2TB+ arrays and backup solutions

jarthel

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 24, 2001
Messages
371
now that 2TB+ array are within the means of ordinary home users, I'm wondering what people uses for backup? tape? extra HDDs?

I've recently lost all my files due to a mistake so I vowed that it won't happen again.

Thank you for the reply :)
 
I use Acronis True Image Home to run backups, all the backup files are stored on my fileserver, which runs unRaid - http://lime-technology.com/

unRaid is a lightweight linux based OS that boots off a flash drive (so all the hard drives are used for storage), and it uses a parity drive. The three disk version is free.

It is much more efficient with storge space than WHS duplication or mirroring, easier to setup and run than Raid5 or other traditional raid arrays. You can continue to get at ALL your data even when one hard drive fails. If two fail, you only lose what is on those drives (whereas most traditional Raid solutions you'd lose the entire array with a multiple drive failure). unRaidwill protect drives of different sizes and allows you to mix and match drive types too. The file system is not proprietary, so if need be, you can pull a drive and still read it on another box, even a Windows box (with some software). You can also upgrade a drive to a bigger drive and unRaid will rebuild it and the data will be available long before the rebuild is finished. The only limit is the parity drive must be as big as your biggest data drive.

All my "can't ever lose" files, such as pictures and documents are backed up onto DVD's (4.7 blanks are so crazy cheap these days) and put into a very fire resistant safe every couple of months in addition to being on the fileserver.

You'd have to nuke my entire house for me to lose any more data. Can you tell I've vowed to never lose data again?
 
WHS is easy. Linux can do anything but if your not comfortable or aren't interested don't bother, there is other ways of doing things. The issue with WHS is you're talking about another system. DVDs are cheap but labor intensive. External HDs are cheap and fast. True Image is good for backing up your OS install to your array... backing up your array I'm not sure of any nice programs. But it can be as simple as plugging in one external HDD, copy half the files, plug in the other external drive and copy the remaining half of files. Buying 2TB drives will keep things simple with minimal extra cost... buying 1TB drives will be cheaper but a little harder to manage. You can obviously build another system, install WHS and be fine... just will cost more. Its a whole spectrum of how much money/time you want to devote.
 
Tapes are far too costly for most home users. You pretty much have to get another file server or use a bunch of external drives.
 
i also pair dvds with mozy's home backup for online storage $56/year of unlimited storage

unraid looks cool, ill have to try it sometime...

can unraid be a iscsi target for WHS? could be a really cool setup
 
unRaid is similiar to Raid4 as the both use a single parity drive, but I dont' know enough about Raid4 to say that they are the same.

Even though unRaid is linux based, I wouldn't say anyone should shy away from it as the management is via a browser on a Windows box - so day-to-day management of it is like managing a NAS vs. another PC. I haven't seen the real unRaid OS since last summer - my unRaid box runs headless (no keyboard/monitor) like a NAS in my furnace room.

I've never setup WHS and everyone says its easy. I found unRaid about MUCH easier to setup than ANY Windows install I've done in the last ten years. unRaid really doesn't "install" quite like a regular OS. I literally disconnected my regular boot drive from my desktop, setup unRaid on a flash (10 min), booted up, and viola! It was visible and available on my home network.

Hardware-wise, unRaid is very forgiving, especially when it comes to the CPU - I'm using a single core 35w 420 (1.6?) celeron.

unRaid has a free/3-disk version that is worth a try if you have a spare flash drive laying around.
 
Flexraid is just like Unraid, except it's OS-independant. Run it on whatever OS you like. (So no system dedicated to just it, unlike Unraid...)

Also, it's free, and without some of the other limitations of Unraid.

I was ready to jump on the Unraid bandwagon 'til Flexraid showed up.

Nothing against Unraid, but Flexraid's another alternative to consider IMO...
 
The OS indepence of FlexRaid would make it a better fit for many, especially for someone just wanting to protect their file storage on their regular desktop without the complications of setting up Raid5 for example. I was not looking to protect data on my desktop, as the last time I lost some it was due to a motherboard failure, so I wanted storage that was independent of all my other machines - I didn't want it to be a dual (or more) purpose box. I wanted sepearate, protected storage without committing to high priced hardware (ala Drobo) that I could keep adding to without replacing hard drives that were still working.

I would not describe FlexRaid as "just like unRaid". FlexRaid is newer, and therefore much less mature. It is free... but that also means an increased chance of it just "going away". If the creator/developer of unRaid gets a new job that keeps him busy... so much for updates. edit - remove remark on thread counts as I was wrong - unRaid does appear to have significant more traffic in the forums.

I think FlexRaid is too new for me to trust very much in the way of important data. With unRaid, I ran the free version for a couple months and tried every which way to get it to "mess up" and corrupt or lose my data in some way and I couldn't make it happen. I test the failed and upgrade data drive capabilities, unplugged a data drive while in use, etc.

Even though I am very satisfied with unRaid, I am not of the vain that "my way is best" - FlexRaid, WHS and traditional Raid configurations with parity protections are all valid and each have their strengths. If someone is looking for an inexpensive way to protect their files on their desktop without setting up traditional Raid, than FlexRaid may be best. If they want a centralized media and backup center for their other home Windows machines, WHS may be best.
 
I would not describe FlexRaid as "just like unRaid". FlexRaid is newer, and therefore much less mature. It is free... but that also means an increased chance of it just "going away". If the creator/developer of unRaid gets a new job that keeps him busy... so much for updates.

They do function the same, though.

The plans are for Flexraid to be open source, which while last I knew it still hadn't been released as such (and I admit I will not use or support it until then...), if the open source occurs, that potentially makes it better than other products, where if support goes, you're totally screwed...

But yes, Flexraid did have a problem with lack of support. Until the "open source" of it is released, I won't use it. But I still promote it as an alternative.

FWIW, Flexraid IMO is better than Unraid and WHS in the regard that it keeps metadata on all data. Not only will it survive a drive failure, but it will also detect corruption.

The metadata part is what sold me over Unraid.

The "support" part can be said about anyone, though. Even Microsoft. Actually, I'd never recommend WHS to anyone over some of their issues. Some of the ways I had used 98 and 2000 as a simple file server was broken in XP. SP3 FINALLY fixed this, but almost seven years to fix "delayed write failed"? Absolutely pathetic. And there have unfortunately been issues directly related to WHS. It was fixed, but took months.

I'll take the risk with open source free software anyday over the "we don't have to give a fuck if you've already been the sucker and given us your buck" mentality of Microsoft and others...

The support for Flexraid is there, regardless of whether or not the original author has time. The only issue FR's had so far is the source wasn't (and still isn't?) released. Even he's stated he wants others to take some duties once he has it to a certain point. And others have been more than willing to take it over from him if he just does not have the time for it, which did stagnate FR for a bit there when he wouldn't take the time, but also wouldn't release the source.

Too bad Unraid doesn't have the metadata capability of Flexraid... That adds capability that even expensive hardware RAID cards do not necessarily offer... It's like RAID-Z in one of the Linux flavors...
 
You could look at disk backups such as bluray (not that bad for 2tb).

Or you can look at something like a cheap WHS box.
 
Back
Top