3.2EE or 2.0 Dual Core Cely?

FatBastard

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 4, 2005
Messages
142
Just wanted to bounce a choice off you all..

I have a couple partial systems sitting around and wanted to ask which would be better to finish. I only need a processor for either and have a budget of 50$.

The first is an Abit IC7-Max3 board with 1gb of Geil 2-2-2-5 PC3200 DDR and a BFG 6800GT OC 256mb (AGP) video card.

The other is a crap ECS Socket 775 board with 1gb of Kingston HyperX 5-5-5-15 PC8500DDR2 and a Radeon HD 2600XT 512mb DDR3 (pciE) video card.

As you can tell, the older system was "top of the line" in it's day (save the GT-OC vs an Ultra), and the newer system has middle to low end items.

So, the 64$ question *well 50$*: Should I buy a P4 3.2EE (800fsb, 512k C2, 2M C3) I found for 50$ or an E1400 Dual Core Celeron (2.0ghz, 800fsb, 512k C2, ? C3) off Newegg? Primarily, the system is a backup to my main gaming rig. My only real goal is to have it available to play World of Warcraft if my main system where to take a crap unexpectedly.

Thoughts and opinions? Myself, I am heavily leaning towards the Celeron system simply due to the use of DDR2 memory and the HD 2600XT.
 
Either computer will play WOW very well. I had a computer with only a 6600gt that could come close to maxing it out. You won't have any problems with that. The 2600xt system could be upgraded further in the future if needed while the IC7 system is pretty much at the end of its line. I would go with the 2600xt rig
 
try looking around for a used c2d e4000 series or Pentium Dual Core E2000/E5000. new E5200 is only $70 so any used should be around $50 and significantly better than both current options.
 
Either computer will play WOW very well. I had a computer with only a 6600gt that could come close to maxing it out. You won't have any problems with that. The 2600xt system could be upgraded further in the future if needed while the IC7 system is pretty much at the end of its line. I would go with the 2600xt rig
I second this.

Go for the newer Core Duo celeron. Then OC it and you're gold.
 
Put that IC-7 MAX 3 on eBay...I sold mine for $225.00 a year ago..and they are still paying HUGE money for those boards....
With the money you get for that, you can buy a nice board and an E7200 or the like.
 
I second this.

Go for the newer Core Duo celeron. Then OC it and you're gold.

+1/QFT

The DC Celerons can ring up some insane overclocks (and on motherboards not known for being overclockers). I have the E1200 overclocked a full gig (1.6 GHz stock@2.67 GHz actual) on my ASUS P5N-EM HDMI (a uATX board with an nForce 630i chipset, and not known for being a OC-friendly board) and did it entirely with FSB adjustments (I'm running a 1333 MHz FSB, as opposed to the stock 800 MHz), on stock voltage, with stock cooling (complete with push-pins), and without overclocking anything else.

It's actually a C2D-based Celeron (Conroe, Conroe-L, or possibly Wolfdale) with a cut-down cache (depending on the processor; the E1200 is Conroe-based). Except for the chopped cache, it has all the other features of the bigger processor (and, as you've doubtless heard from other posters, clocks MUCH taller, especially as a percentage of stock) and, unless you run a lot of applications that benefit from larger on-processor caches (in which case you should be looking at the E8xxx C2D or Q9xxx C2Q, if not i7), they make a killer bargain alternative while you save up. (I bought my own E1200 because I wanted to get my build off the ground while saving up for a quad-core.)
 
Back
Top