1080p playback on a 52" LCD

alphakry

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
470
I currently own the Samsung LN52A650 52" LCD.
I want to hook up my media server to this television and I am looking to purchase a good video card to play HD/Blu-Ray 720p & 1080p files off the hard drive via HDMI.

The PC iteself is powerful (Quad-Q6700, 4GB, Raptor HDD) and it also has a blu-ray drive, so I would use it as my blu-ray player. Ideally, i wouldn't be PC gaming on it as I already own a XBOX360 - but having the option is nice.

I'm trying to figure out the best video card option for me. I would really like to use a high end card with HDMI out - so are there any recommendations? Price range is $300-$400 so the 9800GX2 is out.

I've been looking at the following cards:


SAPPHIRE 100221SR Radeon HD 3870 X2 1GB (512MB x 2)


GECUBE HD3870X2-F3 Radeon HD 3870 X2 1GB 512-bit (256-bit x 2)

BFG Tech BFGE98512GTXOCXE GeForce 9800 GTX 512MB 256-bit


One spec i'm not sure on as far as the benefits of HDMI output is the Stream Processors.
It appears the ATI cards have the NVidia cards quite beat in this area but i'm wondering if it matters for my purposes. I'm also not sure a 1GB card would necessarily be more beneficial for this application then a 512MB card.

I'm traditionally an nVidia fan but am open to whichever choice is best for this application. Thanks for your help!
 
You don't need a high-end card for 1080p playback. Hell, your CPU is powerful enough to do the decoding on its own with ffdshow or CoreAVC. I personally prefer ffdshow over hardware decoding, gives me more control over it.

If you do want to go the route of hardware decoding, any recent card will do (except for G80 core cards like the 8800 GTS 640, 8800 GTX, 8800 Ultra, and the HD 2900 series). Even the HD 2400 Pro will do what you want.
 
why buy gaming cards only for hd playback? get one of the lower end ati cards an hd 34 or hd 36 series card so you can drive 5.1 audio through the card with the hdmi adapter. by the way, stream processors relate to shader performance in games, not hdmi output.
 
thanks for the responses guys.

I'm in a position where i have about $350 to spend as a gift, so i figure why not go for a higher end card anyhow. Especially if i want to try out something more intensive, such as gaming.

But I did neglect to consider how much of a roll the CPU plays into it. The majority of my current collection is 720p H.264 format Matroska .mkv files - so I just want to avoid any possibility of tearing or poor video performance when playing said files on the TV. This is especially true considering my desire to play much larger blu-ray 1080p files also.

The primary requirement here then is a good card with HDMI out - ideally with audio output also so that I don't have to go running a separate optical cable
 
go with an ati card if you only want one connector going out of your computer. the nvidia 9 series video cards can drive audio through the video card but i believe you need another device to jump the audio from a audio device to the card. the ati's have an on-board audio device on the video card. i have rigs that use both ati and nvidia cards, but my htpc will always use an ati card. i would suggest going with a really cheap ati card now, and wait a couple months for their new gaming gpu's to appear on the market. by the way, gaming on a 46in+ panel at 1920x1080 is pretty awesome.
 
thanks for the responses guys.

I'm in a position where i have about $350 to spend as a gift, so i figure why not go for a higher end card anyhow. Especially if i want to try out something more intensive, such as gaming.

But I did neglect to consider how much of a roll the CPU plays into it. The majority of my current collection is 720p H.264 format Matroska .mkv files - so I just want to avoid any possibility of tearing or poor video performance when playing said files on the TV. This is especially true considering my desire to play much larger blu-ray 1080p files also.

The primary requirement here then is a good card with HDMI out - ideally with audio output also so that I don't have to go running a separate optical cable

If you can't wait for the new ATI, then get the
SAPPHIRE 100221SR Radeon HD 3870 X2 1GB (512MB x 2)
otherwise get the HD3650 I pointed out to hold you over.
 
i'd get the best gaming card u can in case u wanna fire up some games on that 4 1/2 foot beast :D
 
Thanks again for the feedback.

renny, any more info on this in-the-middle card you mentioned when it comes to transferring audio from my sound card to 9800 GTX ?

