3G iPhones Prone To Cracking?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The MacRumors forums are packed full of people with 3G iPhones with cracks in them. iPhone owners are speculating that the damage could be caused by everything from heat issues to faulty case castings. It reminds me of all the cracked Nintendo DS hinges a while back.
 
Sounds more like to me that people are dropping them.
 
They look like stress cracks to me not drop damage. I would say its heat related the plastic expanding and contracting causes cracks that look just like those.
 
They look like stress cracks to me not drop damage. I would say its heat related the plastic expanding and contracting causes cracks that look just like those.

You get stress cracks if you dropped it on the opposite end or at another area. You also get stress cracks when you toss it in your pocket and go about your daily activities.

Usually devices like this are tested for temp extremes, thats a common thing to do... thats why they would post temperature operating conditions under the specs. I'd be curious on who dropped the ball if they didn't do the testing.
 
Curiously, I had very similar cracks happening around the screws on my old 1st gen Macbook which I believe uses the same casing material as the new iPhone 3g. And these stress cracks were definatly not cause by dropping or putting in my pocket. I'm wonder if it is a material/casting defect on certain manufacturing runs.
 
WTF man, stop it with all this bad news. It's killing AAPL's stock price. Just let it go back to 180 where I foolishly bought it at, so I can dump the crap. Then let the bad news roll out...

/slight sarcasm
 
Don't know why they switched to cheap plastic backing anyway, I know it's supposed to be cheaper but that seems more like they cut a corner after seeing those photos, well done Apple, you have made an entire product of iFail.
 
This should come as no surprise to apple. Remember when they made the clear mac cubes? Those had major issues with the lucite cracking.
 
Don't know why they switched to cheap plastic backing anyway, I know it's supposed to be cheaper but that seems more like they cut a corner after seeing those photos, well done Apple, you have made an entire product of iFail.

i think i heard it was to improve signal strength/quality of reception.
 
Ya, plastic was used supposedly in order to allow them to use the guh-jillion antennas inside the iPhone. The aluminum backing messed up either the 3G, GSM, WiFi, or Bluetooth recievers. We'll see if crappy plastic is widespread or just some guy sitting on his iphone and blaming the manufacturer.
 
Personally I just think this is so more obese people can claim lawsuit prize money.

God bless America.
 
I knew Apple users were on crack, but this is ridiculous.
 
looks like stress cracks to me too.

nintendo replaced 3 DS lites for me because of a similar issue (hinge stress cracks). my latest one now has the same affliction, i gave up.

i wonder how many replacements apple customers will be allowed.
 
...I wonder how many replacements apple customers will be allowed.

None. Steve Jobs will personally kill anyone who claims it was an Apple defect or they'll ignore it for as long as possible like their monitor fubar.
 
I find myself in need of both a new phone and a new mp3 player, so I've been watching the iPhone news with interest.

If only AT&T would pick up the Nokia N96 so it wouldn't cost $800. Better camera, expansion slot... Extra $500...

I'm going to give the iPhone 3g a couple more months to see how it matures and how it's supported by Apple and AT&T. I'm thinking a black 16gb version - cracks won't be as visible, just fingerprints.
 
I find myself in need of both a new phone and a new mp3 player, so I've been watching the iPhone news with interest.

If only AT&T would pick up the Nokia N96 so it wouldn't cost $800. Better camera, expansion slot... Extra $500...

I'm going to give the iPhone 3g a couple more months to see how it matures and how it's supported by Apple and AT&T. I'm thinking a black 16gb version - cracks won't be as visible, just fingerprints.

i wouldnt hold your breath on that. the N95 is still going through certification with at&t and rumors seem to point to a holliday release of the N95.

i love my n95 but personally i am really looking foward to the e71, just need to wait a few months to justify getting rid of my n95 for the e71.
 
That's interesting. I have a white iPhone as well, since launch, and I have absolutely no signs of wear on the back. I haven't exactly been babying it, either...
 
looks like stress cracks to me too.

nintendo replaced 3 DS lites for me because of a similar issue (hinge stress cracks). my latest one now has the same affliction, i gave up.

i wonder how many replacements apple customers will be allowed.

Are the DS hinge fixes free of charge? I would totally send mine in if its free.
 
I was tempted for a while to sell my 1st gen iPhone but after hearing great news like this I think I'll sit on mine for a while longer (no pun intended ;))
 
i live on an island in the caribbean..there is no at&t here.. how the hell can i buy an iphone 3g and use the local carrier here?
 
i wouldnt hold your breath on that. the N95 is still going through certification with at&t and rumors seem to point to a holliday release of the N95.

i love my n95 but personally i am really looking foward to the e71, just need to wait a few months to justify getting rid of my n95 for the e71.

