512mb a must for 1920x1200?

sj41

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 6, 2003
Messages
200
Building a new computer (been quite a while since my last) and I'm having a difficult time choosing the right video card. Currently, I'm using a 24 inch Dell flat panel (1900x1200) with a x800pro and it's way too laggy (p4 3.2 prescott, corsair 2gb ddr400). I plan on playing WoW, Splinter Cell: Double Agent, F.E.A.R., and some other games as well with this new rig (mostly WoW).
Main question is, is a 512mb card a MUST for 1920x1200 resolution? Been searching all over and I've read a lot of different views on it. Will a x1950xt 256mb (NOT x1950xtx 512mb) be able to play WoW at 1920x1200 with full eye candy enabled? Or do I need to get something different like a 7950gt instead? While I would prefer an ATI, I'm willing to get whatever works (cheaper would be better). I'm aware the x1950xt outperforms the 7950gt, but what about the 256mb ram difference? Also, I'm not looking to go top of the line, not with dx10 cards just on the horizon, so I just need something to hold me over till vista and dx10 cards go mainstream. Rest of the specs will be, C2D e6400, ASUS P5b Deluxe/Wifi, Corsair 2gb ddr2-800(4-4-4-12), Corsair 520w psu (not sure if I plan on overclocking). Any recommendations on which card will be sufficient? (not limited to those 2 cards mentioned, open to anything that works) Thanks in advance.
 
You have a problem if the X800pro can't do it. It should be more than enough. Try OCing the CPU if you have lagg. You could very well have a CPU bottleneck, Prescotts are pretty slow; you have to really crank up the clock speed.


BTW, for reference, my 9800pro 128MB didn't have to much problem doing WoW at full blast @ 1680x1050. It had a A64 3200+ backing it up though.
 
Obi_Kwiet said:
You have a problem if the X800pro can't do it. It should be more than enough. Try OCing the CPU if you have lagg. You could very well have a CPU bottleneck, Prescotts are pretty slow; you have to really crank up the clock speed.


BTW, for reference, my 9800pro 128MB didn't have to much problem doing WoW at full blast @ 1680x1050. It had a A64 3200+ backing it up though.

OCing is out of the question, it's a Shuttle =/. Also I forgot to mention, I'm running a dual monitor setup, 24 inch as main and 17 inch as secondary (tried both playing in normal and windowed mode, doesn't help). And while I can play the game, I can't play with high settings and even without high settings on, it still shows video lag at times (30-40fps normal, <10 fps sometimes)

EDIT: the weakest part of my current computer is the hard drive, which is a old WD 80gb PATA drive, could that have anything to do with it?
 
Obi_Kwiet said:
You have a problem if the X800pro can't do it. It should be more than enough. Try OCing the CPU if you have lagg. You could very well have a CPU bottleneck, Prescotts are pretty slow; you have to really crank up the clock speed.


BTW, for reference, my 9800pro 128MB didn't have to much problem doing WoW at full blast @ 1680x1050. It had a A64 3200+ backing it up though.

Im guessing its more of a X800 Pro and Prescott problem. F.E.A.R is a shader intensive game and the X800Pro probably cant handle it that good. Im pretty sure Splinter Cell is even more shader extensive. On top of that he does have a Prescott which are for today stuff. Hell I barely get 1440x900 with that overclock with anything higher than medium settings.
 
ok, your cpu may not be great, but it's your gpu that is seriously holding you back

anyways,
http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics.html?modelx=33&model1=551&model2=552&chart=227

and

http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics.html?modelx=33&model1=551&model2=552&chart=231

are pretty good references

i set the resolution up high because that's where you will be, as well as it will remove as much of a cpu dependence as possible. when at these kinds of resolutions, and when dealing with the individual sm2.0 and sm3.0 scores, 3Dmark is pretty good judge for comparing cards

as you can see, the 256mb version gets trounced at the high res. granted it is 75mhz slower on core, and 50mhz on mem, but that shouldn't lead to the amount of dominance, UNLESS the amount of ram has something to do with it.

this is not by any means a true comparison, at least for the x1900 series, but it might predictive.

i will try to find the x1900xt256 VS x1900xt512 from alittle back

brb
 
Lazy_Moron said:
Im guessing its more of a X800 Pro and Prescott problem. F.E.A.R is a shader intensive game and the X800Pro probably cant handle it that good. Im pretty sure Splinter Cell is even more shader extensive. On top of that he does have a Prescott which are for today stuff. Hell I barely get 1440x900 with that overclock with anything higher than medium settings.

