4870 512mb vs 1 gig

Snowypup

n00b
Joined
Nov 21, 2007
Messages
40
I've heard if you use a large monitor or play games at resolutions like 1920x1200, 1 gig of video memory starts to pay off. Right now my pc has the 512mb card and it lags a little if I max out the settings in Left 4 Dead, particularly triple buffering.
But I can try to pawn off my video card at some store, maybe even Best Buy. So if money was a small matter would it really be worth it then?
 
There was a review that demonstrated the % differential in different games and resolution... maybe someone can post that. In essence, it seems that 1680 x 1050 is point which brings the 1gb in favor. The cost difference is marginal between the two and IMHO you would be better with the 1gb.
 
well, imo, running out of video ram can be very crippling, so i would go for a gig.
even if it doesnt help now, you'll be glad in the future.
 
I've heard if you use a large monitor or play games at resolutions like 1920x1200, 1 gig of video memory starts to pay off. Right now my pc has the 512mb card and it lags a little if I max out the settings in Left 4 Dead, particularly triple buffering.
But I can try to pawn off my video card at some store, maybe even Best Buy. So if money was a small matter would it really be worth it then?
at 1920 the 1gig would be better in a few games for sure. whether or not its worth the trouble of trying to get rid of your card and get 1gig version is up to you.

btw turning on triple buffering from the video card control panel doesnt do anything in DX games unless you are using something like rivatuner. the standard triple buffering setting in ATI and Nvidia control panels only applies to openGL games.
 
went from a 512 4870 to a gtx260. Big difference, less hitching when AA and V-sync are used. Im convinced its the extra mem.
 
don't know what your budget is but you can get a 4870X2 for 370AR right now, I would sell your 4870 and go there. a 4870 1gb would make a difference to you (would probably get rid of the lag, if by lag you the hitch now and then) but I am not sure how much of an upgrade it would be.
 
The GTX260 Core 216 is said to beat the HD4870 1GB by a 5-10% Difference depending on the game, i'd only go with the HD4870 1GB if it was cheaper then the GTX260 Core 216, if there the same price, the GTX260 Core 216 is the way to go
 
The GTX260 Core 216 is said to beat the HD4870 1GB by a 5-10% Difference depending on the game, i'd only go with the HD4870 1GB if it was cheaper then the GTX260 Core 216, if there the same price, the GTX260 Core 216 is the way to go
That's kinda my thinking.
 
The GTX260 Core 216 is said to beat the HD4870 1GB by a 5-10% Difference depending on the game, i'd only go with the HD4870 1GB if it was cheaper then the GTX260 Core 216, if there the same price, the GTX260 Core 216 is the way to go

thats kind of a it depends. they really trade blows, and if you like AA it actually goes the other way. . at that price difference I would go with the 4870 1gb over all. but its close enough to look at the games you play and see what platform they do better on.
 
thats kind of a it depends. they really trade blows, and if you like AA it actually goes the other way. . at that price difference I would go with the 4870 1gb over all. but its close enough to look at the games you play and see what platform they do better on.
You saying the 4870 is going to handle AA better? When the 9.1 results are in, I may jump on the ATI boat and sell off my 8800GTS 512 SLI. My low resolution (1440x900) gaming would probably benefit more from 1 faster card. I prefer having a better minimal FPS than a max. I'll break even if I sell those on eBay. I just hope Nvidia has coded their own chipset (750i) to not play games with ATI gpu's :p I also have always liked ATI giving the newest drivers with the option to get just the driver without control panel.
 
You saying the 4870 is going to handle AA better? When the 9.1 results are in, I may jump on the ATI boat and sell off my 8800GTS 512 SLI. My low resolution (1440x900) gaming would probably benefit more from 1 faster card. I prefer having a better minimal FPS than a max. I'll break even if I sell those on eBay. I just hope Nvidia has coded their own chipset (750i) to not play games with ATI gpu's :p I also have always liked ATI giving the newest drivers with the option to get just the driver without control panel.

what do you need to upgrade for? save the money and get a better monitor. 8800GTS 512 sli will push that screen just fine. you don't need 1gb of video memory anyways, a 512mb card should be fine. if you really need to upgrade then a 4850 would be fine unless your looking to max some of the newer games.
 
what do you need to upgrade for? save the money and get a better monitor. 8800GTS 512 sli will push that screen just fine. you don't need 1gb of video memory anyways, a 512mb card should be fine. if you really need to upgrade then a 4850 would be fine unless your looking to max some of the newer games.
I'm not looking to 'upgrade'. I wish for no out of pocket expense. I'm interested in switching to a single card solution that will offer similar performance to what I have now, with the same monitor. Money is not an issue, I simply do not want a larger monitor (than 19").
 
I'm not looking to 'upgrade'. I wish for no out of pocket expense. I'm interested in switching to a single card solution that will offer similar performance to what I have now, with the same monitor. Money is not an issue, I simply do not want a larger monitor (than 19").

flea bay your cards and get a 4850, that should do it. sorry, I forget that not everyone likes the big screens, I can't see going with less then my 28" now that I have it.
 
Ugh.... i can't decide what to go for :eek::eek::eek: I just got myself a new 24in monitor and my current video card can't handle 1920 by 1200 in the games i play. I only play 2 games, but these two games i play a lot. I play WoW and BF2 but i can't decide whether to go for a 4830, 4850, or a 4870??? :confused: My budget is between $150 to $200 shipped. My current system specs are as follows:



c2d e4400 running at 3.15ghz on a 956p-ds3 mobo
2gb ddr2 ram running at 840mhz
x800xl vid card
mushkin enhanced 550w psu
36gb Raptor
(2) 200GB HDDs
dvd-rw/cd-rw drive
5 case fans

Will my cpu bottleneck a 4870? Would my psu be able to handle a 4870? I don't want to buy a 4870 and then have to send it back because my psu couldn't handle it :eek: What about a gtx260? I just want to be able to play my two games at a high res with all the eye-candy turned on :( So what do you guys recommend?
 
The max I pull on my 550W PSU so far with a 4850 OC'd is ~250w, this is on my old rig which is a 110w Opteron dual core that is OC'd
 
.....Will my cpu bottleneck a 4870? ......

.....Would my psu be able to handle a 4870? .....

......What about a gtx260?.......

At 1900x1200 a 1 GB 4870 is the sweet-spot, it draws about the same power as a GTX280, which requires a 550w PSU with 40a. on the 12v rails suggested. You should be fine. I have had a 4870x2 running without a problem on my PCPnC 610w without a glitch..

GTX260 core 216 is a great deal and actually beats up on the HD4870 in many games, there was a good review on guru3d recently in that regard.

I do not play WoW; I understand that it is more CPU intensive than GPU, you may not see any frame rate improvement (between a 4850 and a 4870) by just changing your video card... you might think about looking for a deal on a e8400 (e0 stepping).

If I were in your shoes I would probably go with a HD4850 and a CPU upgrade
 
Back
Top