5 Features Windows 9 Needs To Succeed

Or in other words:

1. Be a Mac.
2. Be a Mac.
3. Be a Mac.
4. Be a Mac.
5. Be a Mac.
 
Spot on...

No edit or I would add this to one of my other posts: The only thing I would prefer is that the computer does not need a reboot after installing updates. Of course, even Linux based machines are needing a reboot now after updates so I am not sure how Microsoft could pull it off.
 
Here's a better list:

1. Don't be Windows 8.
2. Don't be Windows Vista.
3. Don't be Windows ME.
4. Be like Windows 7.
5. Be like Windows XP..
 
1. Don't copy what Apple is doing
2. Don't mimic what a tablet can do (if you have a touch screen then there should be an addition package to install, make those people the exception not the norm)
3. Make it act like a Windows desktop that untold number of years people have become accustomed to.

I don't need 5, operating systems don't need to be "edgy" or "hip"
 
I think some of the points are dead on. The Windows Update system is horrible. Unless you have the tools and the technical know how to integrate updates into your build, a fresh install of Windows 7 (SP1) needs 120+ individual updates and ~4 reboots to be current? WTH! There's no reason why Microsoft can't release roll-ups like they do with the rest of their products. Not to mention, updates will commonly fail to install because they are installed out of order or requires a prerequisites and reboot first.
 
It will be interesting to see how Win9 is received by the enterprise desktop covering press tomorrow.

From the short demo I've seen so far, it just looks like the same tablet-ized crap that MS tried pushing on that segment with Win8 -- but now with a start menu!!!11 99 problems minus one is still 98 problems.
 
Here's a better list:

1. Don't be Windows 8.
2. Don't be Windows Vista.
3. Don't be Windows ME.
4. Be like Windows 7.
5. Be like Windows XP..

Be like Windows 7 or XP. Can't have both. 7 is leagues ahead of XP. XP is complete shit in comparison.

With Windows 8, are you not liking the UI, or is everything under the hood fine? Be like Windows 8 but look more like Windows 7?

I think they need to get Windows 9 out fast, as Windows 8 is pretty much universally disliked across a lot of different demographics. A few people love it, but generally it is not well liked. They need to move past that name, that look, everything.
 
I'm really not getting the whole Windows 8 hate and I'm really getting tired of hearing about it. I know there are some issues and you need to get used to the UI, but it's really not that bad of an OS.
 
I know there are some issues and you need to get used to the UI, but it's really not that bad of an OS.

It's not a bad OS at all. It's a step up from Windows 7. The biggest complaint is the UI. A lot of people refuse to upgrade because of it. Not that they CAN'T use it, but they don't like it and don't WANT to use it.
 
Be like Windows 7 or XP. Can't have both. 7 is leagues ahead of XP. XP is complete shit in comparison.

With Windows 8, are you not liking the UI, or is everything under the hood fine? Be like Windows 8 but look more like Windows 7?

I think they need to get Windows 9 out fast, as Windows 8 is pretty much universally disliked across a lot of different demographics. A few people love it, but generally it is not well liked. They need to move past that name, that look, everything.


i still like xp… .it is so much faster than 7, i recently booted up an old celeron 1 ghz with xp, and i swear, web pages load much faster than on my win 7 box with a 4670k
 
Other than #4, everything was shit. I don't want my stuff in the cloud and I do not want to restore over the air. Ever.
 
Other than #4, everything was shit. I don't want my stuff in the cloud and I do not want to restore over the air. Ever.

#3 was great for me. I do the same but with a registry change. Install programs to a different drive and leave the SSD to the OS. Only by default, I can change it manually when installing the application...
 
The author of the article:
I'm still coming across updates that just don't want to install, and trying to diagnose the problem can be a long task.

He must have screwed up something in the OS or installed a crappy program that screwed up the OS. As a professional support tech, the only time I've had issues installing updates is when the user installed some crappy, unsupported, far-off-the-mainstream app that messed up a system file or the registry. It's like people who go to those cheap-o out of the way, non-name brand gas stations to save 3 cents per gallon when they fill up their cars. Of course things are going to go wrong when you go cheap.