Btw I haven't even tried to play F.E.A.R with my current setup, I'm pretty sure it'll be unplayable. Also, my card doesnt support SM 3.0 so Splinter Cell won't even run.
 
Obi_Kwiet said:
You have a problem if the X800pro can't do it. It should be more than enough. Try OCing the CPU if you have lagg. You could very well have a CPU bottleneck, Prescotts are pretty slow; you have to really crank up the clock speed.


BTW, for reference, my 9800pro 128MB didn't have to much problem doing WoW at full blast @ 1680x1050. It had a A64 3200+ backing it up though.

I disagree.

I think for 1920x1200 and high details you're going to like having 512MB's of RAM. I went from a 7900GT CO 256MB stock (500/1500) and was playing CoD2, BF2, FEAR CS: S @ 1920x1200 at full details with some AA/AF and it played them pretty good, except for CoD2 would dip pretty bad and so would FEAR. Well I sold that card and bought myself an X1950XTX and now games run a LOT smoother. I have no troubles turning on ADAA/AF at 1920x1200 now with high details. I also get the benefit of high quality AF.

You will appreciate this difference too, I just don't think a 12 pipe x800 pro is going to cut it for 1920x1200. It might do fine with medium/high details and no aa/af.

Now what card you want depends on what amount of money you have. If it's $200-300 aim for an X1950Pro $400 get an X1950XTX. $400+ get an 8800GTS.

If you have a lot of money I'm going to advise you to pick up an X1950Pro/XTX and wait on the R600. It's going to be a beast and it's out sometime in February.
 
winston856 said:
I disagree.

I think for 1920x1200 and high details you're going to like having 512MB's of RAM. I went from a 7900GT CO 256MB stock (500/1500) and was playing CoD2, BF2, FEAR CS: S @ 1920x1200 at full details with some AA/AF and it played them pretty good, except for CoD2 would dip pretty bad and so would FEAR. Well I sold that card and bought myself an X1950XTX and now games run a LOT smoother. I have no troubles turning on ADAA/AF at 1920x1200 now with high details. I also get the benefit of high quality AF.

You will appreciate this difference too, I just don't think a 12 pipe x800 pro is going to cut it for 1920x1200. It might do fine with medium/high details and no aa/af.

Now what card you want depends on what amount of money you have. If it's $200-300 aim for an X1950Pro $400 get an X1950XTX. $400+ get an 8800GTS.

If you have a lot of money I'm going to advise you to pick up an X1950Pro/XTX and wait on the R600. It's going to be a beast and it's out sometime in February.

The x1950pro has only 256mb. Wouldn't a x1950xt be better for a 256mb card? (only ~$20 difference) Also, if 512mb helps alot like you say, wouldn't a 7950gt (512mb) be a better choice than both of them? (around same price as x1950xt)
 
sj41 said:
The x1950pro has only 256mb. Wouldn't a x1950xt be better for a 256mb card? (only ~$20 difference) Also, if 512mb helps alot like you say, wouldn't a 7950gt (512mb) be a better choice than both of them? (around same price as x1950xt)

Sorry I was referring to the X1950Pro 512MB but it still might be a little weak.

The Sapphire X1950XTX is $399 and it has no trouble with any of the latest games. The only one's it would struggle in at 1920x1200 is Oblivion, CoH. I play CoH right now with everything on the highest setting with no AA and it plays great. It's only when I zoom in to the guys that the fps drop down and starts getting a little choppy but I'm never zoomed in so it doesn't matter.

The 7950GT isn't a bad card, it's a little slower than an X1900XT 256. You however want 512 so I'd get a X1950XTX if you want ATi performance for $400. If you want a little more performance, 8800GTS is $450 for nVidia.

I'm gonna sell this X1950XTX when the R600 comes out and by that.
 
Back
Top