$1600-1800 Rig, comments?

VandyRob

n00b
Joined
Jul 21, 2007
Messages
4
Im about ready to buy this system I found from a guide. The guide is a little more than a month old and the prices have dropped a little. All I need is the box, no monitor, mouse, speakers etc. My budget is flexible but my aim was to spend arround $1600.

Case: GIGABYTE 3D AURORA w/Antec 650W TP3 PSU - $220
Dont know about this one, ill be living in a dorm room so small and quiet are important
Processor: Core 2 Duo E6600 (2.4GHz) Retail - $221
Cooling: Retail HSF - $0
Motherboard: ASUS P5N32-E SLI - $210
Memory: 2x1GB Corsair XMS2-6400 DHX (TWIN2X2048-6400C4DHX) - $180
Hard Drive: 2 x Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 500GB SATA - $240
Video Card: GeForce 8800 GTS 640MB - $380
Sound Card: Creative Labs Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer - $90
DVD-/+RW: Samsung 18x DVD+RW/-RW SH-S182D - $34
Communications: Onboard LAN - $0
Operating System: Windows Vista Home Premium - $120
Floppy: Generic - $5

Total: $1700 by prices from early June, im guessing now it will be ~$1600

Any suggestions before I buy this? Thanks.
 
First, drop the E6600, as you can now get a G0 stepping Q6600 for $266, or a G0 stepping E6850 for the same price. Both processors make the E6600 somewhat obsolete, as the Q gives you four cores, while the E6850 dual core gives you a stock speed of 3.0ghz w/ a default 1333mhz bus. The E6850's real advantage over the E6600 however is that it should OC much better than current batch E6600s.

To decide which proc to get, evaluate what programs you use now and what you plan to use in the future. If you do any software development, image manipulation, video encoding, or HD playback, plus enjoy RTS games such as Supreme Commander or C&C 3, then the quad is the way to go. If your main goal for the machine is to get as high a framerate you can on modern FPSes, then the dual core will serve you beter.

Second, drop the 680i motherboard in favor of the Gigabyte p-35 DS3R, which should save you about $50 or so. 680i boards are only worth picking up if you're going SLI, and SLI is only worth picking up if you're gaming at a resolution of 1920x1200 or higher and can drop a grand on two GTX cards.

Third, drop the X-Fi card. Creative's Vista drivers are still complete and udder crap, and this is after 9 months when most everything else with the OS (including other drivers) have matured greatly. Perhaps if Creative can get their act together in six months or so, it'll be worth picking up a card then.

Fourth, that RAM looks very expensive. You should still be able to pick up 4 gigs of PC-6400 DDR 2 RAM for just under $200, which would be a better option if you're considering Vista. If you do get 4 gigs of RAM, then be sure to run a 64-bit version of the OS.

Fifth: Avoid PSUs purchased in combo deals, especialy when they're made by Antec. Better PSUs can be had for less, and you won't need a 620 watt supply for that setup. Corsair sells excellent models (manufactured by SeaSonic.) I'd look at the 520watt unit.

Good luck,

Mark.
 
Well I was typing up a response saying almost exactly what Markyip1 said, but my work comp crashed twice, ugh.

With that said, I agree, get an E6850, P35 mobo, different (cheaper) ram, Corsair HX620 PSU, and drop the X-Fi.
 
The guide seems a bit outdated already, lol. The newer antecs should be better now, especially the Trio and Earthwatts lines.

What size monitor do you have?

I, too, agree with everything Mark said (its a scripted response he uses on every thread... j/k).
 
Swap the GTS for a GTX or Ultra with the money saved on the RAM, motherboard, and dropping the X-Fi. Also, you will never need a floppy with modern motherboards and OSs.

There's an XFX 8800 Ultra for $600 - $50 MIR with free shipping at www.zipzoomfly.com right now. Newegg has an eVGA 8800 GTX for $490 after MIR right now, too.

Grab an Antec P180/P180B/P182 if you want quiet. They aren't especially small, but aren't insanely big either, and very quiet. Also grab 4 Yate Loon 120mm fans to replace the included Antec TriCool fans, as they're loud on high and move almost no air on low, where as the Yate Loons are as quiet as the TriCools on medium when they're running full speed while moving more air than the TriCools on high. Should be around $20-$25 shipped for all 4.

You can get a 650 watt single 12v rail Silverstone PSU for $128 here. It's a good quality unit. Yes, the new Antec PSUs are better than they once were... but they're still Antecs, and I'm the sort to "never make that mistake again." Antec has proven to me time and time again that they should not manufacture or even rebrand anything but cases. It's all they seem to be able to do properly.
 
Thanks guys.

As for the processor choice, I play both fps and rts games and care more about being capable of running future games than running today's games at ridiculous framerates. So is a Q6600 going to most likely be better than an E6850 for an fps released a year from now?

Everyone seems to hate the creative card, any other suggestions? Seems lacking to go with onboard sound for this budget.

RAM is something I really know nothing about. Should I get 4 cheap gigs now, or get 2 gigs of quality stuff and upgrade later? Isnt there something about RAM being faster if there's an even number of sticks.

Wow $550 for an 8800 Ultra I might just have to squeeze that in, think it's worth it?
 
Wow $550 for an 8800 Ultra I might just have to squeeze that in, think it's worth it?

Depends on your monitor size... so, I'll ask once again... what size monitor do you have?

Onboard HD Audio is pretty good, actually. If you want an alternative to the X-Fi, theres an X-Meridian card people seem to like a lot.

Even number of RAM sticks usually implies dual channel configuration. Dual channel config usually increases performance by about 10%. Most kits are sold in pairs, anyhow. 4GB isn't really needed right now, but RAM is cheap, so buy it while you can. 4GB should run you about $200. If you're going with a Q6600, all you need is DDR2-800... anything higher will be worthless. If you go with an E6850, then you might want to look into some DDR2-1066 if you want to OC like crazy.
 
If you plan to OC the Ultra is the way to go -- the revised A3 core runs cooler and OCs better than the A2 used in the GTX, though other than that the architecture is exactly the same.

Just stick with onboard sound for now, or grab a Chaintech card ($22 at Newegg) to hold you over until the X-Fi drivers improve... if they ever do.

I'd say grab 4Gb of the least expensive 4-4-4-12 DDR2-800 you can find. It'll be $250 or less, and you won't have to worry about adding any for the foreseeable future.

If you're looking for performance in a year, yeah, grab the quad core, just don't expect it to OC nearly as high as the duals. If you want to OC the quad you /really/ need a better HSF than the stock one. A Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme and a Scythe S-Flex fan or a Tuniq Tower would be ideal.
 
I'll be running it on a 26" lcd tv 720p, and on a 19' dell lcd, i think the highest resolution on the monitor is 1600x1200 (not using both at the same time i mean)
 
With more games supporting multiple cores in the future, and with planned use of other processor-intensive apps, then the Quad core would be the way to go. Also, you should consider how far you plan to OC your processor. If not by much, then definitely grab the quad core. The Q6600's main advantage is cores / price, and the four core advantage can be utilized at stock speed. The E6850, on the other hand, really benefits when you've cranked up the speed to 3.6-4.0ghz or beyond.

Good luck,

Mark.
 
I'll be running it on a 26" lcd tv 720p, and on a 19' dell lcd, i think the highest resolution on the monitor is 1600x1200 (not using both at the same time i mean)

People that say the GTX and Ultra don't give an advantage at that resolution haven't used one. Trust me, the money spent won't be wasted, and you'll be happier with it for longer.
 
Back
Top