On occasion, I have seen updates that wouldn't install because they were updates for older versions of IE just after the new version of IE was installed. Granted, Microsoft's updater needs some correction. It needs to present the updates for the current version of IE or the new version of IE, but not both in the same set. In this case, if an update doesn't install, it wasn't meant to.

This author is obviously just a regular user, not a technical type. If he were a techie, he'd know this. This also obviously shows he's more of a Mac idiot, who let's the system take care of itself rather than someone capable of handling technical details. He probably takes his car to Grease Monkey to change the oil and has them do whatever they claim the car needs for repairs or maintenance.

Secondly:
If there's one trick that Microsoft should learn from Apple, it is how to make backing up easier. The Time Machine mechanism in OS X is simply awesome, and takes all the strain out of backing up a system, and after the initial setup it is a total "fire and forget" system.

This guy obviously doesn't know what a decent backup system is, and doesn't know how to use one. Yes, Windows does need a decent backup system, but having Microsoft build in one that emulates the horribleness that is Apple Time Machine is a really bad idea.

There are really good backup programs out there, purchased separately. That's is the way an OS is supposed to work. It gives the basics while you fill in what it needs.

This guy is obviously someone who wants it all from one source, which is the mentality that got Microsoft sued for IE years ago. Microsoft is not going to include mainstream function apps that are good enough to replace what else is in the market in their operating systems anymore. They'll just get sued for anti-trust again.

This guy is probably some socialist that thinks the government should supply everything, like government health care, government birth control, government gas stations, and government grocery stores.

What the heck is this guy writing for a tech site, anyway. He's no techie. He's totally unqualified to be writing about this stuff.
 
Other than #4, everything was shit. I don't want my stuff in the cloud and I do not want to restore over the air. Ever.

The cloud is actually quite useful for document transfer, especially between Android phones and computers as well as computer to computer. I don't use it much for 'storage' though.
 
I'm really not getting the whole Windows 8 hate and I'm really getting tired of hearing about it. I know there are some issues and you need to get used to the UI, but it's really not that bad of an OS.

The UI was Windows 8's sole major downfall. Just about everything else in the OS is great, showing that lots of thought was put into the new/additional functionality.

Taken with just that, Win8 is a real upgrade from Windows 7.

In their zeal to try and PUSH a new paradigm on the desktop (and to unify their product offerings), they didn't stop to think if they SHOULD. It probably would have gone better, and been more productive, had the Metro/Modern options been OPTIONAL in the first release. But nope! Microsoft figured they could dictate from on-high and everyone would move along in lock-step.

Not to put too fine a point on it. But "Ha! Ha ha ha!"

Corporate buyers looked at it as an unnecessary expense (retraining), that Microsoft was foisting off to them.

End users, familiar with the Windows UI paradigm for the last 20 years, looked at it and went "NOPE! NOPE! NOPE! NOPE!"

Other "hidden costs" of the new UI, and problems in dealing with it became more evident later as well.
 
It's not a bad OS at all. It's a step up from Windows 7. The biggest complaint is the UI. A lot of people refuse to upgrade because of it. Not that they CAN'T use it, but they don't like it and don't WANT to use it.

Then stay with the old OS and lose support :D MS can't do the same thing over and over again! They need to evolve. But once people start hating on it, the hate spreads even to people that have never even tried the OS. I have Win 8 on all my devices. I like it most on my Surface Pro. I sure wish the video streaming to my Xbox One wouldn't drop every 15 minutes though... otherwise it's a fine OS.
 
I think they need to get Windows 9 out fast, as Windows 8 is pretty much universally disliked across a lot of different demographics. A few people love it, but generally it is not well liked. They need to move past that name, that look, everything.

I agree with you in that yes, Microsoft needs to get past Windows 8 but there's no need to dump the idea of a hybrid OS. The basic idea of Windows 8 is very flexible and powerful, but 8 didn't have enough options to allow it to be configured well enough on the particular devices it runs on.

