$100 Laptop Still Too Expensive

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Research firm Gartner says that one hundred dollar laptops are still too expensive for their target market. Putting aside the fact that no one even makes a hundred dollar laptop yet, I think it’s a bit premature to envision kids running around in developing countries with a laptop.

“The $100 PC is still quite expensive for the emerging markets. And that’s just the hardware. There are other implementation costs,” says Annette Jump, an analyst at Gartner who has studied ultra-low cost PCs (ULPCs) like the One Laptop Per Child XO laptop and Intel’s Classmate.
 
they want to send these things to countries where the people need the most basic things to live, like food. the whole concept is so absurd that its astounding.
 
I wouldn't buy a 100 laptop becuase it wouldn't come with the worlds greatest OS vista.
 
You know this whole thing is retarded your better off just setting up a recycling program and giving tax credits to people for their old used laptops. Theirs a million laptops out there I'm sure people would be more than willing to part with for $100. Whats the point of all of this anyways really?
So they can use a word processor? Even if they did get onto the internet I'm sure a lot of it would be blocked by whatever government is in control of their third world country. Not trying to be an ass but even Wealthy countries do this. I think the rest of the world is more concerned about getting food or fresh water than having a friggin laptop. Fuck what a joke.
 
If they stopped adding more and more stupid features then maybe they could have made it closer to their goal of a thirdworld laptop instead of a Toys R Us gadget. I knew this would happen when they kept delaying it and adding extra crap that makes it more expensive and more appropriate as a commercial product for rich kids.

they want to send these things to countries where the people need the most basic things to live, like food. the whole concept is so absurd that its astounding.
How is food going to solve any problems? Education is what these people need so they are able to support themselves later. Give a man a fish and he eats for a day, teach a man how to fish and he eats for a life time.
 
How is food going to solve any problems? Education is what these people need so they are able to support themselves later. Give a man a fish and he eats for a day, teach a man how to fish and he eats for a life time.

I hope your kidding otherwise I'd just go hang myself. Yeah so the kid who can research how fast his nation is killing themselves off or the toll aids is taking on their country while he starves to death sitting in front of his hand cranking laptop. With probably no real phone or even internet connection for miles (especially not one free) Unless you go to a hotel where whites might stay and not let any of the locals in. P.S. Who's teaching this kid? Who's raising this kid? His parents are probably working in the field or dead. Get out of the goddamn suburbs and pick up a national geographic fuck. But hey you'll most likely be one of the people who elects the next president who will be fine invading his country and seizing their oil assets.
These things are as useless as sending aids drugs to Africa. They might get to certain people but won't help stop the root of the problem. Just mask it and make a few rich people feel like they did something.

Cliffs: You need food to live. Not having a piece of plastic that you can't likely even read the words on it.
 
At least they don't have to deal with reality TV as a babysitter

maybe they'll pwn some noobs in counterstrike
 
I hope your kidding otherwise I'd just go hang myself. Yeah so the kid who can research how fast his nation is killing themselves off or the toll aids is taking on their country while he starves to death sitting in front of his hand cranking laptop. With probably no real phone or even internet connection for miles (especially not one free) Unless you go to a hotel where whites might stay and not let any of the locals in. P.S. Who's teaching this kid? Who's raising this kid? His parents are probably working in the field or dead. Get out of the goddamn suburbs and pick up a national geographic fuck. But hey you'll most likely be one of the people who elects the next president who will be fine invading his country and seizing their oil assets.
These things are as useless as sending aids drugs to Africa. They might get to certain people but won't help stop the root of the problem. Just mask it and make a few rich people feel like they did something.

Cliffs: You need food to live. Not having a piece of plastic that you can't likely even read the words on it.

If you give a man a fish, you will feed him for the day. If you teach him how to fish, you feed him for a lifetime.
 
I think if you can't afford a $100 computer, then you've got more to worry about than having MySpace and Flickr access.
 
If you give a man a fish, you will feed him for the day. If you teach him how to fish, you feed him for a lifetime.

Give a country food, they multiply and make the problem worse.

Until they get it through their heads that they shouldn't have more kids then they can support there is no helping them. The more you give them the more they need.
 
