24" vs 26" vs 28" Help Roach decide on new LCD

R0achTheWarHero

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 9, 2007
Messages
488
Here is mein options (has to be purchased from circuity city due to store credit):

Samsung 24" 245bw TN panel
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Sams...85618/catOid/-12965/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do

Viewsonic 28" VX2835wm TN panel
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/View...86483/catOid/-12965/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do

Acer 2616wd 26" wide gamut mystery panel, possibly A-MVA
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Cust...d/168765/rpem/ccd/productDetailReview.do#tabs

It would be easy to choose if I could actually see them in person but I have only seen the 245bw in person and it looks pretty good, basically the same as 226bw S panel (one of the better looking LCD's on the market). If the viewsonic also uses a samsung panel I would purchase that instead but I have no idea what kind of panel is in the viewsonic or what it looks like!!!@#%

I'm not scared of the TN panels at all because the newest samsung TN panels are better than p-mva imo. The only thing I don't know is how the new A-MVA panels look. If the black crush effect has been improved on and the panel isn't blurry it would be a good option.
 
Probably because I've never seen 2 of the 3 panels and can't even find out who the panel manufacturers are for the viewsonic + acer, otherwise the choice would be easy.

To the best of my research of possible panels, the acer is a-mva but thats not a certainty and not fun risking 700$ on to see if A-MVA is actually any improvement on P-MVA.

For people that refuse to buy TN panels I would recommend the A-MVA but personally I know the newest Samsung TN panels look great and might be better all around.
 
Why don't you use this awesome guide from an expert?

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1206033
LOL, I am getting flashbacks of Bizaro.


bizarroyq7.jpg
 
im a roach fan now. I read all his posts. :) not mocking him either!

most everyone else is guarded and dull
 
bestthreadeverig3.gif


I am laughing so hard right now. Oh how I love irony. I will seriously cry if Kyle ever bans this guy.
 
anyone have a definited list of what the ACER 26" is?

i mean... if it is is MVA and actually a-mva, that would mean it would contend with Benq's 24" a-mva series like the VW one right?

wrong?
eh?
coffee, tea, wtf?

something? this is getting confusing. I mean... here are my choices and cost is a factor but getting crap is a worse factor I would like to avoid:

I only want MVA panels or S-ips panels. I decided against PVA for what I will be using it for/want.

1. Benq FP241VW - 24"
2. LG L245WP-BN - 24" - nothing different besides button, right? compared to 246?
3. Acer AL2616Wd - 25.5" - not a lot spoken about this... why? seems great? wtf is it?
4. Planar 26" - obviously.. the best one but its 300 dollars more than either of these. newegg has no ETA or anything on when it will get new ones in. CDW slapped me in the face with a personal quote that is 982.... plus tax, plus 20+ dollars shipping. i get taxed 8.625% so that's huge. sux.
5. Cant think of anything else.

I'm looking for this to work with 1:1 mapping over DVI.
Need Blacks and near blacks to show up during a movie
Need text to look superb.
Need this thing to work in a dimly lit room for movies.
Would be good to have it auto adjust without zooming/full (ew). I want black bars vs. pulled out picture or heads chopped off.

anyone help?
 
bestthreadeverig3.gif


I am laughing so hard right now. Oh how I love irony. I will seriously cry if Kyle ever bans this guy.

There is irony because I want technical data and panel manufacturer info of the viewsonic and acer? o_O

The post doesn't say, "can a 6year old plz give me their opinion if this panel looks kool or not".

or

"Can a 40 year old man that has no idea what they are doing with computers and can't distinguish from blurry and non-blurry text tell me what panel to buy"

I want to know the panel manufacturers and model numbers, I don't need ANY SUBJECTIVE DATA because the forum is overrun with people that have no idea what they are doing or people that have only owned 1-2 LCD's and think their 20inch 500contrast widescreen is the greatest thing on earth. Or worst of all, people that buy gateway 24's and LG246's and make 50 posts saying how great they are when they suck. Don't kid yourself, there is a reason the LG is relatively cheap and there is a reason it was discontinued pretty quickly. The coating sucks and the picture is blurry. Once again, I need TECHNICAL DATA and manufacturer names, not advice from those people. If you happen to know more than a best buy employee then feel free to post, if not then nobody cares!

Maybe I should have worded it differently and kept it to 1 sentence to keep the idiot haters away like "DOES THE FUCKING VIEWSONIC HAVE A SAMSUNG TN PANEL, IF NOT THEN WHAT IS IT?"
 
