1k down the drain? P4 EE bent pins!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

poopman

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 24, 2001
Messages
160
Now I pulled my fresh new P4 EE out of the box to find that about 8 pins on the outer row were bent inwards and it would not fit properly into the ZIF Socket. Now I got the retail version so I have a 3 year warrenty as well as the newegg extended warrenty, but being the hardware savy I decided to try and "manipulate" them back into a proper line.

I succeeded in moving them back was able to get the cpu to eventually sit in the socket. Now I haven't turned on the machine because I haven't finished building it and the cable management.

How likely do you think I'm hosed? I've done this before with a an Athlon and it worked fine, I guess I'm just more paranoid because this proc cost 1k.

-Poops
 
y bend the pins back and use a damaged processor? doing something like that could possibly void warranty, im not sure about the policy though. if the pins are bent who knows what else is screwed up. i wouldnt have bought a p4ee to begin with, but since u did its stupid to return it for -15%. 150$ out of 1000.
 
Hehe.

First whatever you do post back here when you are finished!

Second, I would say that if the pins are surface mounted you should be fine.


I however wouldn't risk it!
 
I would just RMA it if it came with broken pins, better to wait then take a chance.

I once bent my pins in a heatsink accident, but was able to bend them back no probs, so if there straight and it goes in the stock you should be allright, however, as I mentioned above, a $1000 chip, I would RMA just in case. Also.. why did you buy an EE!!! :confused:
 
I'd expect more quality out of a processor that costs $1000~ :rolleyes: :(

And another thing, I think spending 1k on just the CPU alone is a waste. Unless you are filthy, filthy rich, then that is another story...
 
Alright guys, how bout we forget why I bought it. I did because I could and wanted to...and that's more then enough of a good reason for me.

How bout we focus on the question at hand :)

The pins weren't broken, just bent inwards a little bit, just enough to make it not fit properly in. I used a very small flat head screw driver to individually move the pins slowly and carefully back in line. I then inserted the processor at a 45 degree angle and the pins all lined up and the processor fell in (no force). I locked it down and put on the heatsink.

I have a feeling it will be fine...but I am still a bit over curious just cause of the money I payed. I'd rather not wait through the RMA process for a new proc...plus you can't return it, newegg policy on P4 EE's (if they did, everyone would buy them, test them and send em back).

-poops
 
no you cant return them, but you can exchange them for the same product.
 
My new P4 2.4C proc had bent pins too. While bent pins shouldn't be a problem in most cases, my proc gave up the ghost when I put it through the Prime95 torture test. My comp refuses to boot or anything now. Time to RMA.

You paid $1000 for it. It might run fine, but with that kind of investment, you'd really want the proc to come non-damaged.

Join me as we RMA!
 
Well he already bought the P4EE and he can't get his money back so he'll just have to live with the mistake of spending $1,000 for a processor.

I would definately RMA it. $1,000 is way to much to keep something that was damaged even if it works now. Newegg's RMA process really doesn't take that long and if you call them you may be able to get them to go ahead and send you a new one while they are waiting on getting that one back. They did that for me on a case i sent back cause of a dent.
 
You're such an idiot, Ben-mod. Don't ask stupid questions like "why did you buy an EE!" Instead, realize that a lot of people on this board aren't 16-year-old kids....we're well out of college....we have good jobs...money....and we like to spend it BECAUSE WE CAN. :eek:

-kjb
 
Originally posted by StanleyJobson
what is a p4 EE?

Its a Pentium 4 Extreme Edition. Its essentially the same thing as a Xeon chip. Its only difference from the normal Pentium 4's is 2mb of L3 cache.
 
i had bent pins on a couple of athlons i've had and i have very carefully bent them into postion and the cpu worked fine. now i am super lazy and i hate sending things back if it means my computer being down for any extended amount of time. but i also havent ever spent $1k on a cpu either lol :p
 
Originally posted by freecableguy
You're such an idiot, Ben-mod. Don't ask stupid questions like "why did you buy an EE!" Instead, realize that a lot of people on this board aren't 16-year-old kids....we're well out of college....we have good jobs...money....and we like to spend it BECAUSE WE CAN. :eek:

-kjb
I don't care HOW rich I am, I'll probably never spend $1000 on a processor. But I understand there are those who do.
 
Originally posted by wesmaster
i had bent pins on a couple of athlons i've had and i have very carefully bent them into postion and the cpu worked fine. now i am super lazy and i hate sending things back if it means my computer being down for any extended amount of time. but i also havent ever spent $1k on a cpu either lol :p

Dont you still have the current rig your sig or another pc to use till you can RMA the processor?
 
