2.5" External Enclosure (For a IDE Drive)

Format _C:

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Jun 12, 2001
Messages
4,207
What's a good one to get? I'm looking for one that uses one USB port (Alot of the ones I see use two, One for power and one for data)
The drive I'm going to be using in it a Seagate 2.5" IDE 160GB. I want one that either has a USB-B or a mini USB-B (The one most cameras use)
Thanks
 
vantec makes some pretty good ones, but honestly even the generic ones work. Ive had some no-name one with a 30gb drive in it for over 3 years.
 
I have seen ones that use the standard Mini 5 Pin USB-B but they all come with a USB Y cable (for two plugs) My drive I'm going to be using says Max 0.487A I know the USB Spec says 500MA max so my drive just makes it. I also have plenty of those Mini-B cables around my house so I can probably use a different cable since my drive draws less then 500MA
 
Last i read, 160gb drives or larger usually need the supplementary power, either in the form of a 5v DC wallwart or a usb Y cable (the cable that uses two usb slots). It's the initial spinup that draws the most power, and even 2.5" laptop drives can sometimes need a full 1amp of power upon spinup. I have an 80gb laptop drive that won't spinup without the supplementary power for example (7200rpm)

And since you're using a 160gb drive you may have to pick your poison, a 5v DC wallwart, or a USB Y cable. The USB Y cables aren't so bad imho... depending on how strong your USB voltage is you might only have to plug in one connector anyway.

The $5 generic enclosures on ebay are often just as fast as the name brand enclosures (i own several different ones, all of them 2.5").

If you have any further questions go ahead and shoot :)
 
Just bought one of These and I hope the drive works without the extra plug (Doesn't really bother me though as I have plenty of USB ports) I was just thinking ahead when I bring it to a friends house as he has an E-Machine that only has 6 USB ports and they are all used by his stuff (External Drives he's a storage freak)
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
That one should work fine.

None of my enclosures ever needed that plastic "anti-short-circuit" layer so you can probably exclude that, if anything your drive would run warmer with it installed.

If you decide to test it out using just one USB connector, be sure to have your ear close to the drive, if it fails to spin up it'll make a very faint squealing noise, that's how you'll know if you need to plug in both USB's.
 
Last edited:
One last question. If the drive fails to spin up with one usb will it hurt or damage the drive?
 
I have a 250gb passport that spins up every time with only 1 usb, and a maxtor 160gb that came with a y cable that works fine with the single passport usb cable. It almost seems to me that it is the cable in question. This is my experience anyway.
 
Back
Top