1920 x 1200 IPS screens

Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
35
Hey guys, my first post here. Glad I found this place.

I'm not going to build my next dream machine until the parts I want are out, but I figure I can get started by buying an LCD screen. I've been looking around and would like some variation on the IPS theme. S-IPS, AS-IPS, I'm not sure. I want a 1920 x 1200 monitor (probably around 24"), and when I assemble the brains they will be powerful enough to play games at that resolution. It's hard to find IPS screens though, as TN's are all over. PVA and MVA both have disadvantages that I don't want to deal with as well, although they're of course higher quality than TN. So far I've found:

NEC MultiSync LCD2490WUXi

Apple Cinema HD Display 23" flat panel - I am not sure if this is IPS but I heard that Apple makes or made IPS at one point.

Dell used to or still does make IPS screens but I'm not sure if they were/are 1920 x 1200.

I heard LG makes them but their website doesn't seem to be too specific on what type of panels the different models use.


There've got to be others. From browsing around both this forum and the intorwebs, you guys seem to know more about monitors than any other forum I've been able to find, so I've come to you for help. Thanks in advance.
 
I believe the NEC is the only 24" with an IPS panel. But it's only sold in the U.S. They also make a 26" IPS LCD too that is available world wide.
 
Unless they did a recent refresh the 23" apple is a several year old panel.
 
Sweet, thanks for the info guys.

I checked out the Planar PX2611W, it looks nice but I can't find where they say it's an IPS model. I looked it up and it costs only $880, which is far below what the NEC is, I think. Anyway, on the Newegg page where they're selling this Planar screen the review says it's an H-IPS screen. Not sure how that differs from S-IPS or AS-IPS, I'm assuming it's another company's variant on the IPS technology...?

Also Hazro makes a 24" monitor that I hear is IPS (HZ24W). Apparently this company basically makes LCD screens.


If I opt for a 26" screen, which hadn't even OCCURRED to me to think of since it's so big, will the pixels look abnormally large or anything? My buddy who lives upstairs uses an HDTV that wasn't meant as a monitor and its resolution is stretched too much for how big it is, which is why it's a TV. Has anybody seen one of these 26"-ers, do they look stretched at all?
 
Pixel pitch isn't as good on the 26"s as it is on the 24"s, but it's nowhere near as bad as 36"+ LCD TVs.
 
Sweet, thanks for the info guys.

I checked out the Planar PX2611W, it looks nice but I can't find where they say it's an IPS model. I looked it up and it costs only $880, which is far below what the NEC is, I think. Anyway, on the Newegg page where they're selling this Planar screen the review says it's an H-IPS screen. Not sure how that differs from S-IPS or AS-IPS, I'm assuming it's another company's variant on the IPS technology...?

Also Hazro makes a 24" monitor that I hear is IPS (HZ24W). Apparently this company basically makes LCD screens.


If I opt for a 26" screen, which hadn't even OCCURRED to me to think of since it's so big, will the pixels look abnormally large or anything? My buddy who lives upstairs uses an HDTV that wasn't meant as a monitor and its resolution is stretched too much for how big it is, which is why it's a TV. Has anybody seen one of these 26"-ers, do they look stretched at all?

I think pixel size is about the same as a regular (Non Widesreen) 19" LCD monitor, should be fine.
 
Sweet, thanks for the info guys.

I checked out the Planar PX2611W, it looks nice but I can't find where they say it's an IPS model. I looked it up and it costs only $880, which is far below what the NEC is, I think. Anyway, on the Newegg page where they're selling this Planar screen the review says it's an H-IPS screen. Not sure how that differs from S-IPS or AS-IPS, I'm assuming it's another company's variant on the IPS technology...?

Also Hazro makes a 24" monitor that I hear is IPS (HZ24W). Apparently this company basically makes LCD screens.


If I opt for a 26" screen, which hadn't even OCCURRED to me to think of since it's so big, will the pixels look abnormally large or anything? My buddy who lives upstairs uses an HDTV that wasn't meant as a monitor and its resolution is stretched too much for how big it is, which is why it's a TV. Has anybody seen one of these 26"-ers, do they look stretched at all?

I have the 26" Planar and have enjoyed it. The pixels aren't abnormally large unless you sit too close. But then again, that's pretty much the same with any of them. If you have to sit closer than 2 feet, it may be a problem.
 