Give a country food, they multiply and make the problem worse.

Until they get it through their heads that they shouldn't have more kids then they can support there is no helping them. The more you give them the more they need.

haha that's true.
 
Given the recent declines of the dollar, a $100 laptop may not be all that expensive in emerging countries (50 or 60 Euros). I think one laptop per child is a lofty, but unrealistic goal. Obviously the basic needs (hierarchy of needs) should be met first, then resources can be allocated toward getting technology in the hands of these kids. I agree that a recycling program needs to be implemented as well, but the needs of technology in an emerging nation (without a stable power grid, infrastructure, etc...) are different from the technology in use in the US today and it may take more effort to "upgrade" a recycled laptop for use in a developing country, but it would still have a net positive on the environment (possibly balancing out any additional resources used to upgrade recycled laptops). There are no simple solutions, but it is good that we are discussing the needs and the proliferation of technology in developing countries. If our economy continues to tank, they will probably own us some day, and it is good to keep that in mind now...
 
Do they come preinstalled with a bunch of shareware programs like what Sony, and Dell do? LOL that would be fucking sad.
 
I hope your kidding otherwise I'd just go hang myself. Yeah so the kid who can research how fast his nation is killing themselves off or the toll aids is taking on their country while he starves to death sitting in front of his hand cranking laptop. With probably no real phone or even internet connection for miles (especially not one free) Unless you go to a hotel where whites might stay and not let any of the locals in. P.S. Who's teaching this kid? Who's raising this kid? His parents are probably working in the field or dead. Get out of the goddamn suburbs and pick up a national geographic fuck. But hey you'll most likely be one of the people who elects the next president who will be fine invading his country and seizing their oil assets.
These things are as useless as sending aids drugs to Africa. They might get to certain people but won't help stop the root of the problem. Just mask it and make a few rich people feel like they did something.

Cliffs: You need food to live. Not having a piece of plastic that you can't likely even read the words on it.
You clearly have no clue what youre talking about. So with your solution they become dependent on countries giving them food? Then what? Relying on food coming in every week is going to solve their problems? That must be some magic soup if it can solve the "root of the problem" which stems from having no economy and not having the ability to make their own food.

Im not saying stop giving them food, computers are no use if everyone is dead. But they already get food from aid groups, what they need now is education and tools so they can eventually support themselves so they dont need to rely on food aid. These computers get the ball rolling and are infinitely superior to what they currently have in school, when these kids grow up they will be much more educated than their parents and more capable of solving at least some of their problems.

They need much more than just food, with your kind of narrow minded thinking youre just dooming another generation to suffer the same fate of relying on other countries to send them food just to survive.
 
You clearly have no clue what youre talking about. So with your solution they become dependent on countries giving them food? Then what? Relying on food coming in every week is going to solve their problems? That must be some magic soup if it can solve the "root of the problem" which stems from having no economy and not having the ability to make their own food.

Im not saying stop giving them food, computers are no use if everyone is dead. But they already get food from aid groups, what they need now is education and tools so they can eventually support themselves so they dont need to rely on food aid. These computers get the ball rolling and are infinitely superior to what they currently have in school, when these kids grow up they will be much more educated than their parents and more capable of solving at least some of their problems.

They need much more than just food, with your kind of narrow minded thinking youre just dooming another generation to suffer the same fate of relying on other countries to send them food just to survive.

Please to GOD explain to me how a piece of shit lappy such as the things people are sending these kids are going to improve their lives. I would like a more full explanation than 'they just will'. Explain to me how your model of economic and cultural growth works for people living at subsistence level with hand crank laptops.
 
Here is where the argument for these stupid laptops falls apart:
How will it connect to the Internet? “In Africa, a one month subscription to the Internet can run you $200,” explains Jump, adding access is a hurdle even if the device is free.
*from thread article.

You don't need a damn device with no ability to connect to anything. Most people can't afford it, and quite honestly, I doubt most places have access anyway. What you're stuck with is a limited device. Show me the textbooks they are sending these kids in digital format? Show me what they are doing other than fumbling with what amounts to a toy. Internet access is the only thing that would make these potentially useful as learning tools. Might as well send them a damn gameboy instead.

