4870x2 vs.Two 4870's in Crossfire

SilentDoh!

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 12, 2007
Messages
70
I am building my next gaming machine and I am trying to figure out what I should do for the video cards. i was thinking about a 4870 x2 but then I started to wonder what are the pros and cons of using two 4870s in crossfire.

I like playing the Battlefield series, GTA series, and a lot of the other games that are out there.

I have two of these monitors Acer X233H bid
http://us.acer.com/acer/product.do?...angedAlts=&kcond5e.c2att92=453&CRC=2302474279

So one of the questions that I have is when running two monitors using HDMI is it better to have one video card or two?

Which consumes more power two 4870 or one 4870 x2 under peak load?

which creates more heat two 4870 or one 4870 x2 under peak load?

Those questions maybe self explanatory but two cards can share the load and cool better than one one card with two boards sandwich together.

What do you think?
 
the 4870x2 isnt two boards sandwiched together like the nvidia cards. its two gpus on one pcb.
 
Thank you for the correction. So I change my question to
Those questions maybe self explanatory but two cards can share the load and cool better than one one card that has two GPU's on it.
 
generally from what I am seeing is 4870CF have a very little performance better than 4870X2, the higher fps it shows, the better fps 4870CF than 4870X2..

its kind of weird, I don't know the reason behind it...

but the impact is so little that its impossible to notice ...

but CF will definitely have better OC ability since its 2 board that does not generate the heat on same board...
 
This just keeps raising more questions is it easier to OC the one 4870x2 or two 4870's?
 
So nobody has seen any comparisons on this before I have been trying to find some for a while now.
 
I am an nvidia user I have an 8800gtx but my friend has been working hard to convince me into trying out ATI, so I have looked a lot into it.

Most benchmarks will show that in some games 4870 in crossfire should yield 1-2 fps better, also better temps, some games are a little glitched with the x2's and in the low end of fps they may dip a little lower even if they can reach higher fps.

The 4870x2 consumes less power than 2 4870 in crossfire, this might be the difference for some ppl in being able to run it or having to upgrade their psu. It's the most powerful ati single board solution atm,

I myself thought about two 4870's on crossfire but I am hesitant because it might push my energy consumption too high, the 4870x2 might be a better alternative for me, something different might be better for you. Honestly the price might even get cheaper on 4870 when the 4890 comes out, there might even be a 4890x2 sometime in the near future.
If your content with your performance at the moment it might be wiser to wait for dx11 then you can get the next gen ati or buy older gen cheaper. Hope this helps.
 
Some other things to consider aside from performance:

4870X2 is longer than the reference 4870. Certain cases may not be able to accommodate their length.
I originally was going to use a Sapphire 4850X2 and when I got it, it wouldn't fit into my case so I went to a 4870. The 4850X2 was just too long.

Also, there's air circulation in your case that may be a concern.
I originally had my 4870 in the middle PCIE slot, thinking that it would stay cooler being further away from my CPU/RAM. It ended up being slightly lower than my 120mm fan on the side of my case so was hitting temps over 90C.
Moving it up to the first slot dropped temps to around 65C under load.

Going to 4870CF will be an air circulation and overheating concern for me, that would be avoidable if I only had to deal with one card (if it could fit in *my* case).
 
IMO if the MB can do Xfire then do it with 2 HD4870s.

If the MB can only run 1 video card then run HD4870x2.
 
I say get a single 4870x2 instead of getting a pair of 4870's and crossfiring them. Crossing a pair of 4870's uses more power than a single 4870x2 and you get pretty much the same performance anyway.

+1 4870x2 here.
 
Better yet. Get 2 HD4890s in Crossfire if you can swing the cash.
 
Everyone has their own opinion but has any one actually seen side by side comparisons of one versus the other?
 
Back
Top