NEC LCD2490WUXi and Hazro HZ24W are pretty much the only 24" S-IPS around

There's a couple of 26" models as mentioned, also including the NEC 2690WUXi and Hazro HZ26W
 
I think pixel size is about the same as a regular (Non Widesreen) 19" LCD monitor, should be fine.

Only if you think a regular 19" LCD is fine. I certainly don't . 19" LCDs look incredibly pixelated to me. You can't make subjective judgments for other people.
 
Well, for what its worth, I have a 27" Dell at 1920 x 1200 and actually think the pixel size is great. I gave my older 20" Dell that runs at 1600 x 1200 to my g/f and when I look at it now, I think the print is way too small. Its just a matter of taste and your vision.

LouP
 
I have the 24" NEC. It is a H-IPS monitor. Best LCD *reasonable* money can buy at the moment in my opinion. Make sure you get NEC's hardware calibrator and the software to go with it as well. I also got a 6500K 90CRI bias light from www.cinemaquestinc.com for mine. ;)
 
Sweet, thanks for the info guys.

I checked out the Planar PX2611W, it looks nice but I can't find where they say it's an IPS model. I looked it up and it costs only $880, which is far below what the NEC is, I think. Anyway, on the Newegg page where they're selling this Planar screen the review says it's an H-IPS screen. Not sure how that differs from S-IPS or AS-IPS, I'm assuming it's another company's variant on the IPS technology...?

Also Hazro makes a 24" monitor that I hear is IPS (HZ24W). Apparently this company basically makes LCD screens.


If I opt for a 26" screen, which hadn't even OCCURRED to me to think of since it's so big, will the pixels look abnormally large or anything? My buddy who lives upstairs uses an HDTV that wasn't meant as a monitor and its resolution is stretched too much for how big it is, which is why it's a TV. Has anybody seen one of these 26"-ers, do they look stretched at all?


the planar is an S-IPS panel and the NEC 2490 is an H-IPS panel. the reason the NEC is more expensive is because it has a 12 bit hardware LUT and can be hardware calibrated with special software/hardware while the planar cannot.
its marketed towards graphics guys. not sure what your looking for your monitor to do.
 
Did a little more looking around based on what you guys said. H-IPS seems to be an advancement over S-IPS, and both are better than plain IPS. I emailed Hazro to find out about their 24" screen, since many people claim it's H-IPS, and the other half claim it's S-IPS. It is an S-IPS screen. Apparently LG-Phillips owns the H-IPS technology and hasn't released it to many people. ToastX of these forums says "H-IPS panels have less spacing between the pixels and a slightly higher contrast ratio, and H-IPS panels don't have the sparkly look that S-IPS panels have. Other than that, they're similar." The only current screens that are H-IPS:

NEC LCD2690WUXi........................($1126.99)
Mitsubishi RDT261W 26″ LCD..........(don't know where this is sold)
Planar PX2611W[2].........................($879.99 on Newegg)
Aluminum 24" iMac.....(but I don't think you can buy the screen separately)

I don't want to settle for an S-IPS if I can get an H-IPS... less space between pixels is a good thing.

@ mike_j_johnson: Is NEC's hardware calibrator a device or a download?
 
The calibration kit is a USB hardware device and software. You HAVE TO buy this if you are going to exploit this fabulous monitor's potential. You will be able to have the hardware calibration unit automatically calibrate the monitor to sRGB spec. It will then generate an ICC file for you to pop into the Windows Color Manager or whatever it is called in Vista (I cant look since I am at work). Basically...once you calibrate the monitor, then it is good to go and you dont need to touch it ever again.

You can also turn off HDCP and scaling in this monitor. Then you can turn off scaling in the nvidia control panel (cant do this if HDCP is on). Whats this mean? It means that you can play older games at their native resolution without scaling. It also means that things like the BIOS POST screen will not be scaled (at least mine doesnt, but I also flashed my video card BIOS with one that has a non-native panel switch turned on).

Anyways...I'm probably going off on too much of a tangent. Trust me...this monitor rocks if you are after accurate images for games. I'm not a FPS guy so I could care less about LCD ghosting/lag (never noticed any by the way).

I have owned both a 24" Samsung 244t and a 24" LG. This NEC monitor kills them. :D
 
The calibration kit is a USB hardware device and software. You HAVE TO buy this if you are going to exploit this fabulous monitor's potential. You will be able to have the hardware calibration unit automatically calibrate the monitor to sRGB spec. It will then generate an ICC file for you to pop into the Windows Color Manager or whatever it is called in Vista (I cant look since I am at work). Basically...once you calibrate the monitor, then it is good to go and you dont need to touch it ever again.