Windows 9 x86 needs to be like both Windows 7 and 8. Being just a keyboard and mouse driven only OS is no longer enough, 8 already moved past being a desktop only OS. Of course it's well understood that Microsoft didn't do it well and 8's UI simply was too different and too confusing to too many traditional Windows desktop users. But Windows has now picked up a number of non traditional Windows users with tablets and particularly hybrid devices. And while that is a small number compared to mouse driven desktop users, that number has grown quite a bit. Windows hybrids, particularly the cheaper ones, seem to be doing pretty well in the market.
 
I agree with you in that yes, Microsoft needs to get past Windows 8 but there's no need to dump the idea of a hybrid OS. The basic idea of Windows 8 is very flexible and powerful, but 8 didn't have enough options to allow it to be configured well enough on the particular devices it runs on.

Windows 9 x86 needs to be like both Windows 7 and 8. Being just a keyboard and mouse driven only OS is no longer enough, 8 already moved past being a desktop only OS. Of course it's well understood that Microsoft didn't do it well and 8's UI simply was too different and too confusing to too many traditional Windows desktop users. But Windows has now picked up a number of non traditional Windows users with tablets and particularly hybrid devices. And while that is a small number compared to mouse driven desktop users, that number has grown quite a bit. Windows hybrids, particularly the cheaper ones, seem to be doing pretty well in the market.

8 Pro is pretty awesome on my Surface!
 
Then stay with the old OS and lose support :D MS can't do the same thing over and over again! They need to evolve. But once people start hating on it, the hate spreads even to people that have never even tried the OS. I have Win 8 on all my devices. I like it most on my Surface Pro. I sure wish the video streaming to my Xbox One wouldn't drop every 15 minutes though... otherwise it's a fine OS.

I have Windows 8 on most of my devices (Server 2012 R2 on the other, along with Linux dev servers). A lot of people aren't worried about official support. Enterprises are, and they get extended support anyway.

Also - I have no issues with streaming to the Xbox One. I do use wired vs. wireless, though. Are you using a Surface 3? There is a known issue with the wireless on that thing (slow, dropping connections) for some users.

With that streaming to the Xbox One thing - that's one feature of Windows 8 that is overlooked a lot. Just the Send To part of things. I can swipe and it's on the TV. Videos, presentations, desktop, whatever. That's awesome for meetings and things like that.

Windows 8 has a lot of excellent features, but people have a hard time getting past the UI. I don't mind it. But, look at all the people that do. I can't say I have a problem, but I'm not going to ignore everyone else. Same with Vista - I had zero problems. None, nada, zilch. Tons of other people did. I can't ignore the problems people have with Windows 8, either. I don't have them, but if lots of others do - then there is a problem.
 
I agree with you in that yes, Microsoft needs to get past Windows 8 but there's no need to dump the idea of a hybrid OS. The basic idea of Windows 8 is very flexible and powerful, but 8 didn't have enough options to allow it to be configured well enough on the particular devices it runs on.

That's been said from day 1, too. Just didn't have that one single option to give it back a classic mode. Via GPO, reg hack, Control Panel, anything - it would have made a HUGE difference. People just wanted the ability to bypass Start Screen. That's it. They finally are getting that with Windows 9 (supposedly...).
 
That has got to be one of the worst articles ever. It seems pretty obvious the author knows little to nothing about Windows since all of his points are pretty much invalid.

1) Updates. While it is not the best system, it is still one of the better update systems out there. And oh, by the way, you can install updates separately, I have been able to do that for at least a decade.

2) Restore from the cloud. Not a good plan at all, what happens when you lose connection during the restore? Also, its possible to already depending on how you have your systems setup. Considering everything that exists out there now, to require that as part of the base system seems a bit flukey.

3) Separate of OS and data. Umm, been doing that for over a decade? Plus his reasons for "separating" the applications from the OS are bs. You don't need to separate them to do what he is suggesting.

4) Pure Desktop Experience mode. Last time I checked it was pretty easy to get to desktop mode even in Windows 8.

