• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

3.4EE vs. E4300???

myktek

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 16, 2004
Messages
244
i have an old p4 socket 478 system and i'm debating on spending the $120 to get the the 3.4EE or just go to fry's and pick up a C2D E4300.for 170...i prob will mostly use this as a htpc.
 
Id go for the C2D. not only is it probs the same speed if not faster it also runs on less power and will OC better....
 
Wait a min... Are you going to keep the 478 motherboard ? If yes, you must forget about C2D and go for the 3.4EE.

However, for a new system with a new motherboard and such, get the C2D E4300 for sure.
 
i have an old p4 socket 478 system and i'm debating on spending the $120 to get the the 3.4EE or just go to fry's and pick up a C2D E4300.for 170...i prob will mostly use this as a htpc.

Fry's currently has a E4300+ECS cheap-ass VIA chipset mobo for $149 (+tax), but you'll also need new DDR2 RAM and PCI-E video card. So youre looking at min $300. And that mobo wont OC worth a damn, and the cheapest mobo they have that will is the Gibabyte DS3 for ~$140. $450 would be more like it then. :eek:
 
let me elaborate more, one I drop in a 3.4EE and use the system or I get the C2D + asrock 775dual-vsta motherboard.
 
I have a ECS P4M800proM from a Fry's combo that is quite stable and even overclocks a little, and a 775Dual-VSTA too. Both are good for the price, and will still drive a C2D past a any X2 let alone a Pentium. My Asrock only does 285MHz FSB, most do better ~300. Still with a E4300 that's over 2.5GHz and faster than a 6000+. Get the 4coreDual-VSTA it has the better ultra chipset.
 
e4300 = dual core and will beat the snot out of it in just about everything.

don't get me wrong the 3.4EE (galatin) chips rocked for their time. But they just can't compare to the power of Core's.

I've had both 3.4EE & Core 2 (e6600), and they just don't compare.

At least not when you overclock a Core 2 to around 3Ghz which almost all of them do. (maybe worst case 2.8Ghz-3Ghz) Anyway, get the Core 2 and a real PCIe motherboard. (965 based, not Via)
 
or I get the C2D + asrock 775dual-vsta motherboard.

This is what I just ordered to allow me to upgrade in steps.....when I have all the required parts, I'll buy a real motherboard :)
In the meantime I can still use my DDR and AGP card to hold me thru till the wife looks the other way, and then I raid the checkbook......


I have the 3.4EE that I bought last week too....that was a mistake..Ill just throw it in my daughters system..... :)
don't get me wrong, its a killer chip, but not gonna hold up against ANY CD2 chip.....

EDIT:If you decide you want the 3.4EE. Ill sell you mine for $100.00 shipped..and include the receipt to prove its 4 days old..:)
It does 3.7 on my Max 3
 
P4. ECS is a joke. Cheap chipsets FTL. Stay away from VIA and SiS.
The same ECS mobo from Fry's + Celery 331 run my HTPC just fine.
This is what I just ordered to allow me to upgrade in steps.....when I have all the required parts, I'll buy a real motherboard :)
In the meantime I can still use my DDR and AGP card to hold me thru till the wife looks the other way, and then I raid the checkbook......


I have the 3.4EE that I bought last week too....that was a mistake..Ill just throw it in my daughters system..... :)
don't get me wrong, its a killer chip, but not gonna hold up against ANY CD2 chip.....

EDIT:If you decide you want the 3.4EE. Ill sell you mine for $100.00 shipped..and include the receipt to prove its 4 days old..:)
It does 3.7 on my Max 3
I would have loved a 3.4EE+Max3!

But, I went the same route. Celery331+AsRock, then C2D, then BADAXE2! Now I just need to wait for a cheap DX10 card, and I'll be solid for a few years.

-bZj
 
The same ECS mobo from Fry's + Celery 331 run my HTPC just fine.I would have loved a 3.4EE+Max3!

But, I went the same route. Celery331+AsRock, then C2D, then BADAXE2! Now I just need to wait for a cheap DX10 card, and I'll be solid for a few years.

-bZj
How is the Asrock board..?Mine will be here tomorrow....
 
P4. ECS is a joke. Cheap chipsets FTL. Stay away from VIA and SiS.



But when they are selling the package of an E4300 and ECS mobo, for LESS than what any online retailer is selling the E4300 by itself, its a KILLER deal.


I just picked one up and will be selling the unopened MOBO, I figure if I get say $35 shipped, that means I got a brand new E4300 for $115.
 
asrock 775dual-vsta motherboard.

I have that board in my second system, its a decent board but your crippled on PCI-E (4x), there are no cpu voltage adjustments so overclocking only goes so far also. For the price though, its not bad at all, but the C2D doesn't live to its full potential on such a board.
 
Fry's currently has a E4300+ECS cheap-ass VIA chipset mobo for $149 (+tax), but you'll also need new DDR2 RAM and PCI-E video card. So youre looking at min $300. And that mobo wont OC worth a damn, and the cheapest mobo they have that will is the Gibabyte DS3 for ~$140. $450 would be more like it then. :eek:


Please do not get an ECS board. As another member noted, they are a joke and I think they are junk.

I've got an Abit IP-95 with the VIA P4M-890 that is stable and runs well. It is running a Celeron D 336 also. A good basic machine and the motherboard was like $55 at Frys. The PCI-E is also crippled at 4x, but it is not a gaming machine...
 
/don't expect to OC it, and you'll be fine. I ran it with PCIe and DDR2, but the same chipset in my ECS HTPC run w/AGP and DDR perfectly.

-bZj

Cool, Im not expecting it to OC..:)

Its just to hold me over till I get a better board...With the C2D price drops coming next month..now is NOT the time to be buying high end hardware :)
The price will be coming down considerably soon
 
Back
Top