You can also turn off HDCP and scaling in this monitor. Then you can turn off scaling in the nvidia control panel (cant do this if HDCP is on). Whats this mean? It means that you can play older games at their native resolution without scaling. It also means that things like the BIOS POST screen will not be scaled (at least mine doesnt, but I also flashed my video card BIOS with one that has a non-native panel switch turned on).

Anyways...I'm probably going off on too much of a tangent. Trust me...this monitor rocks if you are after accurate images for games. I'm not a FPS guy so I could care less about LCD ghosting/lag (never noticed any by the way).

I have owned both a 24" Samsung 244t and a 24" LG. This NEC monitor kills them. :D

true, the NEC is the mutt's nutts, in a class by itself for image quality.

as another poster said, NEC monitors suck. they show you how inferior other lcd's are:D
 
Doesn't the Planar have the same panel as the NEC though? I found some other forums where people were saying that. Although, apparently the Planar doesn't have:

12 bit LUT's
COLORCOMP
UDRA certification

And the NEC has a much better warranty (but I heard Planar does free exchanges if you have dead pixels or something). What do these three things do for the NEC to make it better than the Planar?
 
The calibration kit is a USB hardware device and software. You HAVE TO buy this if you are going to exploit this fabulous monitor's potential. You will be able to have the hardware calibration unit automatically calibrate the monitor to sRGB spec. It will then generate an ICC file for you to pop into the Windows Color Manager or whatever it is called in Vista (I cant look since I am at work). Basically...once you calibrate the monitor, then it is good to go and you dont need to touch it ever again.

Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't one of the big advantages of the NEC monitors the ability to calibrate the monitor internally with the Spectra View package. Once you do this you don't need to load a profile on your computer at all. It is internally profiled.

Also one missed advantage of the NEC screen not mentioned is the True Wide polarizer. Which makes viewing angles and contrast even better/more consistent.
 
Yes, the monitor is calibrated/profiled internally when you use the calibration kit, but it also produces a color profile just in case you have "color aware" applications (I do not believe I even have any color aware applications anyways). I use this color profile in Windows Color Management just to be on the safe side ;)
 
That sounds like quite a fancy monitor. If I end up getting it looks like I will need that hardware calibrator to get everything out of it...

Ok, the NEC has these things, and the Planar DOESN'T have them:

12 bit LUT's
COLORCOMP
UDRA certification

BUT they use the same panel. How different can they be?
 
BUT they use the same panel. How different can they be?

Different control circuitry for the panel. The NEC and Planar both use the LG Philips LM260WU1 panel. The Planar doesn't have the LUT, etc. This probably reduces the 'input lag' a little.
 
That sounds like quite a fancy monitor. If I end up getting it looks like I will need that hardware calibrator to get everything out of it...

Ok, the NEC has these things, and the Planar DOESN'T have them:

12 bit LUT's
COLORCOMP
UDRA certification

BUT they use the same panel. How different can they be?

Don't forget internal hardware calibration, if you get the kit. Extremely handy IMO, because it works with everything, not just color aware apps and you don't need to load config file or anything.

Don't forget True Wide polarizer for even better viewing angle contrast. I wish I kept a link to the comparison picture (I think Toastyx did the compare, but I can't find it), but the difference is quite pronounced, with NEC looking sharp and contrasty and the Planar looking hazy in comparison.

IMO they are about as different as can be. In most cases I just go by the Panel, but NEC adds so much here, it is almost a no brainer to spend the extra and get the NEC. I tend to keep monitors until they die. They outlast systems. It is the one item I don't have much qualms about dropping a extra money on.
 
Do you need to get the kit when you first buy the monitor or can you buy it later?
 
the calibrator is sold seperately from the panel. You can buy it at any time.

Two questions I have is if the calibration needs to be redone regularly or if it's a one off process? If the latter, are their any companies that will rent one? $350-400 is alot to spend for something I'll only actually need to use once.
 
Oooh.... yeah, that's a bit much for something I'll use once. I feel like I could adjust it decently well using my eyesight. If I can't detect a difference with my eyeballs, then tiny adjustments a $350-400 device would make wouldn't seem to matter much.

What exactly are these 12-bit LUT and COLORCOMP things though...? Anyone?
 
The 12 bit LUT calibration doesn't squash some color tones like 8 bit calibration does on a video card. For best color fidelity it's the best way.