These people need doctors, nurses, engineers, farmers, etc. They don't need IT staff, and won't for a long time.
 
I hope your kidding otherwise I'd just go hang myself. Yeah so the kid who can research how fast his nation is killing themselves off or the toll aids is taking on their country while he starves to death sitting in front of his hand cranking laptop. With probably no real phone or even internet connection for miles (especially not one free) Unless you go to a hotel where whites might stay and not let any of the locals in. P.S. Who's teaching this kid? Who's raising this kid? His parents are probably working in the field or dead. Get out of the goddamn suburbs and pick up a national geographic fuck. But hey you'll most likely be one of the people who elects the next president who will be fine invading his country and seizing their oil assets.
These things are as useless as sending aids drugs to Africa. They might get to certain people but won't help stop the root of the problem. Just mask it and make a few rich people feel like they did something.

Cliffs: You need food to live. Not having a piece of plastic that you can't likely even read the words on it.

You don't know what your talking about.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDzjfat3MRc
 
How about we quit fucking worrying about the people in other countries for a while and fix ours first? :confused:
 
Please to GOD explain to me how a piece of shit lappy such as the things people are sending these kids are going to improve their lives. I would like a more full explanation than 'they just will'. Explain to me how your model of economic and cultural growth works for people living at subsistence level with hand crank laptops.

The schools that use these dont have text books or have very out dated textbooks. Computers easily solve that problem, even crappy ones like these. And learning how to use a computer is an invaluable skill in todays age, even learning basic computer skills is a lot better than never using a computer in your life. It also has a number of applications that teach fundamental child development principles that these kids would never have experienced otherwise.

You cant look at it as how can these computers would improve our education, you have to look at it from their perspective. Their educational standards are extremely low, giving them some US textbooks from the 80's would be a huge improvement for them. These computers immediately bring them up to date with current information and education rather than having the teacher teach things from memory.

These things wont immediately solve their problems, but you have to start somewhere and making more educated and capable adults will help.

That being said I still think they dropped the ball with this computer. The original idea was great, but they kept messing with it and adding more and more crap that serves no important purpose or would end up being impossible to use and just made it more expensive. Still they are better than nothing and are really helping those who do have them, but they arent being utilized by as many people as they should since they got over zealous with features.
 
so ok

i agree that its important for people of developing countries to educate themselves, and become self sufficient...but how?

i mean when they educate themselves, won't they just learn that 1st world nations have been exploiting them and raping their resources and labour while slowly trying to depopulate them?

i mean there are tons of groups that are trying to help, but governments and large corporations are doing the opposite

maybe thats what they SHOULD learn
 
I hope your kidding otherwise I'd just go hang myself. Yeah so the kid who can research how fast his nation is killing themselves off or the toll aids is taking on their country while he starves to death sitting in front of his hand cranking laptop. With probably no real phone or even internet connection for miles (especially not one free) Unless you go to a hotel where whites might stay and not let any of the locals in. P.S. Who's teaching this kid? Who's raising this kid? His parents are probably working in the field or dead. Get out of the goddamn suburbs and pick up a national geographic fuck. But hey you'll most likely be one of the people who elects the next president who will be fine invading his country and seizing their oil assets.
These things are as useless as sending aids drugs to Africa. They might get to certain people but won't help stop the root of the problem. Just mask it and make a few rich people feel like they did something.

Cliffs: You need food to live. Not having a piece of plastic that you can't likely even read the words on it.


You send "free" food so the dictators can sell it. Why do we bother to educate our kids if it is so worthless? If you have kids are you going to let them stay at home all their life without a job? Maybe you are hoping your parents let you do this- hope they dont ever die!

Funny what is considered cruel to our own is OK for those poor people.


And for those people that think it is worthless without internet get a clue! You can put thousands of textbooks on one computer or thumb drive and share between computers. They are already free.


One example of many:
http://www.gutenberg.org/wiki/Main_Page

Life is not over without facebook.
 
The schools that use these dont have text books or have very out dated textbooks. Computers easily solve that problem, even crappy ones like these. And learning how to use a computer is an invaluable skill in todays age, even learning basic computer skills is a lot better than never using a computer in your life. It also has a number of applications that teach fundamental child development principles that these kids would never have experienced otherwise.