Yes, I have the current rig in my sig...just itching to use the Radeon 9800XT, 2 gigs of Ram and Duel WD 10k SATA drives...

But Alas I must say that NEW EGG ROCKS. I called them and explained the problem and the guy was like "well we can't cross ship, but I can give you a full refund, you can re-order it, I'll bump the shipping to overnight and I'll add the extended warrenty back on the new drive".

That is what I call customer service. I'm so glad I do business with them. You all were right, if you spend 1k on a proccessor you should get it perfect, no reason to mess around.


BTW, I am out of College and I do have a very nice job and am at a point where I can spend 3k on a computer if I feel like it. I save a ton of money for the future, but what fun is life if you don't do crazy shit every now and then? Just my thoughts...
 
I have an idea. connect the power-supply, put in some ram and a video card and see if it boots. That way, if it doesn't boot you know it doesn't work and you won't have to rely on a bunch of suck-asses who only want to give you sh!t for spending your hard earned dollars.

Just because you don't have a G to drop on a CPU doesn't mean everyone who does is a sucker. This applies to everything except that jackass with the $10,000 desk :D
 
Originally posted by poopman
...BTW, I am out of College and I do have a very nice job and am at a point where I can spend 3k on a computer if I feel like it. I save a ton of money for the future, but what fun is life if you don't do crazy shit every now and then? Just my thoughts...

well said, I agree ;)
 
for 1k i'd be paitient enough to send it back and get one in perfect condition.
 
Per the rules:
Absolutely NO FLAMING OR NAME CALLING, this is grounds for immediate removal of your posting privileges.
The guy asked for advice on what to do about bent pins, not a purchase evaluation.

Keep in on topic and eliminate the off topic flaming and thread crapping or this thread will be locked.

B.B.S.
 
Originally posted by BlindedByScience
Per the rules:

The guy asked for advice on what to do about bent pins, not a purchase evaluation.

Keep in on topic and eliminate the off topic flaming and thread crapping or this thread will be locked.

B.B.S.
has anyone else here noticed how much better the mods here then any other forum. i mean geez im impressed at how much they catch and how fast they catch it. good job BBS and the rest
 
Intel has Also awesome support. I would rather deal with Intel. They were super proffesional with me. I sent a buncho' Intel cpu's to them and they all came back very fast. Once I asked for a P3 heatsink arm (they break easily) and i had one next morning at my doorstep and I live in Ontario Canada. Pretty impressive if u ask me. Once they are ready to ship, your Processor is gona get to you uber fast.

Just my $0.02
 
Well as I said, I RMA'd it cause it isn't worth it to spend that much money and not have a perfect proc :)
 
The fx51 sweetness that could have been had.... ;)

Since the metal on those pins is now significantly weakened, I would rma it and get a new one.
 
<rant>Sorry, but don't you see that this is an omen? You wasted too much money buying that processor...return it and get an Athlon64 3400+ instead...same performance half the cost. Serves you right.</rant>

I wouldn't risk using it. Those pins are probably weakened. Intel will definitely replace it - just take em up on it and get a replacement. For that kind of money, don't take shit.
 
Originally posted by Mad_Pyro
<rant>Sorry, but don't you see that this is an omen? You wasted too much money buying that processor...return it and get an Athlon64 3400+ instead...same performance half the cost. Serves you right.</rant>

The whole idea was to return it and get a BETTER working processor lol :p .
 
Originally posted by cupavi
Intel has Also awesome support.

They are really good.
It took me less than a week around Jan. 4 to get my 2.6C RMA'ed and that's including UPS' two day slacker fest invovling the delivery.
 
Originally posted by poopman
Alright guys, how bout we forget why I bought it. I did because I could and wanted to...and that's more then enough of a good reason for me.

How bout we focus on the question at hand :)


thank you, i'm tired of seeing people bitch about other people buying something that's ungodly expensive (EE, for example :p)

but, as with the other posters, i would definately have RMA'd it, i mean, if they (whoever the hell "they" is) bent the pins, who knows what else has happened to that poor proc...
 