5) Transparent backup. Yet another thing that has been a function of windows for a long time.
 
Here's a better list:

1. Don't be Windows 8.
2. Don't be Windows Vista.
3. Don't be Windows ME.
4. Be like Windows 7.
5. Be like Windows XP..
I'm sorry Windows XP was pretty shitty for 2 or so years upon release. Windows 7 is the only OS to have a smooth release partly because it was just a Vista service pack
 
I have Windows 8 on most of my devices (Server 2012 R2 on the other, along with Linux dev servers). A lot of people aren't worried about official support. Enterprises are, and they get extended support anyway.

Also - I have no issues with streaming to the Xbox One. I do use wired vs. wireless, though. Are you using a Surface 3? There is a known issue with the wireless on that thing (slow, dropping connections) for some users.

With that streaming to the Xbox One thing - that's one feature of Windows 8 that is overlooked a lot. Just the Send To part of things. I can swipe and it's on the TV. Videos, presentations, desktop, whatever. That's awesome for meetings and things like that.

Windows 8 has a lot of excellent features, but people have a hard time getting past the UI. I don't mind it. But, look at all the people that do. I can't say I have a problem, but I'm not going to ignore everyone else. Same with Vista - I had zero problems. None, nada, zilch. Tons of other people did. I can't ignore the problems people have with Windows 8, either. I don't have them, but if lots of others do - then there is a problem.

I had issues with Vista off the bat, but I got it at release. After a few patches they had it running all nice with no issues, but it got a 'bad rap' and no one wanted to use it. Just like Windows 8, but there were no HUGE issues with win 8, just that it was different. People just can't change :S.

As for the surface, it's the Surface Pro 1. The console is wired, but the surface is obviously wireless. The network is stable but what seems to happen is the connection drops and the video goes back to the surface. I have to go the Charms bar and share with "Xbox One" again. It takes a second for "Xbox One" and the other share to contents to reappear.
 
The UI was Windows 8's sole major downfall. Just about everything else in the OS is great, showing that lots of thought was put into the new/additional functionality.

My wife and I despise it.

I purchased her a new laptop a year or two ago and even with me stripping a bunch of stuff down its a nightmare to use. I went as far as to resurrect an older HP laptop we have (new keyboard, replace defective drive and some other issues) because it had Win7 from the factory and I'll be damned if I buy another laptop with Win8 on it.

Everything is more difficult to accomplish (if you get it done at all), the OS is constantly assuming you want to do one thing when you really want to do another. IE what ever version that comes with it is such a steaming crashprone pile of poop I took mercy on her and installed PaleMoon and the browser has not crashed once.

Stuff I can do in two clicks with Win2000Pro or XP now takes a half dozen or more *IF* you can figure out where it is you wish to go in the first place.

Microsoft nailed it with Win2kpro-WinXP and to some degree Win7.

Win8? Utter rubbish. Right up there is Vista as fail on an epic scale.
 
My wife and I despise it.

I purchased her a new laptop a year or two ago and even with me stripping a bunch of stuff down its a nightmare to use. I went as far as to resurrect an older HP laptop we have (new keyboard, replace defective drive and some other issues) because it had Win7 from the factory and I'll be damned if I buy another laptop with Win8 on it.

Everything is more difficult to accomplish (if you get it done at all), the OS is constantly assuming you want to do one thing when you really want to do another. IE what ever version that comes with it is such a steaming crashprone pile of poop I took mercy on her and installed PaleMoon and the browser has not crashed once.

Stuff I can do in two clicks with Win2000Pro or XP now takes a half dozen or more *IF* you can figure out where it is you wish to go in the first place.

Microsoft nailed it with Win2kpro-WinXP and to some degree Win7.

Win8? Utter rubbish. Right up there is Vista as fail on an epic scale.

OK, specifically, what is it that was "a nightmare to use"?

As far as I have used it, on desktops and tablets, it worked the exact same in most respects, and a few minor extra steps in getting to certain things. On a laptop, yeah, it was a nightmare because of the touchpad gestures. I never could stand touchpads, though. I always used a separate wireless mouse with my laptops, which bypassed the touchpad anyway.

