Dead Redemption and Gears of War 2 & 3.
 
Wait for the 6900 series as mentioned, however dont get 5850 crossfire. This setup will go down in history as the buggiest 2 card crossfire of all time. 5850/5870 scaling is notoriously borked in certain games and require certain drivers with certain games, 1/4 of the time you'll disable crossfire and run one card and then realize one day you should never have even bothered. You'd honestly be better off selling the 5850 you have and getting 2 6870s as they would blow 5850 crossfire away. Not just performance wise, I'm talking about bug wise as well. 6900 is 3-4 days away at this point.
 
Consoles are for economicaly disadvantged (relativlley) people and little kids, and those to stupid to asmeble a pc.

You might look better making this argument if you could actually spell.

/Owns PC, Wii, 360, PS3
 
You might look better making this argument if you could actually spell.

Why does he need to know how to spell? He obviously is a PC gamer therefore he is economically advantaged and therefore has no need to spell. He can have his console peons spell for him.
 
If your a gamer, the PS3 is a good bet. Titles on that thing we can only dream of seeing the light of day on a PC, unfortunately.

I've got one to play stuff like Uncharted 2.

Also have a 360 to play Red Dead Redemption and Gears of War 2 & 3.

THe only thing you can play on the Xbox is Red Dead ring of death.
 
Last edited:
THe only thing you can play on the Xbox is Red Dead ring of death.

That's old news heh. Consoles have alot of games worth getting that will never come to the pc. Like Red Dead Redemption. Anyone know if thats ever coming to pc? I got a 360 but would rather play on the pc for obvious reasons.
 
I aqssume it will come to PC. Most rockstar games do after a year or so.
 
Consoles are for economicaly disadvantged (relativlley) people and little kids, and those to stupid to asmeble a pc.

Op clearly wealthy, is not stupid, can work with hardware.

What does he need a PS3 for?

Just buy a B ray drive for 50$ and a second 5850 and be done with it.

THe only thing you can play on the Xbox is Red Dead ring of death.

I aqssume it will come to PC. Most rockstar games do after a year or so.

you are getting a little annoying...

also you should learn how to spell.

the are so many many many many things a PS3 can do that a PC can not, and so many things a PC can do that a PS3 cant.... not really the topic that anyone here cares about though, but you are surely taking it to the grave
 
you are getting a little annoying...

also you should learn how to spell.

the are so many many many many things a PS3 can do that a PC can not, and so many things a PC can do that a PS3 cant.... not really the topic that anyone here cares about though, but you are surely taking it to the grave

What can the PS3 do that PC can't? Play a few crappy ps3 only games?

I can only think of 3 that are even close to being worth playing.

Killzone 2 and Uncharted 2 and RDR.
 
Games at 720p, no thanks.
PC's haven't seen that resolution for over 10 years.
 
Back
Top