<rant>Sorry, but don't you see that this is an omen? You wasted too much money buying that processor...return it and get an Athlon64 3400+ instead...same performance half the cost. Serves you right.</rant>

why would you say something like that even after a mod was here...the guy already made his purchasing decision...some people are just more comfortable getting an intel product...some trust there long history of reliability seeing as how its based on a xeon which is the ultimate in stability this is important to a lot of people. I give you props poop for doing something even though others don't think its "cool". We should all be mostly geeks here arn't we used to taking our own path now and again? Whats the big deal about being differnt? Someone puts a window on a case and you say its "mad ownzer creative" but they buy one product you wouldn't and you don't like him. You were right too its a 1,000 processor you deserve perfection but accidents happen good thing you bought from a company like newegg and intel to back you up.

Just my ought-two.
 
Originally posted by rally9x
why would you say something like that even after a mod was here...the guy already made his purchasing decision...some people are just more comfortable getting an intel product...some trust there long history of reliability seeing as how its based on a xeon which is the ultimate in stability this is important to a lot of people. I give you props poop for doing something even though others don't think its "cool". We should all be mostly geeks here arn't we used to taking our own path now and again? Whats the big deal about being differnt? Someone puts a window on a case and you say its "mad ownzer creative" but they buy one product you wouldn't and you don't like him. You were right too its a 1,000 processor you deserve perfection but accidents happen good thing you bought from a company like newegg and intel to back you up.

Just my ought-two.

My advice comes couple with my opinion - and I didn't name call or the like - didn't flame either - merely offered suggestions.:p
 
Poopman, hopefully you have better luck with the RMA'd P4EE.

I'd be interested in getting some overclocking results from that CPU. :)
 
It will work fine, my friend did the same thing to his 3.2c and I laughed at him, and bent em back and it worked fine.

As for your Warranties and Extended Newegg Warranty, they do not cover bent pin's, so they wouldn't help you anyways.

Why would you buy that extended warranty anways, you plan on keeping that P4EE for longer then 3 years?

/IoWnZa
 
Originally posted by poopman
Well as I said, I RMA'd it cause it isn't worth it to spend that much money and not have a perfect proc :)
Agreed. If I had the jack and bought an EE, and it came mangled, I'd RMA the sucker pronto.

Get it running, and let us know how schweet it is......:cool:

One of the first "retail" Intel P4's I got was packed in the Intel clamshell. I wasn't smart enough at the time to know the way to open those damn things is to lay them on your bench, and work your way around the perimiter of the package, breaking the seals with a wide, flat, screwdriver at which time, the package opens right up. No, I just "went for it" and when the sucker popped open.....I threw that poor 1.6A across my garage.....:eek: I was so embarrased that I just quietly bent the pins back into line....and it worked fine. Lesson learned, trust me on that one....

Good Luck - B.B.S.
 
Originally posted by BlindedByScience
Agreed. If I had the jack and bought an EE, and it came mangled, I'd RMA the sucker pronto.

Get it running, and let us know how schweet it is......:cool:

One of the first "retail" Intel P4's I got was packed in the Intel clamshell. I wasn't smart enough at the time to know the way to open those damn things is to lay them on your bench, and work your way around the perimiter of the package, breaking the seals with a wide, flat, screwdriver at which time, the package opens right up. No, I just "went for it" and when the sucker popped open.....I threw that poor 1.6A across my garage.....:eek: I was so embarrased that I just quietly bent the pins back into line....and it worked fine. Lesson learned, trust me on that one....

Good Luck - B.B.S.


Hahaha I did the same EXACT thing when I forst got my 1.8a P4, ripped the packaging open with my hands and the cpu flew out like it was in a sling shot, I had to bend back about 20 pins:D

A lesson learned on opening Intel CPU packaging:)
 
Originally posted by Carnival Forces
thank you, i'm tired of seeing people bitch about other people buying something that's ungodly expensive (EE, for example :p)

but, as with the other posters, i would definately have RMA'd it, i mean, if they (whoever the hell "they" is) bent the pins, who knows what else has happened to that poor proc...
I bet the guy who handles returns wanted a new proc...so he bent the pins a little, and when poop sends it back, he'll ship out a new one, bend the pins back, and pop it in his own box:D

Either that, or sell it to a friend for full retail:rolleyes:
 
Use the barrel of a .5mm mechanical pencil to bend pins back in place when you need to. Works like a champ and usually keeps them very straight as opposed to other means.
 
Originally posted by FrgMstr
Use the barrel of a .5mm mechanical pencil to bend pins back in place when you need to. Works like a champ and usually keeps them very straight as opposed to other means.
....damn. That rocks.....:cool: Sure beats my scribe and magnifying glass and.....much swearing.

Kudos, Kyle - thanks.

B.B.S.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top