I'm leaning towards that ATI card atm, primarily based on the feedback here. Will probably pull the trigger by tomorrow.
 
the 9 series nvidia cards have a 2pin audio header near the sli connector that either goes to the spdif jumpers on the mobo or a sound card.
 
grab a 3650 or 3450, and check out the 4000 series when ATi releases it. If it is crap the 3800 series will have dropped in price and pick one up, otherwise if its very good pick it up.
 
not really looking to wait here so why suggest a lower card then what is currently available?

what is the ETA of the 4000 series and how much difference is it that you wouldn't suggest the 3800 also?

I don't see much use in playing the waiting game for newer technology without major differences expected and prices staying similar.
 
not really looking to wait here so why suggest a lower card then what is currently available?

what is the ETA of the 4000 series and how much difference is it that you wouldn't suggest the 3800 also?

I don't see much use in playing the waiting game for newer technology without major differences expected and prices staying similar.

we are supposed to get more information about the card in may, maybe even a release in mid-may that is why we are saying wait for the new cards to come out, or atleast see if they are being released or not (some people might sell their 3800 series for super cheap if they plant to upgrade to 4000 series) so either way you win.
 
o forget that. 3800 it is. I'm a beleiver in buying technology when you can use and afford it - otherwise your constantly playing the waiting/catch-up game. There's always something new on the horizon, no sense in always waiting.
 
while that is true (i jumped on the q6600, and 3870s a few weeks ago) i personally would definitely wait for the 4000 series (i bought 2 3870s for $280 i could buy a single 4000 series card that "could" out preform them for a bit more money all while using less power) but in the end its your choice.
 
thanks for the responses guys.

I'm in a position where i have about $350 to spend as a gift, so i figure why not go for a higher end card anyhow. Especially if i want to try out something more intensive, such as gaming.

But I did neglect to consider how much of a roll the CPU plays into it. The majority of my current collection is 720p H.264 format Matroska .mkv files - so I just want to avoid any possibility of tearing or poor video performance when playing said files on the TV. This is especially true considering my desire to play much larger blu-ray 1080p files also.

The primary requirement here then is a good card with HDMI out - ideally with audio output also so that I don't have to go running a separate optical cable

You might as well get an old Nvidia FX5200 as far as graphics performace is concerned. 99% of 720p matroska rips are encoded with x264 L5.1 which precludes them from hardware accelerated decoding. The ATI and Nvidia cards only support up to L4.1 so they won't get accelerated. Therefore is doesnt really matter what video card you get because your video's will be decoded by software.

However, all blu-ray's are encoded in H.264 L4.1 so they are supported by the ATI and Nvidia cards.

Thread describing the issue: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=972503
 
Thanks for the input. I haven't pulled the trigger yet and the nvidia fanboi in me really has me wanting the 9800 series card. Going to do a tad more research
 
if you're into the HD 1080i things , then don't come close to nvidia , ati is pawning in this section
it's just taking very much pressure from the CPU which would ease things
the 2400/2600 would be a wise decision , otherwise 3870x2 . nvidia just can't offer something better for what you're looking for .
 
if you're into the HD 1080i things , then don't come close to nvidia , ati is pawning in this section
it's just taking very much pressure from the CPU which would ease things
the 2400/2600 would be a wise decision , otherwise 3870x2 . nvidia just can't offer something better for what you're looking for .

I agree 100%

while that is true (i jumped on the q6600, and 3870s a few weeks ago) i personally would definitely wait for the 4000 series (i bought 2 3870s for $280 i could buy a single 4000 series card that "could" out preform them for a bit more money all while using less power) but in the end its your choice.

Nice! I would like to know where you found them @ that price.
 
not sure this 3870 X2 was all that it was cracked up to be. seems very finicky due to poor drivers.
 
Back
Top