You cant look at it as how can these computers would improve our education, you have to look at it from their perspective. Their educational standards are extremely low, giving them some US textbooks from the 80's would be a huge improvement for them. These computers immediately bring them up to date with current information and education rather than having the teacher teach things from memory.

These things wont immediately solve their problems, but you have to start somewhere and making more educated and capable adults will help.

That being said I still think they dropped the ball with this computer. The original idea was great, but they kept messing with it and adding more and more crap that serves no important purpose or would end up being impossible to use and just made it more expensive. Still they are better than nothing and are really helping those who do have them, but they arent being utilized by as many people as they should since they got over zealous with features.

You live in a very eutopic world, don't you? Can you please provide me a few examples where your ideal situation has worked? I'll come back in a few years and check this thread.

Give a man a fish he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish and you can force him to feed you for a lifetime.
 
AMD[H]unter;1032335024 said:
How about we quit fucking worrying about the people in other countries for a while and fix ours first? :confused:

qft.
 
they want to send these things to countries where the people need the most basic things to live, like food. the whole concept is so absurd that its astounding.

I have to admit, I agree.

The basic tenets we need to meet in most of these countries are:

-Clean water (lack of water or disease due to untreated water causes massive deaths across Africa)
-Foodstuffs to eliminate starvation and malnutrition
-Basic medicines and hygenic solutions to prevent and treat simple diseases that are still killers in third-world countries that have been all but eliminated in first-world countries
-Education, to eliminate poverty so that the first three items no longer need to be provided by other countries by making said nations self-sustainable.

Does technology assist in education? Yes; I work as someone providing and maintaining technology in education, so I know about it. However, it is just a tool, and without a good communications infrastructure in third-world countries, I believe we are better off sending book-based resources, and low-tech solutions that can survive possible climate issues, lack of consistent clean power sources, etc., at least for the K-12 segment. We can look at higher technology for students at the secondary education level, and trickle it down as countries become more self-sustaining and can build their infrastructures to the point where it becomes logical to provide it.
 
AMD[H]unter;1032335024 said:
How about we quit fucking worrying about the people in other countries for a while and fix ours first? :confused:
Those who think only of their own house will someday find they have no friends when their house is in peril.

We should look both to our own countries AND to those in need in others; it isn't a this OR that situation. We have no need to be exclusive.
 
this is like the fortune cookie thread of wisdom. people have nothing useful to say so they spit out some fortune cookie crap.
 
Give a country food, they multiply and make the problem worse.

Until they get it through their heads that they shouldn't have more kids then they can support there is no helping them. The more you give them the more they need.

Thank you. All those people who donated money to think they were helping them with food made it worse, not to mention made the people who organized it rich.

Is it just me, or am I the only one who thinks these "cheap" laptops will end up in bot farms loaded with a virus? Either that or they will be used to educate poor countries how to hack computers. I'm sure some will use it for something useful, but I suspect that will be few and far between.

If they can't afford food, they can't afford electricity or internet to run the computer...
 
Can't we all just get along? I see us sending rice, but no seeds. I see us sending laptops, with no books on agriculture, etc on them. I see people giving money to buy water to give, not money to drill wells to give water.

We are in the right "frame" of mind, but yet out of context. I agree, we give to feel good within ourselves, no matter where the money goes, we gave, we did our part.

It is like that Cisco commercial where the kid is out in africa talking to his parents and his mother asks him if he is eating enough. Never mind the millions of people starving that he is there to help, is he eating enough? WTF is wrong with that question?
 
they want to send these things to countries where the people need the most basic things to live, like food. the whole concept is so absurd that its astounding.

QFT, these "laptop for children" charities are definitely not solving any problems....
 
I am not sure of the whole model of selling or giving away these laptops whose specifications seem years old. Speed and memory capacity are limited. However I have heard that they acutally work well.

Sending computers to Nigeria so I can get a flood more scam emails when everyone has access to a computer I will be overwhelmed. :)
 
I also have heard these are great for lights at night because homes do not have lighting.

I would like to see the poor of our country given laptops first though. How about a one laptop per child for Canada or USA?
 
Back
Top