AL2616WD, according to behardware a Samsung A-PVA wide gamut panel.. no input lag data though..
 
AL2616WD, according to behardware a Samsung A-PVA wide gamut panel.. no input lag data though..

According to samsung such a panel doesn't exist in 25.5".

Also it's highly unlikely Samsung would manufacture a 27" and a 25.5" and not even release a 25.5" with their own brand name.

= it's probably A-MVA but nobody really knows.
 
They will have a staff of 3 people and the person you talk to will barely know how to turn on a computer much less provide you with technical data on panels, you're lucky if they even speak english.
 
And you know that because you already tried. Oh wait....seriously, the sarcasm aside why not at least try? The worst that could happen is you don't get an answer but that's no worse than where you are right now. This whole forum is full of idiots anyway right? :p Given that 'fact' why even bother asking here :rolleyes:
 
Because some guy in china will take the panel apart and 1 out of 1000 forum readers will read chinese and know what panel it is.
 
thats like completely.... a model that has not be reviewed here... that's a bit random :)
 
Because some guy in china will take the panel apart and 1 out of 1000 forum readers will read chinese and know what panel it is.


Ah, so you basically didn't want to try because you're clairvoyant and know exactly what will happen in the future plus you're impatient and wanted to order asap...although I'd guess it's more the latter than the former.

All the silliness aside for a moment, I was suggesting a completely reasonable way to research your question which it didn't seem you'd tried yet. Twice you rejected this idea by assuming the outcome beforehand. If it was me I would have doubts about getting detailed panel info as well but I'd at least try if it was that important. You're like one of those negative people that just assumes everything will be bad before even trying at all, not very much fun to be around :(

My guess? It's probably P-MVA. It's been in production a good while, maybe Acer upgraded the panel but when was the last time that happened :rolleyes: Acer doesn't seem to be averse to releasing a huge number of models. Then add in the fact that BenQ (who owns or is sister companies with AUO) hasn't released anything new plus the likelihood that A-MVA will demand a price premium leads me to guess it's a P-MVA. There is no mention of any monitors with it yet, just TVs. Going by numbers, a link to A-MVA having very high contrast ratio makes me doubt that the model in question is A-MVA as well.

Good luck with your display, let us idiots know how you like it! ;)
 
With your excellent social engineering skills I'm surprised you didn't get all the info you were after :eek:
 
I can smell a winner, I know the smell every day when I wake up. I think thats what this viewsonic will be. If not, I will list why it isn't and enlighten the unwashed forum noobs.

Imagine
A world without noobs
It's not hard if you try
You might say that I'm a dreamer
But I'm not the only one.
 
See thats just urban myth. If you had ever had a 226bw S panel you would know that TN panels don't suck anymore (if made by samsung). Go to circuit city and look at that new glossy screen 19inch with S panel

http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Sams...84555/catOid/-12965/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do

Probably the best looking LCD I ever seen. They haven't released a bigger one yet in this edition though which sucks.

ALL THIS POOPLAH from a guy who just bought an LG246 24 inch monitor and he's talking about how nice the samsung TN panels are........ROACH IS BIZARRO :D :D
 
For those who dont already know, Roach bought an LG246WPBN lcd monitor, he says the text is blurry blah blah, everyone else loves the panel, it's a PMVA panel JUST LIKE THE BENQ SAME PANEL........AUO LCD.

Anyhow, Roach thinks that TN panels are better.

If you haven't already figured it out folks, Roach is a legend in his own mind :D
 
Hehehehe you forgot to mention he also bought the w2207, a TN panel, and didn't like it and now he want a TN panel again !!

Buy a CRT !
 
From what I've read, the propaganda he spews on this forum is worth nothing more than a good laugh, and it looks like a whole lot of people are laughing.
 
Whoa whoa whoa, back track. Roach now believes the Samsung TN panels are good?! I recall him complaining quite a bit about it...oh, the viewing angles, oh, the woes. Wow, what a hypocrite. And now he's buying the shitty Viewsonic 28" - any logical person should realize that at such a cheap price as that, there will definitely be something wrong with it compared to oh, I don't know, the quality 24" monitors. Not to mention the Viewsonic is butt ugly, especially compared to the Samsung 226BW, which I seem to recall him saying had an ugly bezel. Lol.
 
Hehehehe you forgot to mention he also bought the w2207, a TN panel, and didn't like it and now he want a TN panel again !!

Buy a CRT !

