22" LCDs that are YPbPr friendly?

carterman

n00b
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
18
Well, although I have a 23" Samsung LCD HDTV right now, it's only 1366x768, and I'd kinda like something a little more high-res for when I hook up my laptop and/or for some 1080p usage (yes, I know it's not fully 1080p, but I don't mind a little scaling, and I don't want to pay for a 24" 1920x1200). Now, component video support is important to me mostly because of my stupid Wii (I've got my cable box hooked up over HDMI right now, and the 360 over VGA, and my laptop uses VGA as well, but the connection has so much interference from the laptop, it's insane. I'm going to pick up a higher-quality VGA cable than the one I've got now), and I would like to buy a monitor that would support YPbPr input through a VGA or DVI-I port.

Now, I almost bought the HannsG HW223DPB, which comes with a DVI-A to YPbPr cable and supports 1080p, but when I found out that it didn't have HDCP, making it useless to me as I'll need an HDCP-capable DVI-D input once I get a PS3, and I'd rather use DVI for my cable box rather than component, I decided not to get it. Now, I'd like a 22" monitor that supports YPbPr directly because I'd rather not shell out the extra money for a Transcoder, y'know? Also, I'm a cheapass, so I'd prefer to spend as little as possible. Anyone have any good suggestions? Or should I just keep my current Samsung? I mean, it's not bad, but I might actually get some more use out of a higher-res 16:10 display for using my computer, although HDTV and gaming would suck just a little bit having black bars all the time (granted, I used to put up with this on my old 19" LCD TV before I sold it for something bigger, but the downgrade in resolution for computing wasn't worth it)

Also, this monitor won't really be used for PC gaming, and I've got my own sound system, so internal speakers and that kind of junk isn't important. Anyone have any good suggestions? Also, on a semi-related note, anyone have the Sceptre x22wg-Gamer? Any recommendations on that? I've found it for $250, and it sounds pretty cool, especially once I get a PS3 because of the DVI and HDMI ports on it. (man, if only that HW223DPB had HDCP, it'd be perfect for me, though :()

Thanks in advance for your advice. :)
 
22" LCDs are TN panels and those have viewable angle issues, but if you really don't mind...

NEC's LCD22WMGX meets your requirements. It accepts 1080p, despite being a 1680x1050 display. It's going for around $350. NEC's links to retailers is here.
Newegg has it for $330, Provantage has it for $350, Buy.com has it for $358. I only linked Newegg because they have pretty pictures that show you all the inputs on the display.

I own the 22WMGX's bigger brother, the 24WMCX. Other than the whole TN panel viewable angle problems, it's pretty good. It has three zoom settings for every input - Expansion (maintain aspect ratio), Full (fill the screen), and Off (1:1). I've only had two issues with it:
  • It'll occasionally put 16:10 input into a 4:3 window. When I exit a game on my PC that was 4:3, sometimes the monitor reverts to a 1920x1200 display that only shows on the center of the screen. To clear it I just have to set the desktop to 1680x1050, then put it back to 1920x1200.
  • When I was watching the extras on Hellboy Director's Cut Blu-ray over my PS3 via HDMI, they didn't show properly when the input was set to Expansion, I got the 16:9 input in a 4:3 window that stretched to fill the whole screen top-to-bottom. Full made it look better, but it was 16:10 instead of 16:9. Off made it a small 16:9 window in the center of the screen. The PS3 upscales regular DVDs fine, so I don't know why the extras in 480i were an issue. Could be a problem with the PS3's software.
Anywho, that's one option.
 
Thanks for the reply. TN viewing angle issues are not a problem for me as I'm mostly going to be using this monitor straight-on. However, for $350, that's a little outside of my range in the sense that I could pick up a cheaper monitor and a 1080p transcoder for less than the price of what you recommended, and also, I'd like to spend as little extra money as possible by essentially trading a 23" LCD TV for a 22" monitor. It's silly, but 1680x1050 might just be better for actual computer usage as opposed to 1360x768 (some people here just cringed, I imagine), and I can live with black bars. Makes things seem a little more cinematic, anyway ;)

Cost is the all-encompassing factor here, if a good 22" monitor is a bad idea financially, then I'll just live with my 23" Samsung. I wish I could just buy that stupid HW223DPB, that's everything I want except for the stupid lack of HDCP. :(
 
I feel like I'm going insane trying to choose the right monitor. Finding a monitor that supports 1080p and component as well as HDCP (shaking fist at HW223DBP, argh!) is turning up much like the hunt for Bin Laden thanks to manufacturers' inability to consider the usage of non-16:10 aspect ratios, inability to list every display they support, and no mention of whether or not they support YPbPr video or not. I seem to randomly see mentions of it (I saw one in a thread on the Sceptre x22wg-Gamer, where someone mentioned something about a DVI-Component cable?), and I have to think that there's more support for this than I think. Maybe it's also me being cheap, but then again, trying to spend as little money as possible in replacing my 23" Samsung 16:9 is kind of the modus operandi here since even I'm not convinced I should do this, but using a friend's 22" monitor, I was impressed with the size and resolution, and it strengthened my resolve. OVERDRAMATIC!

Of course, if I would just learn to stop cheaping out on stuff I buy, I wouldn't have these problems. Then again, if I cheaped out, I wouldn't get to buy as much stuff, now would I? Hopefully this post is substance enough to get someone to notice and slap some sense or my perfect monitor into my face.

On a related note, I should really get into the field of consumer displays, if only because I feel like if I knew what I was doing, I'd do a much better job. I dunno. Maybe there's a good reason all this stuff is so weird in the monitor business...
 
Back
Top