Calibration is not a one-time thing. Stuff drifts. Some re-cal as often as every week, but only if your job depends on it. For non-pro use, whenever you feel like it. YMMV.
 
I'm taking a serious look at the LCD2490WUXi myself. I thought I saw someone selling the calibration kit along with the monitor.

Anyone have recommendations on who I should buy this from?

I was leaning towards Techdata just because we have a business account with them at my office. *ah, damn. it's out of stock at Techdata*
 
psilocybn said:
I'm taking a serious look at the LCD2490WUXi myself. I thought I saw someone selling the calibration kit along with the monitor.

Anyone have recommendations on who I should buy this from?

I was leaning towards Techdata just because we have a business account with them at my office. *ah, damn. it's out of stock at Techdata*
uh?

the 2490 @ techdata???

i suppose you are not talking about techdata in EU then??
 
Oooh.... yeah, that's a bit much for something I'll use once. I feel like I could adjust it decently well using my eyesight. If I can't detect a difference with my eyeballs, then tiny adjustments a $350-400 device would make wouldn't seem to matter much.

What exactly are these 12-bit LUT and COLORCOMP things though...? Anyone?

no, you cant adjust or calibrate with your eyes, thats why they make the colormeters. they are not small adjustments, they are quite large differences. its not possible to adjust the picture by eyesight the same as a colormeter will. also, its not $350-400, its about 250-270 all together for the colormeter and software.

12 bit Look Up Tables, for color. as stated before, these are pro monitors, targeted for ppl that are into graphic design that need accurate color representation.

if you're doing photo editing, and need to have accurate colors, look into this monitor. if you're not, then keep looking, probably the planar will be your best bet.
 
Ok, so 12 bit Look Up Tables. I did some Googling without much success. Does anybody have a good idea of what these really are or what they do... or perhaps you can point me in the direction of an explanation? Thanks
 
Ok, so 12 bit Look Up Tables. I did some Googling without much success. Does anybody have a good idea of what these really are or what they do... or perhaps you can point me in the direction of an explanation? Thanks

I believe it has to do with color uniformity. With 12 bit LUT, the result is not only a much greater degree of detail in dark areas, but overall uniformity of brightness and color throughout the entire screen. No black crush in shadows and oversaturated colors.

Thats all i can think of it doing at the moment
 
I believe it has to do with color uniformity. With 12 bit LUT, the result is not only a much greater degree of detail in dark areas, but overall uniformity of brightness and color throughout the entire screen. No black crush in shadows and oversaturated colors.

NEC's description of their technology

Selectable and programmable 12 bit gamma including a Custom selection from .5 to 4.0 and preprogrammed DICOM and S-Curve settings. For optimum color selection of 16 million colors form a palette of 68.5 billion.
 
So even without calibration, this 12-bit LUT improves the blacks and prevents crushing and oversaturation? It must be some kind of extra image processing thing, or fine voltage control for smaller areas of the screen? I'm trying to figure out what kind of hardware it is exactly... thanks for the info guys!
 
The 12 bit LUT calibration doesn't squash some color tones like 8 bit calibration does on a video card. For best color fidelity it's the best way.

Calibration is not a one-time thing. Stuff drifts. Some re-cal as often as every week, but only if your job depends on it. For non-pro use, whenever you feel like it. YMMV.
How quickly does it drift though? Mainly I'm fishing for an estimate on how long until it's effectively drifted to the point of being no better than one that never was calibrated in the first place.
 
Most pros won't go past two weeks. It's possible it could drift back to its uncalibrated state, but unlikely. It would depend on how bad it was to start with. And how many hours of ON time. But it could maintain its calibration within 5-10% for 3 to 6 months. There's so many variables.

I know where you're going, why spend $250-$350 on something you use once a year? Thing is, once you have it, you can use whenever you like and only takes a few minutes. But still it's seems like an unnecessary expense. And it is, unless you're a graphics pro or a gifted amateur seeking perfection.

If you can't justify a high quality H/W calibrator, I'd suggest getting a few like-minded friends to share in a 'calibrator' co-op. The sub $100 units are a waste IMO, as they usually only improve things a little and in some cases make it worse. And if you're going to get a NEC xxx90 then you would be wasting your money not to to use the SpectraView software.

The nice thing about the xxx90 series is they are usually pretty good right out of the box, so you could always purchase the H/W calibrator / SpectraView later when you want another monitor upgrade.
 
Back
Top