What does the w2207 have to do with anything. Just because w2207 isn't that great doesn't make every other TN that exists equally as bad. How dumb are you people. The 226bw S panel looks ridiculously better in color, contrast, black level, and backlight bleed, just has a shitty case because of the bright blue led light shining in your eyes and abrupt change from black to sliver thats very distracting.

Too many little lame fanboys on this forum. They start crying and stalk you in every thread if you say something bad about the monitor they own. Like 8 already posted in this thread. Wouldn't be surprised if a few of them were actual employees of the companies that make the LCD's. If someone makes a post saying XXXXX panel sucks and it stays on the front page of this display forum for a week or two or even discovered with search function that could cost a company thousands of dollars because this forum is that big. That is probably why there are so many posts saying "wow this blah blah blah is the best monitor on earth". Constantly you see people recommending to buy a gateway 24inch or other crap monitor. Bunch of noobs and scammers.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the point of an internet forum is to have a place where people can share their experiences with each other. The dictionary.com definition is "an assembly, meeting place, television program, etc., for the discussion of questions of public interest."

In the case of Hardforum, those experiences are the experiences we have with the hig tech products that we buy or are interested in, such as computers, HDTVs, and other consumer electronics. People come here to research potential purchases and see what others have experienced, and also to discuss rumors and news about upcoming products and industry trends. This is an enthusiast forum.

Based on the threads that you have posted in, you don't seem to hold the opinions of community in very high regard. If a guy buys his first $200 LCD and thinks it's the greatest thing in the world, then he is allowed to come here and talk about how happy he is with his purchase. Even if it was a crappy TN panel by a third-tier manufacturer, if it made the guy happy and suited his needs then he has a right to support the product based on his opinion. Over time, the collective community tends to form a general consensus on how to answer certain questions. A thread about 6-bit panels versus 8-bit panels, for example, will attract many 8-bit panel enthusiasts as well as people who have had good or bad experiences with the value or performance of their 6-bit panel for their needs. God forbid someone should actually like a product from a company that you don't prefer.

If you don't respect the opinions offered to you to try to help you, then why bother asking here at all? It was apparent from the start that you were biased towards TN and you ended up making a decision that was contrary to the advice of several experienced [H] posters.

Please start showing some respect or you won't be very well-liked here. When you start a thread and put things like this in the bottom of your post

R0achTheWarHero said:
"Let the whining begin
|
|
|
|
\/"
you come across as a total dick. Don't be that guy, for your sake.

How dumb are you people.

Too many little lame fanboys on this forum.

Bunch of noobs and scammers.

Once again, I need TECHNICAL DATA and manufacturer names, not advice from those people. If you happen to know more than a best buy employee then feel free to post, if not then nobody cares!

Maybe I should have worded it differently and kept it to 1 sentence to keep the idiot haters away like "DOES THE FUCKING VIEWSONIC HAVE A SAMSUNG TN PANEL, IF NOT THEN WHAT IS IT?"

Fuck it, I'm rolling the dice on the 28" viewsonic, I hope you all die.
 
Maybe you should leave the house at least once a week -=Antimatter=-, then you won't have a stick up your ass and can tell when someone is joking or not:

"Fuck it, I'm rolling the dice on the 28" viewsonic, I hope you all die."

If you want to be a little conformist sheep and present yourself as some kind of boring high school chess club member thats your choice but don't expect everyone else to. I don't like to present myself as someone who has never done anything more exciting than watch battlestar galactica on friday night television and you shouldn't be encouraging everyone else to live in the same little boring world that occurs in your own mind. Unfortunately these people probably occupy the majority of the population. You can even see it in their display self-reviews. "This monitor is stunning, I was floored". Seriously what kind of ridiculous 1950's terminology is that. Then the next sheep reads it and uses the exact same terminology in their review.

It offends me when people can not only be boring but provide no useful information at the same time in a technical forum. If you're gonna be boring you better be providing a lot of large numbers with decimal places.
 
Maybe you should leave the house at least once a week Antimatter, then you won't have a stick up your ass and can tell when someone is joking or not:

"Fuck it, I'm rolling the dice on the 28" viewsonic, I hope you all die."
Just trying to give some friendly advice, I don't want anybody banned. My interest is in keeping the community here an informative and welcoming place. I hope you enjoy your new monitor, it's definitely big as hell and suits your needs with a fast response time for games. :)
 
im a roach fan now. I read all his posts. :) not mocking him either!

most everyone else is guarded and dull
Guarded and dull because we don't refer to ourselves in the third person...joemama says "gotcha".;)
 
Back
Top