4850 crossfire or GTX260 216?

cold_steel

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Jun 27, 2004
Messages
581
What is the better value? Both look to be around the $300 mark. I game on a CRT that I switch between 1600x1200 and 1920x1200 letterboxed depending on performance. My PC is a DFI x48 mobo, 4GB ram, e8400 @ 4GHz, vista 64.
 
4850 CF actually beats the GTX280 in performance, much less the GTX260. But...
I've seen a review that show just the opposite; show me one where the 4850 XFire outdoes a GTX 280, please. Here is the one that shows the GTX 280 basically beating the 4850 Crossfire in many cases: http://www.tweaktown.com/articles/1470/5/radeon_hd_4850_in_crossfire_at_4ghz/index.html

The GTX 280 beat the 4850 in most of the tests, except for benchmarks, which don't actually matter apparently, if they don't reflect real-world performance.
 
I've seen a review that show just the opposite; show me one where the 4850 XFire outdoes a GTX 280, please. Here is the one that shows the GTX 280 basically beating the 4850 Crossfire in many cases: http://www.tweaktown.com/articles/1470/5/radeon_hd_4850_in_crossfire_at_4ghz/index.html

The GTX 280 beat the 4850 in most of the tests, except for benchmarks, which don't actually matter apparently, if they don't reflect real-world performance.

Open your freakin eyes and look at the date of that article"

19th June 2008

got to love the nv fan boys in denial:eek:
 
Well, for one thing, I know the Nvidia drivers have improved quite a bit since then. What makes you think the results would favor ATI? I'm not an Nvidia boy, anyway. Gosh, I liked when the Internet didn't have so many morons. HardOCP used to be sort of an cool place to come, a few years back, I thought. For what reason would I choose to be biased when it comes to video card companies....

Time for me to find another community, I suppose.
 
I've seen a review that show just the opposite; show me one where the 4850 XFire outdoes a GTX 280, please.

Age of Conan at 1920x1200 with 8X AA – 16X AF and the highest in-game settings

Call of Duty 4 at 2560x1600 with 4X AA – 16X AF with the highest level of Transparency Antialiasing supported on both platforms

However, on the page following these two, for the GRID test, the 4850 CF didn't even register a score because they had issues.

Just because 4850 CF can outperform a GTX 280 doesn't mean it's the right way to go.
 
Not everything is measured in terms of performance and not everything is measured in terms of raw power. In the end, these comparisons are all relative. In one game, the GTX 280 can give you 5 more frames and in another it can give you less. I just don't see these comparisons as having much weight because once you get the product, two weeks later ATI and nVidia will come out with something newer and better. Additionally, can you really notice the 2% increase in performance and does it really affect gameplay significantly?
 
Yes, there is little question that 2 4850s in crossfire will outperform a GTX260(216) overall.
 
Back
Top