4870 Aftermarket Cooling solutions

SubtleOne

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
291
Hi,

I've been looking into an aftermarket cooling solution for my 4870 (reference design). The temps are fine after modding the BIOS, and get 58C in idle and 75-77C at full load. This is with fan speeds ranging from 30 at idle to a full blown 48 if it hits 75C, which is pretty audible.

Set this way, my OC limits are either 815/1000 or 800/1100, take your pick. No actual performance difference between the two as I've amply tested. At least with the 4870(512), +25MHz core will yield roughly 200 points in Vantage GPU, and +100MHz memory a bit over 100pts also. To go beyond that, say to 825/1050, stable (my first criteria is completing 3DMark06 - Vantage is too forgiving), I need to really jack up the fan speed to a very obnoxious 60-65%.

Right now, my number one choices are the Accelero S1 rev.2. with a selection of fans, or the Scythe Musashi. Naturally, I'll be taking into account and attending to the VRM issues explained by Arctic at their site, as well as covered by PCGH's review of the coolers.

Arctic suggests sticking heatsinks on the VRM or buying separately their Voltage Regulator Heat Spreader Module. PCGH is a little more practical, and suggests removing the VRM plate from the stock cooler, and using it instead, in conjunction with either of the cooling solutions.

Either way, the Accelero with fan(s) would go for roughly $40-45 as would the Musashi. The Thermalright T-rad is way too expensive ($55 with no fans). I'm quoting prices from CoolerGuys.

Any thoughts?
 
The Accelero S1 Rev. 2 doesn't include ramsinks capable of properly cooling the vregs from my experience. I watched the VDDR temps in GPUz go to 130*C running furmark after just a few minutes overclocked 800/1100. It is slightly more acceptable with the original ATI spreader plate installed under the Accelero. Up to around 120*C.

However, the Accelero doesn't sit flush over the spreader plate. The angled portion of the plate (near the fan exhaust side) pushes that side of an S1 rev 2 or Twin Turbo slightly away from the board. I idle at 45*C OC to 800/1100, so the cooler has enough flex to push upwards without compromising the mating of the cooler and core. You can of course simply cut the plate with proper tools, but I don't have them.

Overall, I am happy with my results with S1 rev.2 (120mm fan) and Twin Turbo. I have no experience with the other heatsink.

Sorry, my food is getting cold. :/
 
Beware of the radiant heat in your case if you go aftermarket air cooling. Most of them do no longer blow heat out of your case, so even if they do cool your card better, maybe they will give you worse results about your incase temp... Go water with this card if you can. That's what I did and I am quite happy with the result.
 
Add an fan blowing through heatsink toward the back of the case and you will yield the best result.
 
Back
Top