You comment on "the OS is constantly assuming you want to do one thing when you really want to do another" but I've never seen this. What are you referring to, specifically?
 
So, explain to me how a downloaded image is going to works on 10 of thousands of different configurations?

Explain to me how a DVD in a box is going to work on 10 of thousands of different configurations?

They weren't even referring to the article, but seriously? Why would a downloaded image NOT work with similarly effectiveness as a disk based install, which has been around forever?
 
I think some of the points are dead on. The Windows Update system is horrible. Unless you have the tools and the technical know how to integrate updates into your build, a fresh install of Windows 7 (SP1) needs 120+ individual updates and ~4 reboots to be current? WTH! There's no reason why Microsoft can't release roll-ups like they do with the rest of their products. Not to mention, updates will commonly fail to install because they are installed out of order or requires a prerequisites and reboot first.

I had to update a laptop a few weeks ago. I think it was about 75-80 updates to get a fresh Sept. 2013 8.0 install updated to be able to install 8.1. Can I just install a fresh copy of 8.1 on that Toshiba laptop? Nope, apparently not. Just over 3 hours to update, some of that due to a failed update pre 8.1 install and due to windows update just sitting there for 15 minutes before I checked on it at the start. I guess it couldn't figure out which update to download and install first. Add another 80 minutes or so if you count my backing up the 8.0 install using the factory utility to a usb drive and making a clone image on top of that.
 
You comment on "the OS is constantly assuming you want to do one thing when you really want to do another" but I've never seen this. What are you referring to, specifically?

PC Settings vs. Control Panel is one big one. There are others, too. Common complaint, and it helped to bring the initial "double personality" claims from many reviewers of Windows 8.
 
I had to update a laptop a few weeks ago. I think it was about 75-80 updates to get a fresh Sept. 2013 8.0 install updated to be able to install 8.1. Can I just install a fresh copy of 8.1 on that Toshiba laptop? Nope, apparently not. Just over 3 hours to update, some of that due to a failed update pre 8.1 install and due to windows update just sitting there for 15 minutes before I checked on it at the start. I guess it couldn't figure out which update to download and install first. Add another 80 minutes or so if you count my backing up the 8.0 install using the factory utility to a usb drive and making a clone image on top of that.

Yeah Windows 8 updates can be quite finicky and frustrating at times...way more than any previous Windows OS.
 
I think some of the points are dead on. The Windows Update system is horrible. Unless you have the tools and the technical know how to integrate updates into your build, a fresh install of Windows 7 (SP1) needs 120+ individual updates and ~4 reboots to be current? WTH! There's no reason why Microsoft can't release roll-ups like they do with the rest of their products. Not to mention, updates will commonly fail to install because they are installed out of order or requires a prerequisites and reboot first.

While, yes, it needs more rollup updates in the system, it is certainly not horrible. Try updating CentOS 6 on a fresh install. 1238 updates as of today. How about Ubuntu 14.04? 937 updates. The brand spanking new Oracle Linux 7 still has over 300 updates. It actually had more updates on release day than Windows 7 has right now.

Now, IBM's AIX 7.1 is the most horrible OS I get to deal with in the updates department. I just did a fresh install, and the updates, when I finally got them all downloaded using a separate machine totaled over 4000. IBM's site for the downloads was absolutely horrible, with either downloading each file separately by FTP or HTTPS or using their Java based download to download them in bundles, only to have every single bundle give me a "connection refused" error after downloading about two thirds of them. It took them three days to fix their site to the point where I could download them.

Of course, Unix and Linux both have two big advantages with their updates: they all come at once instead of the tiered updates Microsoft does and most don't require reboots. (CentOS and Red Hat 6 both have one update to the LVM system that requires a reboot.)

Believe me, Windows is great when it comes to the update system. It is leaps and bounds ahead of anyone else, except perhaps Mac, but Apple doesn't even bother to patch many of their security problems. Does not having an update to a known problem count as a good thing? I don't think so.
 
Back
Top