Not really an expectation, just a wish or a hope...

I figure by the time AT&T has it, I'll want something else. :D
 
a coworkers was working for a few hours then said no sim card. reset all the settings.. take it out, breathe on it and then use the ipod cleaning cloth to whipe it clean

if that doesnt work try a qtip gently... if that doesnt work try some alcohol and qtip
 
Not really an expectation, just a wish or a hope...

I figure by the time AT&T has it, I'll want something else. :D

In all honesty when the n96 was announced i didnt see anything really above and beyond the n95, its a slightly different styling of the case, but spec wise is quite close to the n95. One thing i think it added was mobile television services, however it is not compatable with the service that the us uses. So if you are looking forward to the n96 i would look into the n95 when it launches and pick that up. Just remember to flash it with the nokia firmware, at&t has been know to slaughter their previous s60 handsets by time they are done with the "customizations"
 
In all honesty when the n96 was announced i didnt see anything really above and beyond the n95, its a slightly different styling of the case, but spec wise is quite close to the n95. One thing i think it added was mobile television services, however it is not compatable with the service that the us uses. So if you are looking forward to the n96 i would look into the n95 when it launches and pick that up. Just remember to flash it with the nokia firmware, at&t has been know to slaughter their previous s60 handsets by time they are done with the "customizations"

Which N95 are they going with? I thought the biggest was the 8gb model. I'd like to be able to carry a bit more of my collection. The N96 is really just a slightly refreshed N95. I think of it as a 16gb N95.

With my current phone, I was able to get it from Nokia, at the AT&T price. No customizations... Don't know if I'll be able to do the same with my next one.
 
Not to thread-crap, but I routinely keep my cell phone and sunglasses in my pocket, and nothing bigger than a flip phone survives long with a seatbelt across it - especially the way I drive. If the phone were just a bit smaller, I'd have bought the last gen and a 3G already. Instead, I go with $7 sunglasses and $25 unlocked quadband phones from eBay. That way I'm not crying when they break.
 
Which N95 are they going with? I thought the biggest was the 8gb model. I'd like to be able to carry a bit more of my collection. The N96 is really just a slightly refreshed N95. I think of it as a 16gb N95.

With my current phone, I was able to get it from Nokia, at the AT&T price. No customizations... Don't know if I'll be able to do the same with my next one.

I dont know which variant they are going with, I hope the n95-3 not the 8GB model. the 8GB has one issue which bugs alot of people, the usb controler between the phone and the 8GB of memory is a USB 1 controler which means transfers are quite slow. Also it doesnt have removable memory. Where as the -3 can take microSD cards up to 32GB (when they are released)
 
Not to thread-crap, but I routinely keep my cell phone and sunglasses in my pocket, and nothing bigger than a flip phone survives long with a seatbelt across it - especially the way I drive. If the phone were just a bit smaller, I'd have bought the last gen and a 3G already. Instead, I go with $7 sunglasses and $25 unlocked quadband phones from eBay. That way I'm not crying when they break.

On my first 2 year cellphone contract, I went through 3 phones. Luckly I bought the insurance. On my second cell phone contract I only had one. From what I can tell, cell phones are far less fragile these days then they were. Or perhaps I've grown up.:eek:
 
I find myself in need of both a new phone and a new mp3 player, so I've been watching the iPhone news with interest.

If only AT&T would pick up the Nokia N96 so it wouldn't cost $800. Better camera, expansion slot... Extra $500...

I'm going to give the iPhone 3g a couple more months to see how it matures and how it's supported by Apple and AT&T. I'm thinking a black 16gb version - cracks won't be as visible, just fingerprints.

N95 8gb version would work better as it is slgihtly smaller and wayyyyyyyyyyy longer battery life :)
 
N95 8gb version would work better as it is slgihtly smaller and wayyyyyyyyyyy longer battery life :)

This is not correct, The n95-4 (8GB) and the n95-3 (160MB with microSD slot) are the exact same size, with the 8GB being 8g heavier (128g vs 120g). They also use the same battery, and although the 8GB had a slight advantage as it shipped with the firmware that has several perfomance increases, the same update has been released for the -3.

Back to the topic at hand though, i dont buy the idea of why they switched to plastic was because of RF perfomance, it was purely a business decision to drive costs down, there are plenty of other metal phones that have excelent RF performance.
 
Back
Top